An International Timeline Of False Rape Allegations 1674-2015
Compiled And Annotated By Alexander Baron

 

Click Here For Types Of False Rape Accuser
Click Here To Return To Introduction


April 29, 1674: This case of a Frenchman falsely accused appears in the Old Bailey proceedings so dated.


August 28, 1678: This case from the Old Bailey proceedings sees a married man bringing home a piece of nookie and being caught in flagrante delicto by the lady of the house, who then proceeds to beat the girl, who then cries rape. The reader is invited to compare this case with that of false accuser Heather Atkins - plus ça change !!


August 28, 1678: Another case from the Old Bailey proceedings; a man is cleared of raping a child. Details are scant, but this false allegation could have been made for a number of reasons, including a GENUINE MISTAKE.


March 2, 1686: An alleged rape on this date is heard in the Old Bailey proceedings, and is found to be an attempt at extortion. File under GIVE ME MONEY.


September 10, 1696: With a little help from his brother John, Richard Birchman is alleged to have raped Eleanor Bouchier. In May 1697, he is acquitted at the Old Bailey; all three appear to have been the worse for drink.


October 8, 1715: William Willis is alleged to have raped 14 year old Phebe Shaw. The case is tried at the Old Bailey on December 7, 1715; Willis is acquitted when the defence adduces considerable evidence that this was a malicious prosecution engineered by the girl’s mother.


February 3, 1716: Richard Newall is alleged to have raped Elizabeth Morris. He is tried at the Old Bailey and acquitted on April 11, 1716. This appears to have been yet another malicious prosecution, though it remains to be seen if Elizabeth Morris was solely responsible.


May 31, 1718: Jacob Wykes and John Johnson are alleged to have raped a married woman, Johnson is said to have assisted rather than carried out the actual rape. In July 1718, they are acquitted at the Old Bailey. Married or not, Ann Cooper appears to have been a SERIAL FALSE ACCUSER if not a serial false rape accuser, her motives being entirely pecuniary.


November 14, 1720: Daniel Collins is said to have raped Mary Powell. On January 13, 1721, he is cleared at the Old Bailey; the court was of the opinion that this was an extortion attempt.


January 16, 1754: Jane Darcy appears at the Old Bailey where in the words of Counsel for the Prosecution she pleads guilty to taking part in “one of the most wicked conspiracies that ever appeared before this court”, to wit, extracting money from the wealthy John Delafont under threat of accusing him of rape - a capital offence. The other parties were her husband and a man named William Walker. Her co-conspirators did not appear with her. File this one under both GIVE ME MONEY and NONE DARE CALL IT CONSPIRACY.


October 5, 1754: Benjamin Jones is accused of raping Sarah Robertson. He is found not guilty on January 16, 1755 at the Old Bailey. On October 22, 1755 at the same court, Robertson and her accomplice John Hunt are convicted of perverting justice by framing him. File this one under NONE DARE CALL IT CONSPIRACY.


July 6, 1755: John Baynham is accused of raping the 14 year old Elizabeth Broadben assisted by the widow Sarah Clifton, who is indicted with him. They stand trial at the Old Bailey and are found not guilty. Subsequently, Charles Frederick Wirsanthall is indicted for suborning perjury against the two. On May 28, 1756, he is convicted at the same court. Elizabeth Broadben (spelt here Broadbent) and Rachel Hannet testify against him. A remarkable tale - call it CONSPIRACY.


June 23, 1756: This is a very strange case from the Old Bailey sessions. On April 20, 1757, John Morris stood trial for the rape of Mary Shortney; he was acquitted. On December 7, 1757, there was a second trial: “Terence Shortney, Mary Shortney, Fared Leigh, and Edmund Thomas Warren, were indicted for a conspiracy, for that they did unlawfully and wickedly contrive and conspire together to prosecute John Morris for a rape, pretended to have been committed by him, on the body of the said Mary Shortney, with intent to extort money from him”. All four were acquitted. File this one under CONSPIRACY.


December 27, 1760: This false allegation from Scotland against a Glasgow man named John Finlay which appears to have been made up out of the whole cloth, found its way into a newspaper. This report is extracted from The Decisions of the Court of Session: From Its Institution Until the Separation of the Court Into Two Divisions in the Year 1808, Volumes 7-8. File under POISON PEN LETTER.


May 2, 1763: Mary Heather claims to have been raped by John Medows (also known as John Meads) on said date. He stands trial at the Old Bailey, and is acquitted on September 14, 1763. She stands trial for perjury at the same court, and on January 13, 1764 she is convicted and sentenced to be transported.


August 3, 1768: David Taylor tries to collect a debt from Anne Wingate (and her husband); she accuses him of rape. He is found not guilty on September 7, 1758 at the Old Bailey.


September 12, 1787: John Ince is accused of raping a young girl named Cornelia Winter. He stands trial at the Old Bailey and is acquitted on October 24, 1787. It remains to be seen why this man was accused, probably she was in his company at some point, but from the little information given here, it appears to have been a GENUINE MISTAKE. There are a number of medical conditions that can be confused with child sexual abuse, especially in young girls. That appears to have been the case here, and indeed medical evidence was presented to that effect.


November 8, 1807: John Faden of the Royal Marines is accused of raping Elizabeth Stapleford at his barracks in Portsmouth. The girl tells one of her sisters and her mother about the outrage the following morning, but, inter alia, evidence is given to the effect that had she in fact been raped, the bloke in the next apartment would have heard her cry out. Not guilty, M’lud.

[The above is based on a report in the London Times, March 15, 1808, page 4].


October 18, 1814: James Harris is alleged to have raped Susannah Woodward; the non-victim did not accuse him until she was visibly pregnant. Harris was arrested, tried and acquitted. In March 1817, Susannah Woodward, her sister Sarah and their father the Reverend Robert Woodward stood trial at Bedford Assizes. All three conspirators were convicted, and bearing in mind that rape was capital at this time, they received extremely lenient sentences, he of two years; his daughters of one year apiece. The one unresolved question is who was the baby’s father? It was not James Harris.

[The above is based on a report in the London Times, March 24, 1817, page 3].


October 31, 1843: At the Central Criminal Court, Andrew M’Donough is acquitted of the rape of Margaret Somerville. She was an underage girl (though not underage at that time) who had been employed by him as a nanny/servant. She made a stock charge, namely that he had thrown her to the ground and had his way with her, muffling her cries with one hand while presumably unbuttoning his trousers with the other. Although she delayed reporting, she was examined by a doctor, and her motive or partial motive appears that she had been having sex with a person or persons of ill-repute, contracting some sort of infection, for which she attempted to blame her one-time employer.

There were other people present in the house too when the alleged rape occurred, and it seems inconceivable that had she been telling the truth, someone would not have been alerted.

[The above is based on a report in the London Times, November 1, 1843, page 6].


June 12, 1844: A police officer appears in court at Marylebone, London, accused of raping Rosetta Catherine Bassan. He says the sex was consensual and that she made this allegation because he refused to marry her. The magistrate agrees, but says also that Thomas Smyth is no longer fit to keep the Queen’s peace. He is not the last police officer in this database to have thrown away his career for a leg over.

[The above is based on a report in the London Times, June 13, 1844, page 8].


December 28, 1849: Illiterate farm servant Mary Anne Bennett accuses Isaac Hopkins and Shadrach Lewis of rape. They stand trial at Gloucester Assizes and are convicted; at this time rape was capital, but they were sentenced to be transported for life.

The truth comes out - she had been having consensual sex with Lewis for some time. In April 1851, she is tried for perjury, convicted, and sentenced to transportation for seven years.

This report is from Lloyd’s Weekly Newspaper, August 17, 1851, page 3.


February 19, 1851: Catherine Dunn is indicted for perjury after testifying that she had been raped by her master Mr E.S. Davies. This report is from The Sydney Morning Herald, Thursday, February 20, 1851, page 3. The following month it is reported she was convicted and sentenced to 3 years at hard labour in Sydney Gaol, which was alluded to as a lenient sentence. How times have changed!


September 16, 1854: The Anna Koch case is reported by the New York Times; click here for more.


May 12, 1858: This article from The Hampshire Advertiser, May 15, 1858, page 3, reports on the acquittal at the Central Criminal Court of James Harrison for the rape of mother of six Mary Southeran.


October 27, 1858: The letter here under the heading HALLUCINATION WHILE UNDER THE INFLUENCE OF CHLOROFORM does not concern an actual false rape allegation (unless the dentist alluded to was wrongly convicted) but it is important because it shows that even in the mid-19th Century the hallucinatory effects of substances such as chloroform were known.

As the reader will see, it was published originally in the Louisville Journal of July 9 that year - actually the Louisville Daily Journal. I managed to find an albeit extremely faint copy of this, which may or may not be complete. At any rate, I could not find the actual letter, perhaps the citation is wrong?


August 23, 1859: This is the date of this imaginary offence in Newport, Wales. Catherine Murray claimed the surgeon David Owen had raped her. When he and his servant Sarah Phillips appeared in court, the latter charged as an accessory, it was Murray who ended up behind bars. She was said to have previously falsely accused a soldier of raping her. This report appeared in The Cardiff And Merthyr Guardian, April 7, 1860, page 6. This woman was very likely a SERIAL FALSE ACCUSER.


March 17, 1861: This Australian case sees servant girl Matilda Bulleen caught in flagrante delicto with Emanuel Reed. Probably as a result of that, she accuses him of rape, but the truth comes out at his trial the following month: the two engaged in sex regularly, and on this occasion he stopped by for a quickie. Shame on her. And SHAME her case is filed under.


June 2, 1863: This article which appeared in the Dundee Advertiser, page 6, on said date, reports on an apparent conspiracy to extract money from a Worcestershire clergyman. Or it may have been Mrs Harriet Tyler was simply a HEAD CASE. Whatever, no one appears to have believed her, for obvious reasons.


January 19, 1864: At Maitland, Australia, four men are alleged to have raped a young woman. The tables are turned on her, and she is ordered to stand trial for perjury.


January 13, 1866: An Australian press report so dated makes an observation that remains true today, sometimes little credence can be placed on the testimony heard in rape cases - for both accuser and accused. In this case, a married woman named Greaves accused James Dunne of raping her, saying that she had never been intimate with him. She told her solicitor something different, namely that Dunne was in the habit of staying the night. And they were obviously not playing chess! In his role as an officer of the court, her solicitor drew this to the attention of the bench. Dunne was acquitted.


August 1866: At Chard in the West Country, a young woman deposes on oath that a man named Porter had “acted indecently towards her”. No further details of this false allegation are given, but allowing for the restrained language used in such reports at the time and from the sentence of hard labour - a whole year of it - one can assume that she accused him of probably attempted rape if not actual rape.

This report appeared on the front page of The Canterbury Journal AND FARMERS’ GAZETTE. The full stop is part of the title!


January 5, 1867: In this Australian case, John Lynch is acquitted of the rape of Eliza M’Kay Gunnell, a teenager of loose morals, who clearly had not suffered “the worst possible outrage that a woman can suffer.” An aside here, New Year’s Day appears to be an extraordinarily popular date for false rape allegations.


April 10, 1870: At Philadelphia, Sarah Gore, a married woman, is fined $500 and sentenced to seven years for perjury in the wake of the acquittal of her victim, a man named Weiner. Gore had attempted to blackmail him; in sentencing her, Judge Parson said this was not her first such blackmail attempt, and that some of the others had been successful. File this one under GIVE ME MONEY.


February 19, 1875: William Bell and Philip Routledge face a rape trial at Carlisle where the jurors decide they want to deliberate in spite of the judge, Baron Pollock, suggesting he dismiss the case. They return with a not guilty verdict. The unnamed complainant had been examined by a doctor who had concluded she was not only lying about other matters but subject to hysteria and delusions.

[The above is based the report in the London Times, February 22, 1875, page 11].


November 27, 1877: This is a particularly distasteful case from South Australia involving an extortion attempt; the perpetrator is neither a first offender nor a woman. On said date, George Evans made a false allegation against David Bennett - the details of the case being unfit for publication! On April 3, 1878, he was convicted after a jury trial before Mr Justice Stow, and in view of his quite appalling rap sheet, was sentenced to life imprisonment at hard labour.


April 7, 1881: In this Australian case, Edward Drake is accused by his servant, the 15 year old Margaret Taylor of raping her two nights in a row in her own bed, March 29-30 and March 30-31. This came as a surprise to his wife, and to the other occupant of the house, Miss Tremain. On June 25, 1881, Margaret Taylor was tried for and convicted of perjury. She was given a 12 month sentence.


August 14, 1881: A very brief report from New Zealand. According to The Manawatu Times, August 17, 1881, page 3, Thomas Nees appears in court accused of rape; the medical evidence shows otherwise; he is acquitted.


July 4-13, 1885: The Maiden Tribute Of Modern Babylon

The above is a famous series of articles by W.T. Stead. This was part of a campaign, rightly alluded to by its detractors as a moral panic. Its result was that in England the age of consent was raised from 13 to 16. Notwithstanding Stead’s dishonest methods, the end result was beneficial. There has for some time been a movement to lower the age of consent, including by the homosexual lobby. No surprises there. Hopefully, nothing will come of it.


August 8, 1885: This case from Adelaide, Australia, sees Bridget Fitzgerald accusing a teenager named John Reardon of a violent rape in the street. There was some suggestion this was a case of mistaken identity, but that seems unlikely. At any rate, it took the jury only a few minutes to find the accused not guilty.


September 2, 1886: At Berry Pomeroy in the West of England, teenage fish hawker George Neel is accused of raping Mrs Mary Evans. This is a very strange case which resulted in the acquittal of the accused, the woman having been drunk, but the behaviour of her husband, well...

While Neel and a man called Thomas Harrington (who supported his version of events) do appear the more credible, the remarks of the judge are worth commenting on: “during the 11 years he had been on the Bench he had known more absolutely false charges for rape than for any other offence. As had been remarked more than 200 years ago, it was a charge easily made, but very difficult to disprove.”

[The above case was reported by The Western Times, November 5, 1886].


August 1889: A young girl named Mary Ellen Bond accuses a man called Naylor of rape. He breaks bail and flees to America. The following February, the girl appears before Bradford magistrates where she admits she had been put up to it by her mother to extort money from him. This report is from The Cardiff Times, February 22, 1890, page 2.


October 1889: Albert Henck is sentenced at the Superior Court of San Diego to seven years. The Sacramento Daily Record-Union, March 1, 1894, page 4, reports he has been pardoned by Governor Markham. Not only had the alleged victim lied about her personal circumstances but she had previously claimed to have been sexually assaulted by another man.


February 5, 1890: In this Australian case, Joseph Kiddle is alleged to have raped a married woman named Hannah Malcolm on said date. She had worked for Kiddle for some time. He is arrested February 7 and tried the same month - they didn’t hang about in those days. Immediately on his acquittal he lays an information for perjury, and this too is disposed of quickly. He had wanted only to extract an admission from her that she had lied, which he appears to have obtained.


August 19, 1890: This Australian newspaper report of a court case the previous day sees Kate O’Reilley née Slavin testing the patience of the court when she claims to have been raped by Joseph Martin. She was given short shrift, primarily because she appears to have turned up the worse for drink.


January 1892: Another shocking Australian case. William Henry Taylor is tried for the rape of a young girl named Jane Elizabeth Thomson - a capital offence. The rape is said to have been carried out at Bear Hill on May 23, 1891 and reported June 21, 1891. Taylor is convicted only of attempted rape, and receives the seemingly light sentence of hard labour for 18 months. Seven years and more later, the girl, now known as Jane Morrison, RECANTS. See this article.


December 18, 1893: This is another Australian case. An Aborigine known as Wadgee is acquitted of the rape of Mrs Cadwalder. The non-victim appears to have been ill or recovering from an illness and to have suffered a bizarre hallucination.


January 22, 1894: This Australian case sees a girl named Isabella Maude Cooke claiming to have been raped by John Guerin. It is heard behind closed doors on January 24, 1894, so apart from Guerin’s acquittal, nothing of substance is recorded until 1903, when now known as Mrs Schmarr, she accuses Frederick Mitchell of attempted rape. He is acquitted.


April 5, 1894: This article so dated is from page 3 of The Western Mail; unfortunately, the quality of the scan leaves much to be desired, but the bottom line is that a young girl named Maggie Hughes in the Welsh village of Cymmer had fantasised about being violated by both her own father and his teenage son (her brother). It remains to be seen if this fantasy was entirely her own, but there was no medical evidence.


1895: William Harris of Charleston, West Virginia is convicted of raping an underage girl. Five years later he is pardoned, the girl having testified she was not raped, and that her father had pressurised her into testifying falsely because he had a grudge against Harris. This article appeared on the front page of The Wheeling Intelligencer, July 24, 1900.


June 4, 1895: A report so dated from Australia, three young men indicted for the rape of a girl apparently named Jellman are acquitted when she admits the sex was consensual, but see this report where her name is given as Tillman; her first name appears to have been Isabella. Also one of the names of the accused is given variously as Anderson and Henderson.

This girl may have been a slut, but in those days even sluts could exhibit common decency, probably because they hadn’t been brainwashed by 21st Century feminist victim narratives.


July 27, 1895: A warrant is issued for the arrest of the wealthy Clifton Mayne; on November 11 he is convicted of the rape of 13 year old Elsie Shipton, and on November 23, he is sentenced to 25 years in San Quentin. He is cleared in October 1897 when the alleged victim, her sister Della and their mother admit to perjury.


December 14, 1895: This article is from The Indianapolis Journal, page 5, so dated. A widely reported story at the time, in New York, Barbara Aub had accused Walter Langerman of criminal assault (ie rape), and shortly after his conviction, she recanted. Better late, than never.


April 2, 1897: A short article so dated from the Evening Express (Fifth Edition), page 2 reports that Margaret Wirth appears at North London Police-court charged with perjury, for falsely accusing her former employer, Mr Erhardt, of rape.


April 9, 1899: The wife of Thomas G. Barker is allegedly raped by the Reverend John Keller, or so she tells her husband on February 3, 1901. Barker shoots Keller, but fortunately not fatally. In June 1901, Barker stands trial at Jersey City and is convicted. The Reverend Keller was no rapist, but a man of the cloth has no excuses for ignoring the Seventh Commandment.


November 18, 1900: This is an interesting press report from Australia which points out that false rape allegations - made from purely pecuniary motives - were surprisingly common at this time. It alludes to a number of such cases but one in particular, that of a young miner named Joshua M’Carthy, who appeared in court on November 6, 1900 when he was accused of the rape of a girl named Alice Kelly. The case went nowhere.


November 18, 1900: This is a false allegation of attempted rape, but it is included here because it generated some considerable commentary at the time. At Yass in Australia, a teenager named Ada Webber claimed to have been the victim of an assault by a Mr F.C. McIntosh. The girl appears to have suffered some sort of bizarre hallucination, and one wonders how it ever got to court. The defendant was acquitted in January 1901.


September 6, 1903: At Hillgrove, Armidale, New South Wales, fourteen year old Ellen Hocking has sex with eighteen year old Burgess Boland, (at that time the age of consent in this jurisdiction was 14). Later, she accuses him of rape, but admits under oath that she consented. The defence lawyer alluded to her as a lying young hussy. At that time, Boland could have been sentenced to death. The last execution for rape in Australia was September 26, 1932; in 1911, David Bennett was given a life sentence for rape, but was released after only six years going on to rape again, this time his victim was 4 years old.

[The relevant press report, from Truth, September 20, 1903, page 8, is too faint to include here].


July 28, 1904: At Sydney, Australia, Dolly Leahy falsely accuses a cabman named Charles Smith of rape. He is acquitted. In October, she is back in court, this time as a defendant, charged with theft. This scan is from Truth, Sunday, June 25, 1905, page 1.

The same article reports the case of a young girl named Farrell who is said to have made a false allegation of a serious assault against a companion. It is not clear if this was an alleged rape.


August 31, 1904: In New South Wales, Julia Heston has sex with Alfred Hannam then cries rape. At his trial in late September 1904, the jury is not impressed with her evidence, while another witness for the Crown bolsters the defence case. He is found not guilty.


November 6, 1910: At Perth, Australia, Maud Lipshut is in the company of two men and a woman when she claims to have been raped and robbed. Click here for more.


March 22, 1920: William Edward Moore is accused of raping Eileen Violet Durbin. Who is found to be still A VIRGIN! This Australian case was tried at Darlinghurst Sessions before Judge Armstrong in July, 1920. Unfortunately, the scan of this report is an extremely poor copy.


June 14, 1920: In Duluth, James Sullivan and Irene Tusken visit the John Robinson Circus. Click here for more.


July 9, 1920: In Ward County, North Dakota, Al Reynolds is cleared of raping a teenager. Little information is available, but it is clear that she was not the kind of girl he would have taken home to meet mother. This article appeared in The Ward County Independent, July 15, 1920, page 12 (unnumbered).


September 7, 1921: The actor Fatty Arbuckle is accused of rape by Bambina Maude Delmont. She had been at a party with Arbuckle when Virginia Rappe was taken seriously ill. Rappe died September 9 from a ruptured bladder and peritonitis without making any coherent statement about what had happened. It is clear though that she had not been sexually assaulted by Arbuckle, and appears to have been in poor shape due to her lifestyle, which included extreme promiscuity. Although Arbuckle was not charged with sexual assault he was charged with murder, later reduced to manslaughter. After a trial and two retrials he was cleared of all blame, although his career was ruined.


November 15, 1923: Mamie Snow of Waukegan, Illinois is allegedly raped. She was said to be mentally disabled - ie not right in the head. James Montgomery is convicted the following year, and given a life sentence. In 1949, his conviction is overturned when suppressed medical evidence shows the victim to have been A VIRGIN!


January 20, 1929: At Sydney, Australia, Eugene Spalding and her partner-in-crime Roy Anderson (one of his names) are arrested on a charge of conspiring to falsely accuse Phillip Ryan of rape.


January 6, 1931: Like the two other notorious American cases from 1931, this needs no citations. Dorothy Skaggs, a married white woman, claims to have been attacked, robbed and raped by a Negro in Upton Lane, Norfolk, Virginia in the early evening. The following day, William Harper is arrested on an unrelated assault charge, and confesses. Harper is none too bright, but is found sane on January 12, and a trial date is set for January 15, although it actually opens on January 28. He is found guilty, and on January 29, is sentenced to death. His lawyer moves for a new trial, this motion is granted, and a new trial is scheduled for March 5.

By the time the retrial started, there was literally an avalanche of new evidence, including from W.P. Kidd, the lover of the faux victim! There was also evidence that she suffered from delusions. Harper was found not guilty, and Dorothy Skaggs was indicted for perjury.


March 24, 1931: The notorious Scottsboro case. Because the alleged victims were both white and all the alleged perpetrators black, this is generally given a racial angle, but the bottom line is that the lies of Victoria Price resulted in years of Hell for all concerned. For the complete story of the case, check out this academic website.

Early on in these proceedings, the extremely fair-minded Judge Horton made the following pronouncement: “History, sacred and profane, and the common experience of mankind teach us that women of the character shown in this case are prone for selfish reasons to make false accusations both of rape and of insult upon the slightest provocation for ulterior purposes.”

This is what is commonly referred to nowadays as a rape myth. Having read this far, the reader will probably have already reached a different conclusion!


September 12/3, 1931: On the island of Hawaii, the wife of the American naval officer Thomas Massie claims to have been attacked and gang-raped on her way home after leaving a dance late at night unescorted. This was an extremely controversial case, as much so as the better known Scottsboro case earlier the same year because it led to a VIGILANTE ATTACK that resulted in the murder of one of the alleged gang-rapists. If this press report is too brief, check out the dedicated website.

Be warned, almost everyone who has written about or commented on this case has done so from a racial perspective, so much so that most rad-fems would consider them to be engaging in victim blaming. Thalia Massie died from a drug overdose in July 1963, her death was probably suicide.


May 27, 1932: WRECKED LIVES: The POISON of the BUTTERFLY... is published in the Australian magazine Arrow.

This is a very interesting article that is totally at odds with the perceived wisdom of rape today, ie that it is vastly under-reported and that false allegations are extremely rare. It alludes to a number of outrageous cases.


October 18, 1932: Teenage domestic servant Dorothy Fitchett claims to have been abducted and raped by two men the previous day. Not only that, they robbed her. Even though they didn’t exist. When the truth comes out, Superintendent Campbell of Derbyshire Police is not amused.

This article was published in The Yorkshire Evening Post, October 27, 1932, page 12.


July 23, 1934: A widow named Lily Browning walks into a South London police station where she tells plod a man had thrown pepper in her face. Click here for more.


1940: Wigmore On Evidence is published. At Volume 3, page 460 the reader is told: “The facts are that there exist occasionally female types of excessive or perverted sexuality, just as there are such male types; and that these are often accompanied by a testimonial plausibility which should not be taken at its face value. Only an inquiry into the social and medical history will reveal the degree of credibility. This inquiry the law of Evidence ought to permit to the fullest extent, rejecting the hindrance of rules that were framed without an understanding of these facts.”

Today this is alluded to as a rape myth. As the compiler of this timeline, I beg to differ.


October 27, 1941: At Leesburg, the young Negro Samuel Legions is accused of the rape of a white woman, Mrs Viola Miller. Click here for more.


May 2, 1943: Kingston housekeeper Constance Brown tells PC Willis she was tied up and raped by an army sergeant. She looked unruffled, but as this was three decades before a couple of airheads came up with rape trauma syndrome, our plod thought she was lying. And he was right. When she appeared in court two months later, she was bound over.

This article was published in The Whitstable Times And Tankerton Press, July 3, 1943, page 6.


May 16, 1943: Rosa Drage gives PC Forth a “most graphic and detailed account” of how she was violated by two men. Alas, it is she rather than these ectoplasmic figures who appears at Northampton Quarter Sessions on July 8, 1943. Her excuse for making this false allegation was original, to put it mildly. It remains to be seen if her previous sexual encounter with a teenager was quite as reluctant as she would later make out, especially as she was a married woman whose husband was serving overseas. File this sad case under I MIGHT BE PREGNANT.

This report appeared on the front page of the Mercury & Herald (Northampton), July 9, 1943.


August 12, 1943: Henry Reynolds meets Gloria Stevens at a dance in Penrith, Australia. She misses her last train home, and ends up sleeping in the back of a car. That wasn’t the only thing she did. She accuses him of rape and he stands trial, but the jury clears him in record time.


December 18, 1943: Half of Rape Cases Reported Are Bunk, Police Probes Show - Click here to read.


May 5, 1944: The black American soldier Leroy Henry has sex with a woman at Bath, England, and ends up being sentenced to death. Click here for more.


June 16, 1944: Author Arthur Derounian visits waitress June Kelly at her home. Three days later, a conspiracy is hatched to frame him for rape.

This is a weird one, and for once a man really is to blame. The man who put her up to this allegation was the seventy-three year old Edwin Banta, whose motivation was purely political. Kelly agreed to make a false allegation of attempted rape but had a change of heart. The charge was soon dropped, and on August 3, 1944, Banta was indicted by a grand jury at New York. He was convicted in October.

This one can only be filed under CONSPIRACY.


October 4, 1944: Nellie Scott of Margate makes a false allegation of rape against an airman. She had actually been in the barn with her boyfriend, and they weren’t playing chess, either. She ends up facing trial for committing a public mischief.

This article, which appeared in the Thanet Advertiser and Echo, November 14, 1944, page 2, is the best quality reproduction I can get.


November 14, 1944: This report so dated was published in the Daily Mirror, page 4. Married woman Marian Griffin of Warwick admits to fabricating a rape allegation after having sex with an American soldier. The title says rape, the text says attempted. Whatever, she lied.

In this connection, check out the entry for Leroy Henry, May 25, 1944, (above). Bad girl, Marian.


November 22, 1944: In Birmingham, Dorothy Edwards hooks up with an American sergeant when they are interrupted by a local plod. There is no suggestion of money changing hands, but read between the lines. When her rape allegation does not hold up, she is charged with causing a public mischief.

This article appeared on the front page of The Birmingham Mail, November 27, 1944.


January 9, 1945: Dora Harris appears before a special court where she is committed for trial at Derbyshire Assizes. Bail is refused. She had accused American soldier William Powers of raping her for no apparent reason.

This report from the local press is dated January 10, 1945.


May 25, 1945: This article appeared on the front page of The Deseret News; it reveals an epidemic or at least a substantial outburst of false rape claims against American soldiers in occupied Germany shortly after the end of the Second World War (in Europe).

The spin author Kenneth L. Dixon puts on the claims therein is unwarranted; women are perfectly capable of making unfounded allegations of rape without the direction of (male) conspirators, especially when rape is capital, as can be seen from the Old Bailey cases listed above. Dixon cites three examples of false rape allegations: two girls who were found to be virgo intacta and a woman who was a known prostitute. Doubtless, there were many more.


October 29, 1945: This report from Australia sees Aircraftwoman Audrey Dorwood crying rape because she THINKS SHE IS PREGNANT. When she appears in court shortly she is clearly in no fit state for the military. It’s difficult not to feel sorry for this poor girl; either she had been sleeping around or she had terrible judgment when it came to men, quite likely both.


November 24, 1945: This report from the Australian press, so dated, shows that even in the 1940s, wine, women and sex could be a dangerous combination. Two English naval officers are cleared of raping Dorothy Day; one of them had sex with her, which she appears to have regretted almost at once.


March 9, 1946: Kathleen Vera Johnson Barrett of The Lizard in Cornwall tells a police officer she was the victim of an indecent assault “probably amounting to rape” in her own home by an airman. As she was married with two kids, one might assume she knew the difference between a grope and an actual rape.

She attends an identification parade, but after a second visit to the aerodrome she comes clean: she’d been having it off with a local man named Richards, and was afraid he’d made her pregnant.

When she appeared at the Penzance Quarter Sessions the following May, the judge was understanding, probably a great deal more so than her husband.

This article was culled from The Cornishman, May 2, 1946, page 3. If your eyes are as bad as mine, save it to disk before opening and resizing it.


November 2, 1946: Early on a Saturday morning, a woman is raped in a field by two men, or is she? This speedy retraction shows how times have changed. Was an American woman of 24 really so under her mother’s thumb in 1946?

This report appeared on the front page of The Journal (Milwaukee), November 4, 1946, page.


December 18, 1946: Boy soldier Hector Baldi has sex with a 19 year old girl, who then accuses him of rape. He stands trial at the Supreme Court in Grafton, New South Wales, and on May 6, 1946, a jury takes just five minutes to clear him.

Here is a more detailed report from the local press


November 12, 1947: This is another quaint Australian case: a white man named Leonard Philpott has sex with an Aboriginal woman, and is accused of rape. As the case is about to come to trial, she writes to the court saying she doesn’t want to proceed. Philpott had made the big mistake of denying intercourse had taken place and then admitting it had but claiming she consented. Her version was that she didn’t consent but was too afraid to say no - a feminist classic; his version was that she wanted money for her services and he didn’t want to pay her. Leaving this aside, what rape victim has ever called her violator “so lovely” ??


November 19, 1948: R.A.A.F mechanic Jack Barton has sex with Jane Andrews in a park after a dance. Then he spends the next few months behind bars at Long Bay, New South Wales. When he stands trial in March 1949 at the Central Criminal Court in Sydney, the jurors don’t even draw breath before acquitting him.


November 25, 1948: At Parammatta Quarter Sessions, Australia, teenage carnival assistant Lillian Esther Halyday pleads guilty to a charge of creating a public mischief by falsely accusing three men of raping her. She is fined, ordered to pay costs, and bound over.


September 29, 1949: The tale of a married woman who claimed falsely to have been robbed and raped at Waverley, New South Wales by a taxi driver is reported in The Cessnock Eagle And South Maitland Recorder, October 4, 1949, page 3.


March 25, 1950: A teenage Leslie Frecklington goes to a dance where she meets boy soldier Alan Young. They have sex, and she accuses him of rape. In September the same year, Young appears at Dubbo Criminal Court, New South Wales, where he is acquitted. This article from the local press reports some wise words from Defence Counsel:

“Women are not helpless. They have a voice to scream with — teeth to bite with — fingers to scratch with and feet to kick with”.


May 8, 1950: At Sydney, Australia, Michael Ledwidge meets an unnamed waitress just before midnight. She stays with him until around 4am the next day, then accuses him of rape. He is arrested and held in custody, but shortly she thinks better of it and decides she does not want to proceed. The magistrate is not amused.


January 4, 1951: This is another amusing case from Australia, not because of the false allegation but because of what happened afterwards. Mrs Violet Jean Anna Fortnum-Neale is arrested for drunkenness, and is taken to a police station at Port Melbourne. She claims to have been raped therein by a police officer, John William Shelley, who is promptly arrested by Inspector Stanley Ewart who puts him in a line-up at 5am the next day. The accuser admits she lied, and Shelley brings a civil action against the Inspector for assault and false imprisonment - which he wins. Ewart said he did not see anything unusual about the allegation, and appears to have believed the woman uncritically. That must have made him incredibly popular with his colleagues!


January 31, 1951: Another Australian case, a 16 year old girl claims to have been raped by four armed, masked men. Her lies are uncovered almost at once.


March 2-3, 1951: A slightly unusual false rape story from Australia; a teenage girl and her boyfriend playing stupid games with the police. Earlier press coverage gives more details; although the police were clearly suspicious, they took this report extremely seriously. The bottom line is the girl had missed her curfew.


March 10, 1951: A story from the Australian newspaper Barrier Daily Truth reports on False Rape Stories Told By Three Girls - filed from Sydney, March 9, one is from Guildford where on March 7, an 18 year old told police she had been raped by a man who threatened her with a gun as she walked home from work late. The other false allegations were two weeks previously, and “a few days ago” by a 20 year old.


February 10, 1952: This article so dated from the Australian press is or is based on an interview with/quotes from a senior police officer, Superintendent Delaney. It is about hoaxes generally, including of a false rape report that is already in this database (see entry for March 2-3, 1951 above). More interesting though is a report of a 9 year old boy who claimed to have been assaulted (presumably sexually assaulted) by a man who lured him into a cave. The boy is said to have faked this because he had spent some money that did not belong to him. Believe women and believe the children!


November 8, 1952: In a report so dated, it is revealed that at Ipswich Assizes, Ronald Rowley is cleared of the rape of Elaine Mary Whalley. The medical evidence revealed no sign of a struggle but a sexual encounter.


December 12, 1953: A Spartanburg teenager accuses 2 youths of raping her. Both are arrested, but when the girl is questioned the following day, she says she became angry with them for some reason then made the false allegation. This report is from the The Spartanburg Herald, December 15, 1953, page 9 (unnumbered).


March 19, 1954: This report so dated of American false “rape” accuser Virgil Sumininski is offered in the spirit of sexual equality.


July 24, 1958: This is an extraordinary case. After pleading guilty to “simple rape”, William Lott receives a 5 year sentence. (At that time, aggravated rape was capital in Louisiana). Then something amazing happens. A girl tells police she has been beaten by a group of Negroes who tried to rape her; shortly she admits this claim is false. An assistant DA recognises her name as the victim in the Lott case, a special investigation is ordered, and Lott is cleared; he is pardoned by State Governor Earl Long. This report views best at 75%. File this one under FALSE CONFESSION.


August 14, 1961: Clara Roderick tells Houston police she was kidnapped from San Mateo, California, held for seventeen days, and raped. She had her four year old son with her, but the following day admitted she had made it all up.

This article was published in the St. Petersburg Times (Florida), August 16, 1961, page 11-A.


July 14, 1963: In Canberra, a teenager has group sex with two men and another teen: Robert Hebditch, Cecil Twaddell and the 19 year old Kevin Phillips end up in the dock when she cries rape.

All three were cleared by a jury two months later. The non-victim didn’t impress her 16 year old roommate either.


After Christmas 1964-July 1965: The 50 year old Walter C. Nab is accused of having sex with a 13 year old girl. A medical examination indicates she is probably not a virgin. Nab is convicted, but on December 14, 1966 the Supreme Court of Oregon quashes his conviction, and on January 17, 1967, a retrial is refused. The girl who accused Nab also accused her own father, her grandfather, and Nab’s son. How likely is this? Believe the “victim”.


July 10/11, 1965: After attending a dance at Mirror Lake Junior High School, Florida, Patricia Hardy returns to the Huntington Hotel and tells a roommate she has been raped. The police are called, and the accused youth is arrested. Shortly the truth comes out, she and another girl had gone to the woods with two boys, and...(join up the dots). Patricia Lee Hardy appears in court later that month, is given a heavy fine and a short suspended sentence. This article is from the Evening Independent (St Petersburg, Florida), August 17, 1965, page 8-A.


January 4, 1966: This report so dated in the Ocala Star-Banner, page 2, concerns a false alarm in that Florida city by a woman who was an obvious HEAD CASE. No details are given.


October 19, 1966: A teenager runs into a South Milwaukee apartment block screaming, with her blouse torn. The police are called, but it turns out she staged this rape hoax because she was late home from school. Not only that, she dragged an innocent man into her stupid act. This article was published in the Mikwaukee Sentinel, October 21, 1966, page 5.


January 13, 1967: Shortly after this date, a Lakota schoolgirl accuses Bill Jankalow of raping her. No charges are filed against him, but the story comes back to haunt him in the 1980s when he is Governor of Dakota. Jankalow would have been a controversial character without this specious claim; he died aged 72 in January 2012.

This article from Saratosa Herald-Tribune, October 7, 1983, page 8-A, contains his version, including the claim that he was not the first person this girl had falsely accused.


March 25, 1967: Kidnap and rape story turns out to be false published in The Afro-American, page 13.

The above is a fairly straightforward story. Rather than a rape victim what he have here is jailbait.


June 1967: Corroborating Charges Of Rape

The above unsigned article from the Columbia Law Review is an excellent, in-depth analysis of the need for corroboration. The substance of the author’s claims, that false rape allegations are easy to make and are often made, has not been refuted in the nearly five decades since it was written. Rather, we have seen a concerted and totally baseless worldwide propaganda campaign seeking to persuade us otherwise.

An important point is that corroboration need not be overwhelming, only of the usual reasonable man standard.


November 13, 1967: Kristen Gilbert is born Kristen Heather Strickland. She is known to have made at least one false rape allegation, but the details have alluded me to date. Crying rape is the least of her sins though, because on March 27, 2001, this Angel of Death was sentenced to four consecutive terms of life without the possibility of parole plus twenty years.

One person who won’t be too pleased with this is Lizzie Borden, who is now no longer the most infamous native of Fall River, Massachusetts.


December 22, 1967: The Graduate is released. In this comedy, a young man is seduced by a wilful housewife, who then accuses him of rape. It remains to be seen how many false rape allegations this film has inspired.


1968: POLICE DISCRETION AND THE JUDGMENT THAT A CRIME HAS BEEN COMMITTED—RAPE IN PHILADELPHIA

The above is a very interesting uncredited article from the UNIVERSITY of PENNSYLVANIA LAW REVIEW. It gives several anonymised examples of false allegations and some comment as to the perceived veracity of complainants. Some investigators are said to believe that 80-90% of alleged rapes are not really rapes while one defense attorney suggested that 75% involved some element of consent. Hmm. A pathologist estimated that 85% were not really forcible rapes, which begs the question how does he define forcible?


December 2, 1968: This report so dated from the Prince George, British Columbia newspaper The Citizen, page 2 sees an unnamed 18 year old girl receiving a short custodial sentence for attempting to frame no fewer than four of her peers for rape. Perish the thought.


July 12, 1969: At Canberra, Australia, a teenage girl goes to a party. Later she claims that that night or in the small hours of July 13 she was raped by another teenager. At the petty sessions on August 12, 1969, she admits she had lied. This case was reported by the Canberra Times, August 13, 1969, page 10.


1970: THE CORROBORATION RULE AND CRIMES ACCOMPANYING RAPE is published in The University Of Pennsylvania Law Review.

This is an excellent article. How about this quote? “Women often falsely accuse men of sexual attacks to extort money, to force marriage, to satisfy a childish desire for notoriety, or to attain personal revenge. Their motives include hatred, a sense of shame after consenting to illicit intercourse, especially when pregnancy results, and delusion.”

According to the sisterhood, this constitutes the endorsement of rape myths, if not outright misogyny. If you’ve read this far you will realise how wrong they are. Check out too TYPES OF FALSE RAPE ACCUSER where you will find all of these listed and more.


July 19/20, 1970: A Spartanburg teenager is kidnapped and gang-raped. Or is she? According to this report from The Spartanburg Herald, July 24, 1970, page 11, she was found on the Monday afternoon, crying and babbling incoherently. She said she had been kidnapped on the Sunday night, but she made it all up. Her lies led to the arrest of a 16 year old for rape.


February 19, 1971: This story so dated appeared in the Dutch language newspaper Het Vrije Volk, page 21. A teenager has sex with a man then withdraws her consent retroactively. The Rotterdam magistrate is not impressed.


January 22, 1973: Roe v Wade is decided by the US Supreme Court. Click here for more.


February 27, 1973: At Santa Cruz, Bombay (as it then was), an unnamed woman - a teacher - is allegedly raped by Anthony Lobo and Godfrey Jacob, them and two others. The two named men were convicted of a lesser offence, but five years later, the High Court quashes their convictions.

This report appeared in The Times Of India, May 5, 1978, page 6.


January 31, 1974: The Child Abuse Prevention And Treatment Act is signed into American law; championed by Walter Mondale, this well-intentioned leglisation has caused more problems than it solved.

For a very brief critique of this legislation, see entry for February 24-March 24, 2010.


February 20, 1974: The TV film A Case Of Rape is screened. Although entirely fictitious, this film and later ones have painted a one-sided and largely dishonest picture of the way alleged victims of sexual assault are treated by the police, the courts, and society. You can read what I think of it here.


March 17, 1974: Inez Garcia murders Miguel Jiminez, gunning him down in the street. Click here for more.


May 22, 1974: William Bohannon, Robert Stonestreet and an unnamed juvenile have sex with a woman who is said to have an IQ of 63 and to be mildly retarded. Mildly? This case is sordid in the extreme, and even if this woman wasn’t raped, these reprobates certainly took advantage of her. All three are indicted for rape and convicted, but on appeal, the Supreme Court of Massachusetts orders a retrial.

Leaving aside her contradictory testimony, evidence was adduced that she had previously made false rape allegations - plural; these were excluded by the judge. The retrial led to another conviction, another appeal, and another reversal, by which time the unnamed juvenile was dead. From the available evidence it is difficult to see how any jury would convict considering the continually changing testimony of the accuser. Neither was her clothing torn, which is indicative of consent.

This one can only be filed under ASKING FOR IT. Having sex with a woman who will drop her knickers for a can of beer whether alone or in a group can lead only to trouble, and having sex with a woman whom you even suspect of being mentally defective is a recipe for disaster.


June 6, 1974: A girl claims to have been raped in a storeroom at the Boca Ciega High School. A boy is arrested, and the girl is sent to a medical centre. Later in the afternoon, the girl admits she lied. This report is from a local newspaper, The Evening Independent, June 7, 1974, page 14-A.


September 1974: Rape Trauma Syndrome by Ann Wolbert Burgess and Lynda Lytle Holmstrom is published. Click here for analysis.


September 19, 1974: Two men are arrested by Saratosa police after a 20 year old woman found wandering incoherently tells them she was raped in the apartment of Mark Johnson; Johnson and his friend Frank Pelto are thrown into gaol where they remain until special investigator Al Danielo gets a call from Johnson’s roommate. The non-victim was angry because the two men had not kept their side of a financial transaction. Charges against the two were dropped on November 6. This report appeared in the Saratosa Herald-Tribune, November 7, 1974, page 2-B.


October 2, 1974: Teenager Deborah Kantaeng of Long Beach, California, claims to have been kidnapped and raped by Danny Allen and another man on this date. Click here for more.


October 31, 1974: The phrase “rape culture” appears in Rape: The First Sourcebook For Women by Noreen Connell and Cassandra Wilson. This is generally recognised as the first time it appeared in print, although it was in use since around 1970/71. To see what rape culture really looks like, click here.


January 15, 1975: Rape complaint was false, police discover

The above uncredited report which appeared on page 3 of the London Times speaks for itself. On January 14, Deputy Chief Constable John Woodcock revealed that a young woman who had told Devon & Cornwall Police she had been raped had admitted she had made up the story to make her husband jealous.

She had also complained about her treatment at Torquay Police Station. That complaint appears likewise to have been ill-founded.


April 1, 1975: The 1974 Michigan rape shield statute comes into force, the first such law in the United States.


May 17, 1975: Wayman Cammile is arrested for the rape of 64 year old Alice Mock. Faced with an horrendous sentence, he pleads guilty to lesser charges, and is sentenced to 15 years by a Delaware judge. On November 28, 1986, Alice Mock makes a deathbed confession to Evelyn Burns: the rape never happened. On June 17, 1987, Wayman Cammile is released from prison. He dies from a heart attack three years later aged only 53, a case strange and tragic in equal measure.


June 18, 1975: James Knight of New Haven, Connecticut is cleared of the rape of a 14 year old girl who accused him in March this year. According to his lawyer, this was “a child with problems, a sick girl...” and he was doubtless right on the money. This report was published in The Day (Connecticut), June 20, 1975, page 11.


September 1975: At Lakeland, Florida, a black schoolgirl gives birth to a mulatto baby. As she is way under age, clearly a serious crime has been committed. She accuses her white teacher, Michael Stephenson, who she says raped her in January. Then another girl comes forward - a thirteen year old - and accuses him of raping her on December 27, 1976. However, when it is shown Stephenson was out of town that day, the second girl recants.

Medical and other evidence proves he could not have fathered the child. Eventually, the nightmare ends, and he is completely exonerated.

This report is from the local press.


October 15, 1975: The first edition of Susan Brownmiller’s hysterical Against Our Will... is published. This toxic book (which I read in the early 1980s) is the source for the spurious claim that only 2% of rape allegations are false. For the other 2% claim, see entry for Lipstick at April 2, 1976, (below). It is also said to see the first appearance in print of the phrase “date rape”.

For a critique of the above statistic, see the April 2000 article by Edward Greer.


January 19, 1976: A woman reports being attacked in her home at Scissett near Huddersfield. Click here for more.


March 10, 1976: In Connecticut, Linda Jadwinski tells police she had been raped the night before or 1am the same morning. An investigation determines the rape never happened, and she is arrested. This report is from The Day, March 12, 1976, page 13.


April 2, 1976: The film Lipstick is released; here is my review, and here is a short clip from it, an early reference to the lie that rape is both a vastly under-reported crime and that not only are women given a rough ride in court but most rapists who are brought to trial are acquitted. The reality is of course that rapists are not brought to trial, alleged rapists are, as I pointed out in April 2000.

Incidentally, this film - the aforementioned clip in particular - appears to be the origin of the widely touted claim (by RAIIN for example) that only 2% of rapists are convicted.


May 28, 1976: The women running Britain’s pioneering Rape Crisis Centre have shunned publicity to protect clients. Click here for more.


June 14, 1976: A 21 year old Little Miss Anonymous accuses professional football player Johnny Sample of rape. On June 30, 1976 she refuses to testify before a Philadelphia court after admitting she had lied. The linked report is from the Washington Afro-American, July 6, 1976, page 10.


July 17, 1976: This report so dated from page 3 of the Dutch language newspaper Leeuwarder Courant alludes to Rape turned lovemaking - which will really annoy the rad-fems, but a better translation is probably Girl bows to seducer. Whatever, a teenager had sex with another teenager in public at Maarssen, accused him of rape, then thought better of it. The reader is invited to compare this with the June 10, 2007 entry for Kerry Thomas - one of many such herein.


July 23, 1976: A woman is raped at Rochester, New York. Paranoid schizophrenic Freddie Peacock is framed by John Wernsdorfer, one of the investigating officers. Peacock is eventually exonerated by DNA. The background to the case can be found here.

The victim had and has no doubt that it was Peacock who raped her, but this is far from the first time a rape victim has been so wrong. File this one under FALSE AND TRUE.


November 22, 1976: In the UK, the Sexual Offences (Amendment) Act, 1976 is passed. The accuser in a rape case is granted lifelong anonymity. A terrible law that offends against the principle of open justice.


1976-7: This article by Constance A. Hill was published in the Dusquesne Law Review, Volume 15, 305, pages 305-14. Although it makes interesting reading, it is incredibly venal. Among other things it perpetuates the feminist rape narrative about rape being a vastly under-reported crime. It covers too in depth the erosion of the need for corroboration in rape and sexual offence cases. It also mentions an imaginary disease called sexism.


July 9, 1977: Teenager Cathleen Webb of Homewood, Illinois, claims to have been raped. Click here for more.


November 3, 1977: This report from page 1B of The Ledger (Lakeland, Florida) so dated tells the story of Haines City woman Sally Hullender who told detectives she had been raped by two men; the doctor told them otherwise.

The same article reports a sadder case, a 16 year old girl from Plant City who phoned the sheriff’s office to report being raped in a car on a state road. She was highly intoxicated and obviously not telling the truth. When law enforcement contacted the girl’s mother they were told she was a runaway who had been prostituting herself. The girl was delivered to the mother’s custody. Selling her body is no pastime for a 16 year old.


1978: Florida police officer Christopher Scholz is accused of raping two women. The charges are dropped, and in 1982, after it is determined these allegations were clearly false, he wins a civil rights case against the Broward County Sheriff’s Office.

This article appeared on the Sun Sentinel website.


March 18, 1978: Thomas Moffitt and his two teenage sons Thomas and John are arrested after a teenage girl accuses all three of them of rape. On October 18, the charges having been dismissed, the girl is ordered to be held in the custody of the Department of Social Services for treatment and evaluation. This report is from The Times-News (Hendersonville, North Carolina), November 1, 1978, page 12.

This one can only be filed under HEAD CASE.


April 5, 1978: This false rape claim doesn’t last long. At Newburgh, New York, teenager Lucille Stevens phones Deputy Police Commissioner Frank Navarra and tells him she wants to report being raped by her former boyfriend, one of his officers, on March 29. She claims that last month he had broken up with her to return to his estranged wife, but forced her to have sex first. She agreed to take a lie detector test, and apparently not realising this is junk science, broke down and told the truth while it was being administered. Another case of a WOMAN SCORNED. She was charged with perjury and false reporting. This report is from The Evening News (Newburgh), April 6, 1978, page 3A.


July 14, 1978: Police seal off the village of North Aston, Oxfordshire due to a siege by David Brain. He claimed his wife Valerie was gang-raped by detectives. His wife claimed he beat her up after he accused her of having an affair with a police officer. Which of them do you believe?

This report appeared in the Guardian, July 17, 1978, page 20.


October 10, 1978: This is another famous/notorious case that needs no citations. Greta Rideout phones the police telling them she has just been beaten by her husband John. When they turn up, she claims he had raped her. This led to Oregon v Rideout, the first time in the United States a man was charged with raping his wife (while they were still living as man and wife).

The case came to trial in December 1978; his version was that they’d had an argument over sundry matters which resulted in her kneeing him in the groin. He slapped her, and they ended up making up by making out. She said he had punched her repeatedly in the face and sexually violated her. She had since filed for divorce. A physician said there were signs of forced intercourse but he could not be sure. After Rideout’s acquittal, the two agreed to an amicable divorce. For the record, it has never been legal for a man to rape his wife in the United States anymore than in England; a man who violated his wife either physically or sexually could be charged with an offence - and there are such cases - but forced sex was not charged as rape. John Rideout sold his story afterwards.


February 1, 1979: An interesting report in the Ottawa Citizen, page 77, according to which more than half the rapes in Hamilton were totally unfounded while in Ottawa, only 15 of 54 reports were unfounded. Victims under 16 years of age were almost always assaulted by relatives or acquaintances, while older victims were assaulted by strangers. This is not what the sisterhood tells us. Unlike these hard figures, the claim in the same article that 60-90% of all rape cases go unreported is of course a statistic that has been pulled out of a hat.


May 3, 1979: According to The Pittsburgh Press of May 23, 1979, page A-15, a report of a rape in the city by a teenager, who claimed the assailant was known to her, never happened.


May 23, 1979: Hotel doorman Murray Wentzell has an ugly encounter with a teenage stripper who accuses him of sexual assault. On October 31, 1979, the Supreme Court of British Columbia clears him of rape. This report is from the Prince George newspaper The Citizen, November 2, 1979, page 2.


June 28, 1979: Steven McCarthy picks up a young woman, takes her to a bar, a restaurant a liquor store, a nightclub, and then to the beach where they have sex. On the drive back to Providence, Rhode Island, he is stopped for speeding. His companion gets out of the van and claims he had just raped her. In March 1980, he is convicted of rape and kidnapping, but unusually is granted bail pending an appeal.

On June 15, 1982, the Supreme Court of Rhode Island quashes his convictions and orders a retrial. After accusing him of rape his companion had gone on to accuse another man, and then withdraw the allegation. The trial judge had refused to allow this in evidence.

It beggars belief to think this woman was raped twice in quick succession by two different men.


June 29, 1979: A horrible incident involving two celebrities leads to one of them being charged with inter alia rape by instrumentation. In October, a judge dismisses the sexual assault charge against Jack Nitzsche after Carrie Snodgress gives a more accurate description of what actually happened after her lover caught her in flagrante delicto with an actor named Paul Williams.

Nitzsche received a slap on the wrist for the physical abuse he meted out to her that night, and their relationship continued for another decade and more. Okay, she shouldn’t have two-timed him, but dude, you were ASKING FOR IT.

This report appeared in the St. Petersburg Times (St, Petersburg, Florida), October 23, 1979, page 4A


July 10, 1979: In this article by Sharon Deveau from the Lewiston Evening Journal (Maine), July 10, 1979, page 13, a police officer tells it like it is about false allegations including of rape, many of which he says are REGRET SEX.


December 1979: On September 2, 1980, Douglas L. Caswell rapes a single mother in her own apartment. He appears to have used some force and was lucky to escape with a 43 month sentence, certainly in an American courtroom. At trial he claims the sex was consensual - which it clearly was not - and tries to adduce evidence that his victim had made a prior false rape allegation to the police against another man. In dismissing his appeal, the Supreme Court of Minnesota states that: “The false claim of rape which complainant made to appellant against Wilberg was not made to the police and she did not persist in making it after it became clear that it had negative consequences for Wilberg.”


May 29, 1980: This report so dated from the Prince George, British Columbia newspaper The Citizen, page 12 sees false rape accuser Patricia Stuart branded a COMPULSIVE LIAR. She told police at Saanich, British Columbia she had been raped by a named individual to test her boyfriend’s love. Sadly, she was given a non-custodial sentence.


August 12/3, 1980: Close to midnight, a woman cries “Rape! Rape!” This is another incredible case from Canada. Mrs. Nicole Marie Lukasik alias Cecile Blanche Lukasik was convicted of both perjury and public mischief for which she received a sentence of 45 days plus 2 years of probation, but the Crown appealed, which resulted in her sentence being extended to 9 months. The case ended up in the civil courts with a victory for the plaintiff, the falsely accused and aptly named Ronald Pierre Canada. And would you believe this started as a fairly minor motoring accident? Read the judgment and weep.


September 11, 1980: This report so dated from The Sydney Morning Herald, page 9, tells how a judge halted a rape trial at Parramatta Supreme Court when it became clear the alleged victim had offered no physical or verbal resistance nor tried to escape when she was supposedly being held prisoner at a hotel with plenty of strangers - staff and clientele - about.


November 13, 1980: In 1979, New York City employee Jeffrey Gordon is accused of raping Andrea Cohen. When the grand jury refuses to indict him, he sues her in the New York Supreme Court. The trial is heard without a jury. He won the case, and not by a hair’s breadth either! This report, from the Boca Raton News, page 14A so dated is priceless.


Circa 1981: Judy Owens accuses a staff member of the First Baptist Church of Mineola, Texas, of rape. A meeting is held, which includes the girl’s parents, and it is determined she is not telling the truth. No further action is taken. In March 1991, by which time she is known as Judy Gaumond, she accuses another man of raping her. He is convicted, and his conviction is upheld on appeal. This conviction appears to have been sound, but how would you have liked to have been a juror hearing this case if you had known about the first (false) rape allegation? In this connection, see also false rape accuser/later rape victim Sabrina Dean.


Circa 1981: According to her mother, Lily Place, when Angela Stretton was 14 years old, she claimed to have been raped in Leicester where they were then living. The mother called the police, and the surgeon concluded she had not been interfered with sexually. By the time of the Satanic abuse panic in the Scottish islands, in which she played a major part, Stretton was already a known SERIAL FALSE ACCUSER.


February 16, 1981: In Pennsylvania, gynecologist Panayotis Apostolidis is cleared of raping three of his patients. This is a very interesting case; the rapes were alleged to have been committed between October 1978 and April 1980. Two of his nurses testified they were present during the examinations, so was this a folie à deux, or something far more sinister? This report was published in The Spokesman-Review, February 18, 1981, page B26.


April 12, 1981: There is a disturbance outside a dormitory at the University of Richmond, Virginia. Gary Ribar is one of three students accused of rape by a 14 year old girl. Two days later, he and his team mates are charged. The following month, the charges are withdrawn. Ribar says neither he nor his colleagues left the dormitory. This report is from The Pittsburgh Press, May 27, 1981, page D-4.


May 2, 1981: This is that rarest of sex cases, a woman charged with rape, not a schoolteacher giving a 14 year old sex lessons after school, but real rape. Mary Conteh is accused of violating an 8 year old in her apartment. Even the boy’s mother wasn’t impressed with her son. This report was published in the Evening News (Beacon, New York), November 14, 1981, page 2A, the day after her acquittal.


June 12, 1981: This report so dated says that of six alleged rapes in Okaloosa County, Florida the previous month, four were spurious. One of them involved a woman who prostituted herself then cried rape when her john didn’t pay her. The reader is invited to compare this with the case of Gareth Linekar.


July 25, 1981: In the small hours, a state trooper is called to the apartment of Sandra Nelson, who claims to have been raped. She has no visible injuries, but Herbert Winfield is convicted by a jury after the trial judge excludes what might be called bad character evidence under the rape shield law. On March 11, 1983, the Supreme Court of Virginia reverses his conviction because this excluded evidence shows “Sandra had a distinctive pattern of past sexual conduct, involving the extortion of money by threat after acts of prostitution, of which her conduct in this case was but an example”.


October 1981: Washington County man William Davis is convicted of the rape of Ronnda Baker, who was 14 at the time of the trial. He is said to have raped her several times between August 1979 and March 1981. In June 1985, his accuser recants officially, and in spite of attempts to dissuade her, continues to protest her victim’s innocence. Davis is released in May 1985. This article appeared on the front page of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, June 14, 1985.


November 1, 1981: The publication of the first edition of Michelle Remembers; this is the book that started the modern Satanic panic. Although the claims of its subject, Michelle Smith, have been thoroughly debunked, it has spawned a host of imitators including real life tragedies such as the Bakersfield and McMartin Satanic abuse cases.


Circa December 19, 1981: A student at Lincoln University, Pennsylvania accuses two other students of raping her. Law enforcement are informed and so are her family; before a criminal investigation can be launched, a lynch mob arrives. The resulting fracas leaves six people requiring hospital treatment, then the girl admits she’d lied.

[The above is based on this report from The Afro American, December 26, 1981].


1982: A Spokane woman is charged with obstructing a public servant after filing a false rape report. According to this article from The Spokesman-Review, February 27, 1983, a detective said half the allegations of rape and attempted rape his unit investigates end up being classified as unfounded, or the complainant withdraws the charges.


1982: In California, a woman is said to have made no fewer than 11 false rape allegations. See entry for May 26, 1989.


Early 1982: A girl identified only as Tina claims to have been raped by another juvenile resident at the Whitaker State Home, Pryor, Oklahoma. However, when asked to take a lie detector test by investigators, she admits she lied.

[The above was extracted from The Daily Oklahoman, September 12, 1982, no page given, (accessed here through NewsBank)].


January 1982: A woman claims to have been raped in Amsterdam; later in the year, the public prosecutor declares her complaint to be groundless, according to the Dutch newspaper Het Vrije Volk, September 2, 1982, page 3.


January 15, 1982: T.T. Watson visits a home in which three youngsters are being supervised by an 18 year old. On January 21, he is arrested on suspicion of rape, the 11 year old having told the 18 year old he had violated her without anyone noticing. He stands trial in June, and is quickly acquitted, wisely taking the stand in his own defense. This report appeared in the Gainesville Sun, June 23, 1982, page 1B. Thaddeus Timothy Watson died at his native Gainesville in April 2011 aged only 54, and was well thought of.


January 18, 1982: A Complaint Of Rape is screened. This controversial documentary generated more heat than light, in particular although it showed Thames Valley detectives giving a rape complainant a rough ride, it didn’t show the way they questioned suspects at the time.


March 15, 1982: This UPI report so dated begins: “Calgary police said Monday they are concerned with the increasing number of women reporting unfounded rapes and may consider laying public mischief charges.”

Women and girls like the case alluded to here. What sort of idiot slashes herself across the chest with a razor (quite deeply, apparently) to bolster a false rape claim made because she had missed her curfew?

According to one investigator, Brian Larsen, his unit had recently spent almost as much time investigating fake rapes as real ones.


March 23, 1982: According to this report in the Gainesville Sun (Final Edition) so dated, page 16A, Deputy John Walls was reinstated on March 22 after being cleared of rape following an allegation by a Gainesville woman.


May 11, 1982: Around 2.30am, police in Rhode Island respond to a call from Patricia Clelan of Middletown who says her car was stolen by two men, who had also raped her. There is no mention of a rape kit, and shortly no mention of a rape, because later in the day she speaks to Police Chief Robert Gibson and tells him she wants to drop the charges: no crime had been committed, per se. Except the crime of false reporting, and when she appears in court a few days hence she is given a summary punishment by Judge Anthony J. Davies.

[The above is based on a report in The Providence Journal, EAST BAY EDITION, May 19, 1982, page C-03, (accessed here through NewsBank].


June 1, 1982: This is an extremely rare and bizarre case from Florida of a woman being arrested for rape. Mary West was accused of the sexual battery of a three year old girl. This article appeared in the Daytona Beach Morning Journal, June 18, 1982, page 2B. Reading between the lines, this was a GENUINE MISTAKE.


July 29, 1982: A 12 year old girl tells her mother she was raped in mid-May by Allen Howard, who is a relative. He is also a Philadelphia police officer. Howard is arrested October 14; he is dismissed.

On February 2, 1983 it is reported that he has been cleared. There was no medical evidence. Why do you think that was?

[The above information was extracted from the Philadelphia Daily News, February 2, 1983, Edition 4*, page 12, (accessed through NewsBank)].


September 21, 1982: Police officer’s wife Sheila DeLuca celebrates her 42nd birthday, and around seven o’clock the following morning ends up at a motel with Robert Bissett. Afterwards, they go back to Bissett’s van where around 2pm she murders him, shooting him four times in the head. She tells her husband she was abducted by three men - the other two did exist, she had originally gone to the motel with all three of them. In April 1984, she is convicted of second degree murder, but in 1994 her conviction is quashed and a retrial ordered.

After pleading guilty to manslaughter, she walks free in November 1996, time served. File under PRETEXT FOR MURDER.


October 5, 1982: Police don’t believe rape reports: Data published in The Gazette (Montreal), page B1.

The title of the above says it all. Once upon a time the police were rightly suspicious of any rape victim who didn’t look the part.


November 9, 1982: This is a shocking story that proves not only do even quite young girls lie about being raped but they conspire to do so. At Miami, Florida, Pedro Figueroa is arrested for the rape of an 11 year old girl. The case looks extremely strong because not only does another girl back up her story but a forensic test from the Jackson Memorial Hospital Rape Treatment Center appears to confirm she has indeed been raped. He is indicted, but on December 14, when State Attorney Jeff Feldman takes over the case he notices a serious anomaly with the forensics.

When both girls are re-interviewed on January 3, 1983, the truth comes out: the girl was afraid she would be disciplined by her grandmother for being late. After 58 days, Figueroa is cleared. File under both NONE DARE CALL IT CONSPIRACY and WHAT’S THE MATTER WITH KIDS TODAY?


1982 or early 1983: According to this article from February 27, 1983, a Spokane woman who claimed to have been raped at knifepoint by a man posing as a vacuum cleaner salesman was charged with filing a false report.


1983: Elizabeth Ward has a one-night stand with Bill Clinton, who was then Governor of Arkansas. Like Clinton, she was married, although she was divorced in 1984. In 1981, Elizabeth Ward won the title of Miss Arkansas; the following year she became Miss America. Later known as Elizabeth Gracen, she went on to become an actress but did not achieve the success she deserved.

After the Lewinsky affair, all manner of rumours were circulated about Clinton; there was open speculation that he was a serial rapist, and the name Elizabeth Ward was thrown into the ring.

What she thought about this particular allegation can be seen in this syndicated article from The Gainesville Sun, April 26, 1998, page 8A. Some people have claimed she told her friends Clinton raped her and still insists so in private to this day, but unlike most of Clinton’s accusers, the lady has more class than that.


1983: The Child Sexual Abuse Accommodation Syndrome by Roland C. Summit is published. Click here for more.


January 6, 1983: The Court of Criminal Appeals of Oklahoma reverses the incest conviction of Bennie J. Woods who was convicted of having sex with (ie raping) his own daughter. Read the judgment and about her other false allegations.


January 12-3, 1983: Karen Sorlucco claims to have been falsely imprisoned in her New York City apartment. The man who did this raped and otherwise violated her. Conveniently, she destroys the evidence on January 14, but as she is a probationary police officer this claim does not ring true. On January 17, she reports her alleged rape, but claims the perpetrator was a stranger, and that it happened on January 7. After much more flim-flam she gives her penultimate version of events, she was raped January 13-4 by another police officer, John Mielko; eventually she withdraws the charges. Mielko admits there was sex but says it was consensual. He passes a polygraph, but she has already told so many lies that...more follow.

Unsurprisingly, she is sacked. This is the way it played out in civil court.

There may be an error in the transcript regarding the dates January 12-3/January 13-4. I have found and advised of errors in legal transcripts before, but once they are published permanently they are generally not corrected.


January 17, 1983: At Providence, Rhode Island, Laurie Keenan and another teenager are allegedly kidnapped and raped. Click here for more.


January 26, 1983: Police target falsified reports of sex assaults - click here for more about this story from Rhode Island.


January 28, 1983: A conviction for gang-rape in Scotland is finally overturned 24 years later. Not much information is available about this case as can be seen from the previous link, but the lessons are clear. Having sex - group sex or otherwise - with women who are not right in the head can be dangerous, whether or not as in this case the non-victim has been sniffing glue.


January 31, 1983: A woman is attacked at Charlotte, North Carolina, by the man who becomes known as the Red Light Rapist. He is said to be impersonating a police officer, an amazing achievement for a bloke who doesn’t actually exist. In spite of this, he appears to have attacked two more women.

This report appeared in The Dispatch (Lexington, North Carolina), February 26, 1983, page 1.


Circa February 1983: In separate incidents, a fifteen year old girl has been charged with filing a false rape report, and a warrant has been issued for a woman who allegedly lied to police about being raped, as reported by The Spokesman-Review, February 27, 1983, (below).


February 9, 1983: This report so dated is from the Observer-Reporter (Washington, Pennsylvania), February 9, 1983, page B9.

At Tucson, Arizona, a girl claims to have been raped in broad daylight while a woman ignored her screams. Four days later, she admits the intercourse was consensual but tells the police Mummy would be soooo angry if she found out.


February 27, 1983: This article by Tim Hanson is from The Spokesman-Review, pages B1 & B6. It contains some interesting comment, especially by a detective named Leland Elliott.


March 9, 1983: A teenager hoaxes the entire Boston Police Department; this report so dated is from Lewiston Journal, page 12, yet still they are not convinced!


March 31, 1983: At Ephrata, Pennsylvania, a teenager claims to have been kidnapped at knifepoint from the grounds of her high school and sexually assaulted. On April 6, 1983, the Reading Eagle newspaper reports at page 2 that the girl lied.


April 13, 1983: Democratic politician Lonnie Carr is indicted for the rape of his girlfriend’s teenage daughter. According to the Schenectady Gazette, July 22, 1983, page 9, Barbette McKnight made up the story after staying out late. Carr spent 20 days in gaol before posting bail. In July 1983, he was totally vindicated.


April 24, 1983: A woman tells police she was raped that night in a Melbourne suburb. Her assailant was a stranger. After an appeal, a man comes forward and says he had consensual sex with her. When this is put to her, she fesses up, then obviously realising she is in hot water, she reverts to her original rape claim. Read what happened next here.


May 2, 1983: A teenager from Bradenton, Florida tells a detective she was raped on her way to school. Later, she tells her mother she made it up. This report appeared in the Saratosa Herald-Tribune, June 28, 1983, page 2-BM.


June 24/5, 1983: In the Netherlands, a teenage girl claims to have been gang-raped. The allegation has been shown to be false, now do we prosecute the little minx or what? File under AIN’T NUTHIN’ LIKE A GANG BANG.

[The above is based on this report from the Dutch newspaper NIEUWSBLAD van het NOORDEN, July 5, 1983, page 1].


Summer 1983: Rape Trauma Syndrome by Ann Wolbert Burgess.

The above is an updated and much augmented version of the September 1974 article by the same author, although for whatever reason her co-author has not contributed to it.

It contains the usual statistics which in deference to the author I will say are simply misleading rather than contrived.


August 1, 1983: Police at Gytsjerk announce they are to press false rape and assault charges against a 28 year old woman who claimed to have been attacked on a cycle path and raped. She confessed to the lie but was unable to give a reason. This report

is from the Dutch newspaper Leeuwarder Courant, August 5, 1983, page 16.


August 28, 1983: Kathleen Leona Sanchez of Lakeland tells police she was abducted and raped. The following month, it is reported that someone has been charged in connection with these offences. Her. This article appeared in The Ledger (Lakeland, Florida), September 7, 1983, page 1B.


August 29, 1983: An interesting report, so dated, by Russ Nugent from the Saratosa Herald-Tribune, page 4-B. According to this, of the 37 rapes reported to the authorities since January of that year, 4 were voluntary sex acts, and nearly half were suspect.


September 7, 1983: Ray Buckey is arrested. This is as good a date as any for the McMartin Preschool case. Buckey and the women caught up in this endured years of Hell, him in particular, the rape of young children being one of the least bizarre of the crimes for which they were indicted. Check out the dedicated academic/legal website for the full sickening details.

The related cases of Bakersfield and (Margaret) Kelly Michaels will not be discussed here, but here is an archived video of her 2003 interview with Oprah Winfrey, who appears to have come a long way since her May 1, 1989 interview with Vicki Polin (above). If you have problems playing this clip, try saving to disk first.


November 15, 1983: The Glasgow Herald, page 10, includes a long letter from P.B. Watson, a former senior detective with Strathclyde Police, an extract from which is given below:

 


December 1983: The notorious publisher Larry Flynt sacks husband and wife employees William and Marsha Rider. Then he accuses Mr Rider of raping his 14 year old daughter. After protracted legal proceedings and a six week trial, the Riders are awarded an $8.6 million judgment against Flynt by a Santa Monica jury.


December 27, 1983: The article Sex Claims Dismissed from London’s Alternative Magazine, Dec 27-Jan 2, 1983-4, page 61 reports on a thankfully false paedophile alert in the Philippines. My apologies for the poor quality scan.


January 1984: Teenager Terry Williams commits the first of two murders; Herbert Hamilton was stabbed and battered to death in his own home, then his body was set on fire. On June 11, 1984, he commits murder number 2. Amos Norwood is battered to death, only this time, Williams ropes in his friend Marc Draper. After his arrest, Williams points the finger at Draper and another (totally innocent) individual. Draper is given a life sentence; Williams is sentenced to death for the Norwood murder.

Years later, the anti-death penalty crowd invent an entirely fictitious narrative claiming Williams had suffered years of sexual abuse as a child. The Wikipedia entry for Williams claims the two victims had raped him repeatedly. These people have no shame.

The reader is invited to compare this and other rubbish about the case with the findings of fact of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania.


January 1984: In Gainesville, a high school student is kidnapped and raped; that’s what she said, anyway. Later in the year, the truth is revealed. This article is from the Gainesville Sun (Final Edition), September 27, 1984, page 8A.


January 19, 1984: This article from page 7 of the Glasgow Herald relates to the trial of a particularly odious individual named Kevin Kenneth O’Dowd. Serial rapist O’Dowd was given a life sentence in 2007, but two years later the Court of Appeal ruled “regrettably” that the jury verdicts were unsafe. This was for purely technical reasons. A retrial was not ordered, the original trial having been spread over a period of more than six months.

The allegations about Edward Heath made in the above article were clearly scurrilous and were based on fabricated documents. This is one of the earlier false allegations against the former Prime Minister. Many allegations against politicians, celebrities, etc, are made by people cut from the same cloth as O’Dowd, and must always be treated with extreme reserve. One of the few such allegations that turned out to be true was that made by prostitute Monica Coghlan against Jeffrey Archer in 1986, but a politician having (paid) sex with a prostitute is hardly in the same league as the kind of depravity alleged here.


January 24, 1984: Philadelphia Police correspondence

The above internal letter so dated does not contain any actual false allegations but reports several different types of false allegation.

The reader might like to compare the classifications therein with the types of false rape accuser listed here.


February 19, 1984: Student Alberto Ramos is accused of raping a 5 year old girl at the New York City nursery where he is employed as a part-time teacher’s aide. The alleged rape is said to have occurred two days earlier.

This unusual and disturbing case involves a child who might be described as highly sexualised. Although uncommon, this problem is by no means unique, as can be seen for example from Sexual Behavior and Children: When Is It a Problem and What to Do About It.

In this case, the young girl had also (falsely) accused another child of interfering with her sexually. Serious prosecutorial misconduct led to the conviction of Ramos when realistically no prosecution should have been brought. He was convicted May 20, 1985 and exonerated in 1994.

There is a mistake in this judgment - the former date is given instead as February 19, 1994.


March 5, 1984: This one is both shocking and weird. Two young girls - cousins aged four and five - are taken to hospital where they are found to have been sexually violated. They are named, but will not be named here. The girls accuse Sylvester Smith, who is tried and convicted. The assaults were said to have taken place over the weekend. On December 10, 1985, the North Carolina Supreme Court finds no error, but when they grow up, the girls recant. They had actually been molested by their 9 year old cousin, and their grandmother had pressured them into accusing Smith to protect him, even though he was doli incapax. Smith is cleared finally in November 2004; the real perpetrator ends up serving a life sentence for murder.

This is an AP release and this is part of a report from the Injustice Busters website.

This poor guy can only be filed under FALSE AND TRUE.


April 14, 1984: In Manchester, Jacqueline Berkeley claims to have been raped in a police cell. This text is from the 2013 edition of a book first published in 1991. Out Of Order? Policing Black People was written by a pair of braindead academics. This article appeared on page 3 of the February 26, 1985 issue of the Glasgow Herald, (CITY EDITION). It is clear from this latter that the police went the extra mile to refute this stupid girl’s baseless claims, and who can blame them in this instance?


May 29, 1984: In Australia, teenager Karen Sharp fakes her own abduction. This one can be summed up with the phrase “Rape is not a nice word”.


May 29, 1984: After pleading guilty to arson, a woman is allowed to withdraw her plea on the grounds that a meeting with a psychologist shortly before she was due to be sentenced “unlocked” the memory of two men raping her in her Olathe apartment. Unsurprisingly, no arrests were made in connection with this phantom sexual assault.

The judge swallowed the nonsense of rape trauma syndrome - which does not exist - and sentenced her to probation on a lesser charge.

This report appeared in the The Ledger (Lakeland, Florida), July 5, 1984, page 9C.


June 23, 1984: Steve Carney takes co-worker Karen Winkler for a drive with a mutual friend. Click here for more.


July 1984: The police are called in after the daughter of Michael Wayne Clinebell accuses him of unspeakable crimes dating from June 1983. He is tried and convicted, by which time she is 12 years old. On April 22, 1988, the Supreme Court of Virginia quashes his convictions, and makes the following findings of fact relating to the evidence of his daughter:

“The statements included the daughter’s claims on two different occasions that she was pregnant. These claims were patently untrue and were made in 1983 and 1984 when the daughter was 10 and 11 years of age. The daughter also claimed to have been sexually assaulted by her grandfather and her uncle. In light of her obviously false claims of pregnancy, a reasonable probability exists that her claims of sexual misconduct against the grandfather and the uncle also were false.”


July 1984: Danny Garrels is arrested after a disturbance at his Belleview home, and in the presence of police officers confesses to raping an 11 year old girl. This is a very interesting case because it shows that while you can’t always believe women who claim they’ve been raped, you can’t always believe men who confess to it either. Garrels was tried in July 1985 when he was found not guilty by reason of insanity, but the medical evidence indicated that no rape was committed. It appears that Garrels, who although only in his 30s had suffered a heart attack. He also had a low IQ, and had mixed his medication with alcohol which caused a toxic psychosis - ie had caused him to suffer delusions. This article appeared in the Ocala Star-Banner, July 22, 1985. File Mr Garrels under HEAD CASE.


August 7, 1984: Lesbian lovers Charmaine Pfender and Sara Mae Richardson go for a drive with two Turkish students. Pfender shoots one of them dead; the other manages to escape. Pfender and Richardson bury the dead man in the woods. After their arrest, they play THE RAPE CARD, but the jury is not swayed. Three decades on, Pfender supporters - the usual braindeads - attempt to portray her as the victim, but in dismissing her 1988 appeal, the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania stated: “this man was shot and killed, these two women then tried to bury him, and then chased the other man through the woods, trying to kill him, like a wild animal...This was a wanton killing that arouses no signs of mercy from this Court.”


August 18, 1984: At Haines City, Florida, in the small hours, three young men have sex with a teenage prostitute in exchange for drugs. Then she accuses them of rape. They are tried separately; David Harris is the first to be cleared. Curtis McArthur King is one of those people who never learn; in 2001, he is busted for possession of cocaine. This article appeared in The Ledger (Lakeland, Florida), November 21, 1984, page 2B.

I hate to say this guys, but you were ASKING FOR IT.


September 8, 1984: Ollie Baine of Wilmington is raped at gunpoint by Robert Rice, at least that is what she told the police. Fortunately, her lies are soon exposed, and the poor bloke spends only two days behind bars. When she appears in court later that month, Baine is given a 29 day sentence or $100 fine, a very soft sentence indeed.

This report is from the Morning Star (Wilmington, North Carolina), September 26, 1984, page 2B.


1985: RAPE TRAUMA SYNDROME by Carole Lewis Iles is published.

The above article is from the Missouri Law Review; it examines a number of cases. In the first, State v Taylor, the use of this so-called syndrome in so-called expert evidence led to the reversal of a conviction in what was on the face of it a fairly straightforward case of rape, one in which the victim reported promptly and in which her claim was corroborated by physical evidence - including of a physical assault. In addition to that, the accused did not take the stand.

State v Nobles is even more ridiculous as the victim was nine years old and the accused admitted having sex with her but claimed she had consented. Excuse me!?! Because this so-called expert evidence was admitted (accidentally), the appellate court reversed and remanded for a new trial.

Click here for the original article about rape trauma syndrome.


Circa 1985: Bigamist Susan Sigler who was involved in a controversial Ohio murder case, is convicted of making a false rape allegation.


January 7, 1985: In Philadelphia, a school custodian - or caretaker as we say in the UK - is arrested after a 14 year old girl tells the police he kidnapped her on December 4, 1984, took her to his house and raped her three times overnight. Alexander Bradway is freed from prison when she recants. This report is from the Observer-Reporter, April 5, 1985, page 27. Apparently the girl showed courage coming forward to admit she had lied. And she needs help. No charges were filed against her because of her age.


January 11, 1985: Jenny Wilcox and Robert Aldridge are convicted of unspeakable crimes against the young. This case dates to August 1984 and demonstrates that at times women can also be the victims of these absurd witch-hunts. Wilcox and Aldridge were nursery workers in Ohio.

Here is the appeal judgment and here are details of her exoneration.


January 23, 1985: A man and two women are indicted on 18 counts of raping, sexually assaulting and abusing preschoolers. This was the Fells Acre Day School case. The accused were Gerald Amirault, his mother Violet, and Cheryl Amirault LaFave - the daughter of Violet/sister of Gerald.

Brief details of this shameful and tragic case are given by The National Registry of EXONERATIONS.


February 1985: Clyde Ray Spencer known as Ray Spencer was a traffic cop. This is a widely reported case that has been the subject of at least one documentary. He was accused of raping his own daughter and son, and then his stepson. By the time the case came to trial he was beginning to believe he had indeed raped his kids, and took an ALFORD PLEA. Eventually they recanted. This was a terrible miscarriage of justice that involved the suppression of exculpatory evidence and worse. He was formally cleared September 9, 2010.


February 1, 1985: A first year student at the University of Virginia claims to have been kidnapped from a parking lot, raped and then returned from whence she had come. Shortly she decides she was neither kidnapped nor raped. This report appeared on the front page of The Cavalier Daily, February 6, 1985.


February 19, 1985: American football player turned film actor Jim Brown is accused of raping a woman at his home. Four months later, the charges are sensationally dismissed when prosecutors say they no longer believe his accuser.

Although Brown was rightly cleared, this is a dude who clearly suffered from anger management issues, though not as badly as that other far more infamous football player O.J. Simpson!

This article appeared in the Lodi News-Sentinel, June 21, 1985, page 14.


February 25, 1985: In Nottingham, Trevor Armitage is murdered by teenage prostitute Emma Humphreys. Click here for more.


Circa March 1985: The Chicago Tribune reports on the little known case of Donna Dugan who accused Mr X and then switched to a man with a name, who ended up in gaol. What was that about police failing to believe the victim? Pity they believed this non-victim. Eventually they realised they’d been had.


March 1985: A man is cleared by a Roanoke County jury of sexually abusing his own granddaughter, including orally raping her. See entry for Clinebell, (above).


April 1, 1985: This report, so dated, is from the Victoria Advocate newspaper, page 6D. Kathryn Hargis Tucci of Laurel, Maryland, wasn’t laughing. Her lies had kept her former boyfriend in gaol for over a year.


April 6, 1985: A report so dated from the Deseret News, page A5 quotes Ada Country Sheriff’s Detective Ken Smith who says a 16 year old girl who claimed to have been kidnapped and raped the previous week made up the story to deflect from her poor school grades.


April 11, 1985: This article so dated appeared in The New York Times, page B3; it reports on the case of Santiago Martinez, and the recantation of his accuser from her hospital bed, the non-victim having attempted suicide.


April 23, 1985: A student claims to have been raped at Smith College, Massachusetts. Would you believe it is a liberal arts college? This probably explains the subsequent anti-rape demonstration. The following month it is announced that Little Miss Anonymous has withdrawn her complaint and left. She probably belongs in a booby hatch rather than an institution of higher learning. This report appeared in the Boca Raton News, May 5, 1985, page 16A. It alludes too to two other reported rapes at Mount Holyoke College; one of these rape allegations, apparently against a named or at least known individual, had since been withdrawn. Two false claims out of three sounds about right.


April 25, 1985: Betty Peavy of Frostproof, Florida, is charged with filing a false report after local law enforcement determine her claim of aggravated rape by a stranger has no substance. She is said to have staged the assault for the benefit of her husband.

This report appeared in The Ledger, (Lakeland, Florida) LAKELAND SUNRISE EDITION, April 26, 1985, page 2B.


June 1985: Two teenage girls claim to have been abducted by three masked men from Main Street, Auburn, Maine. They are then raped. Or are they? According to the police, their story was a hoax.

This article was published in the Bangor Daily News, July 19, 1985, page 17.


June 1985: This is an interesting document relating to the Crowell/Dotson case. Make your own assessment of its utility.


July 24, 1985: A teenager tells Gainesville police she was forced into a car by 2 men, forced to smoke marijuana, and raped. After a hospital examination which is unable to confirm the rape, she comes clean, she had exchanged sex and $30 for a ride to New Jersey. Sigh. The phantom rape was on Wednesday, July 24; the allegation is made on the Thursday; the arrest (hers) comes Friday morning. As she was still well over 900 miles from New Jersey, an obvious question remains...This report is from the Gainesville Sun, July 27, 1985, page 8A.


August 19, 1985: A 20 year old student nurse is allegedly sexually assaulted after alighting from a bus in Bromley, Kent. On July 21, 1986, Roy Burnett is convicted of rape, buggery and assault occasioning actual bodily harm. He is given a life sentence. He does not appeal his conviction, but on January 22, 1987, the Court of Appeal dismisses his appeal against sentence in strong terms. At that time he was 43 years old, and his antecedents included two indecent assaults. He was deemed “a psychopathic dullard and patently a danger to the community, particularly to young, unsuspecting females.”

In 1998, the same woman made a false rape allegation in a different part of the country. This led to the Metropolitan Police re-opening this case, and for once both they and the lawyers acted with commendable integrity. In April 2000 at the age of 56, Roy Burnett was freed when the Crown told the Court of Appeal that it was unable to argue that his conviction was safe.

This legal document concerns the medical evidence presented at the 2000 appeal.


October 11, 1985: An unnamed 16 year old girl batters a man to death in Ealing, West London. She claimed he had raped her, but she was clearly not right in the head. When she appeared at the Central Criminal Court she pleaded guilty to manslaughter by the legal fiction of diminished responsibility. She was described as presenting “a great danger to the public”, which is probably why she was clutching two teddy bears after she was detained for life. Seriously.

File Miss X under PRETEXT FOR MURDER.


November 4, 1985 This report so dated was published in the Dutch language newspaper Amigoe, page 3. At Willemstad on the Caribbean island of Curaçao, a woman, apparently a tourist, turns up at the police station looking the worse for wear and claiming to have been raped. She ended up being arrested, her bruises - if not self-inflicted - were apparently the result of a financial transaction with an unhappy client.


December 1985: In Wichita County, Treva Throneberry accuses her own father of raping her; this appears to have been her first false rape allegation. The charge is dismissed in December 1986.


December 2, 1985: Sharon Donohue is not abducted from a parking lot by two men and a woman, and was therefore not raped by any of her imaginary kidnappers. Her actions lead to a major investigation in New Hampshire and Vermont. On February 4, 1986, she recants, and subsequently pleads guilty to inventing the story.

This article is from the Lewiston Journal, February 6, 1986, page 2.


December 23, 1985: Lorraine Miles visits her physiotherapist Kenneth Cain. Click here for more.


1986: In South Carolina, Joe Kennedy is accused by his own daughter of raping her over a period of years from the age of 13. He is convicted in 1987 and is given a sentence heavy enough to ensure he will never see daylight again. In 1998, Vickie Kennedy recants. This report is from the The Dispatch (Lexington), January 8, 2001, page 2A. He is finally released January 9, 2001.


January 20, 1986: The Reverend Nathaniel T. Grady is convicted of unspeakable crimes against the young. This is yet another of these absurd child abuse cases resulting from the Satanic panic of the 1980s, although there was no witchcraft alleged here. Grady was finally cleared in 1996 and freed in September 1997. Here is the short version, and here is the June 1996 ruling.


January 23, 1986: Joseph Nelson is cleared by a jury at Hillsborough County Superior Court of the multiple rapes of a 12 year old girl at Hudson in 1983. This was a retrial; the first had resulted in a hung jury. Wisely he took the stand in his own defence.

The above report appeared in The Nashua Telegraph, January 24, 1986, page 23.

[For the avoidance of doubt, the Joseph Nelson alluded to therein is not the same Joseph Nelson who was convicted of serious child sexual offences in Tennessee a quarter of a century later].


March 7, 1986: Dennis Werchowski is accused of raping Lynne R. Cronin. Although he is totally innocent, like Brian Banks he is threatened with a heavy sentence if convicted, so pleads guilty to a lesser charge which results in him serving a short sentence as well as probation, and of course being stigmatised as a sex offender. In 1988, Cronin makes another false rape allegation, and admits she lied about this alleged sexual assault too. This article is from the Milwaukee Sentinel, October 5, 1988, page 10.


April 1986: False complaints by children of sexual abuse by Paul Wilson.

The above is an interesting article written largely from an Australian perspective. Apart from his claim that false allegations of rape are rare and the claim that (in his experience) child witnesses are no less reliable than adults, he makes some valid points.


April 1, 1986: TIDEWATER SAYS FALSE RAPE REPORTS UP

The above article (credited to UPI) appeared in the Richmond Times-Dispatch, One Star Edition, page B-3 (accessed here through NewsBank).

Twenty-two rapes were reported in Virginia Beach this year (up to what date is not given), eight of these were said to have been fabricated - not unfounded, but fabricated.

In 1985, there were 138 reports of rape and attempted rape, of which the police said 21% were false. According to police spokesman J.N. Perry, in one two week period he saw seven false reports.

A number of reasons are given for making false reports. Here is my fairly comprehensive list.


May 7, 1986: In Milwaukee, Antonio Ferguson is arrested after his girlfriend accuses him of aggravated rape. Three months later she admits she lied. This report is from the Ocala Star-Banner, August 16, 1986, page 4A.


May 12, 1986: In Salt Lake City, a four year old girl experiences pain urinating; when her mother questions her, she says she has been raped, although clearly not in so many words. The police are called in, but all that is required is a visit to the doctor. This GENUINE MISTAKE is cleared up later in the week.

The happy conclusion is reported in Deseret News, May 16, 1986, page B1.


May 21, 1986: According to this report so dated from The Ledger (Lakeland, Florida), page 4A, a 10 year old girl who had accused a man of raping her, had recanted, telling her mother she wanted to make right what she’d done at trial. Michael Ray Chandler had been behind bars for 10 months.

Interestingly, nearly three decades later a man named Michael Ray Chandler Junior was convicted of child sex offences in Texas - like this one. This does not appear to be the same person. Also, in 1988, a serial rapist named Michael Chandler was convicted in London.


June 17, 1986: In quashing the conviction of David Cox for rape at Dudley Crown Court, the Court of Appeal heard that the alleged victim had previously accused a man of rape, although not apparently to the police. The circumstances were that Cox left her flat at 8am, after which she was rejoined by her boyfriend. She did not tell him she had been raped until after 11pm. When Cox was arrested, he told the police they’d had consensual sex. Neither they nor the jury believed him; at trial he sought to adduce evidence that she had lied to her boyfriend about being raped on a previous occasion. She had then had sex with a man named Steven while her boyfriend was away, and Steven had told him! She had then told her boyfriend she had been raped by Steven. That allegation was false. The trial judge had not allowed this to be introduced in evidence; the Court of Appeal took issue with this. Thus we appear to have another two-time false rape accuser.


June 28, 1986: Late at night, a teenage girl is raped by Abdul Bazuk bin Mat Salleh, at least that is what she tells the authorities, but when the case comes before the Sessions Court at Mallaca, she retracts her claims.

This report appeared in the New Straits Times, July 5, 1988, page 4.


September 1, 1986: The Texas Criminal Rule of Evidence 412 replaces the Texas rape shield statute.


September 10, 1986: Nursery owner Sandra Craig is indicted on 53 counts including serious sexual offences against her young charges. Her teenage son faces similar allegations. In September 1987, she is given a ten year sentence. In July 1989, the Maryland Court of Appeals reverses her convictions. She is finally exonerated in 1991.


November 22, 1986: This report, so dated, is from the Birmingham Evening Mail (WEEKEND SPECIAL), page 3. The jury taking ten minutes to clear him says what they thought of his accuser.


November 29, 1986: Kevin Ibbs has sex with Christine Watson. And then...? If the case of the man who become known as the 30 second rapist is not the most notorious false rape allegation in Australian history, it is certainly the most bizarre and the most ludicrous as well as one of the most mendacious. You can read an excellent summary of it here. If you want the long version (written in legalese), here is the final appeal judgment. File under NONE DARE CALL IT CONSPIRACY.


December 1, 1986: Former public schoolboy Andrew Richins murders Wai Lai Choi after toxic teen temptress Sabrina Ngiau claims he raped her. This is another case of the victim being put on trial, but it didn’t wash, and Richins was convicted at the Central Criminal Court albeit by a majority verdict. A sad, tragic tale of a teenager throwing his own life away over a youthful infatuation.

This report appeared in the New Straits Times, March 27, 1988, page 6.


December 27, 1986: Laddya Gould of Punta Gorda tells police she was kidnapped and raped the previous evening. An investigation reveals that Gould - a married woman - had been out partying and was afraid of her husband’s reaction. Read between the lines. This report was published in the Saratosa Herald-Tribune, December 29, 1986, page 3BC.


1987: In Canada, Donna Mercier falsely accuses her lover Kenneth Sylvia of rape and theft. Nine years later she hits the headlines big time for a different type of false report, and her lies are even reported in Parliament.


January 17, 1987: Joseph Blair of Berwick, Pennsylvania is cleared of raping a 5 year old girl, who claimed he violated her about a hundred times from April 1984. This article appeared in the Observer-Reporter (Washington, Pennsylvania), January 19, 1987, page A-3; it contains an interesting but flawed comment: “No medical or other physical evidence to prove or disprove the charges was available because the girl’s mother waited 18 months before going to authorities with the allegations”. If such a young girl had indeed been so violated, there would have been plenty of evidence. WHAT’S THE MATTER WITH KIDS TODAY?


February 1987: The Cleveland sexual abuse scandal is one of the most shameful episodes in child protection (so-called). Really it began in July 1986 when Dr Marietta Higgs examined a child at the Fleming Memorial Hospital and concluded she had been sexually abused. In January 1987, she transferred to Middlesbrough General where the following month she and her colleague Dr Geoffrey Wyatt set about the mass diagnosis of the anal rape of young girls and boys with the reflex anal dilation test. In all over a hundred were so diagnosed and taken into care. Luckily the police soon caught on; there was an official report, but Marietta Higgs remained unrepentant in spite of the enormous damage she caused virtually single-handed.


February 3, 1987: In Spartanburg County, South Carolina, Catherine Conklin claims to have been raped at knifepoint by a man who posed as a utility worker. Utility worker Anthony B. Gaines is arrested after she picks out his photograph (which was on record due to a trivial traffic offence).

Although he is soon released on bond, Gaines is (obviously) suspended from his job without pay. After repeating the lie to a grand jury on March 19, Conklin moves to Florida, but soon has a change of heart, and does the decent thing, although she blames her boyfriend! She faces a possible perjury charge. This article appeared in the Spartanburg Herald-Journal, April 25, 1987, front page & A6.


March 9, 1987: This is an unusual report from Pittsburgh. A woman tells police she was raped by a man posing as a Jehovah’s Witness. When her story is shown to be false, she claims to have been raped by a relative, Thurman Dumas, who is subsequently arrested.

The above was reported by The Pittsburgh Press, June 18, 1987. An earlier press report says Dumas had previous convictions (plural) for rape. I can find no later reports concerning this case, but it is possible he did rape this woman or that she lied about him too, although the police appear to believe she was indeed raped by Dumas, so one would assume they had some sort of evidence in view of her lying to them.


March 27, 1987: United States Senator Brock Adams meets Kari Tupper at his home, a woman young enough to be his granddaughter. She claims he drugged and raped her, but the following day when she is examined at Arlington Hospital, Virginia, no trace of drugs or evidence of sexual assault are found. She does not file a complaint with the police until July 24. The District Attorney dismisses her allegations.

If Brock Adams thought this would be the end of this affair, he was mistaken; as with many high profile cases since, when the information hit the public domain, a slew of women crawled out of the woodwork making the same or similar allegations. One claimed he’d raped her and then thrown $200 down on the table - one of Bill Cosby’s myriad accusers would later make exactly the same allegation. Thankfully this leads nowhere although it trashes his political career.


April 1987: The Scope Of Rape... is published by Mary Koss et al. Click here for more.


June 5, 1987: Teresa McCandless is convicted of manslaughter. This is only a false allegation of attempted rape, but is included here because of the outcome.

McCandless had been drinking with Harold Bolton - a man nearly twice her age - when she stabbed him to death at an apartment in Catford. From the little information available, both appear to have been down and outs, or at best two people living near the bottom of society. She claimed he had the knife, which does little to explain how he was the one who was stabbed.

This report appeared in the Guardian, June 13, 1987, page 5. File Toxic Teresa under PRETEXT FOR MURDER and HEAD CASE.


June 28, 1987: Michael McElroy is arrested hours after robbing a man. Doubtless much to his surprise, he is charged with rape as well. (And there was me thinking they called it sodomy in 1987). On July 22, 1987 it is reported by The Pittsburgh Press, (page S2) that the sex charges have been dropped. Deviant sexual intercourse - ah, that’s better. According to Mount Lebanon Detective Rich Nehilia, the victim was mad that he’d been robbed.


July 30, 1987: Marian Snyder of New Jersey goes the extra mile when she fakes her own kidnapping and rape. Click here for more.


September 9, 1987: A teenager goes for a ride with a man and is raped before being released near Youngwood, Pennsylvania. Or is she? Greensburg police officers Michael Dell and Paul Burkey think not. This article is from the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, October 28, 1987, page 5-W.


October 9, 1987: Singer-songwriter David Bowie spends the night with a woman named Wanda Nichols who shortly accuses him of raping her and also claims he told he she had now been infected with AIDS. On November 18, 1987, a Dallas grand jury declines to indict him. Her civil suit is dismissed by District Judge Sam Cummings on February 12, 1990.


October 12, 1987: A woman is carjacked at knifepoint and raped. At least that is what she told the men with badges. Greensburg police officers Michael Dell and Paul Burkey don’t believe her. This article is from the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, October 28, 1987, page 5-W.


October 16, 1987: A DePaul University student is raped late at night. Or is she? Click here for more.


October 21, 1987: This report so dated appeared in the Guardian, page 4. Teen temptress Alison Morcom accused another youth of rape for a truly bizarre reason. Her victim was arrested, and she wasted 243 hours of police time, so the bench at Newquay sent her to youth custody for 90 days.


November 5, 1987: Christine Burzynski has sex with two men at a motel. They threaten to tell her boyfriend, so she tells him first, and he tells her to do what any boyfriend worth the name would do. She tells the police, and in January 1988, testifies to the rape, embellishing the tale by claiming to have been kidnapped at gunpoint by them from outside a Detroit bowling alley. In June 1988, she does the decent thing, and recants to Detective Eugene Hlibay. The charges are dropped against the two men, and she is charged with perjury.

Although she was clearly in the wrong - both for having sex with them and for the far more serious false rape claim - don’t have too much sympathy for these two; they were ASKING FOR IT. The linked report is from the Spokane Chronicle, October 28, 1988, page A10.


November 25, 1987: After a three day trial, Michael Smith is convicted of several offences against an underage girl, including rape. The allegations are very recent, from June 1-September 24 the same year. Misapplying the rape shield statute, the judge refuses to permit him to adduce evidence of multiple false allegations against different people by the same girl. On March 16, 1989, the Supreme Court of Georgia reverses his conviction and on March 29, 1989, denies reconsideration.


November 28, 1987: A small town in New York State is the scene of one of the most notorious and extensively documented false rape allegations in American history. The Tawana Brawley case is too well known to discuss in detail here. The reader is referred in the first instance to the substantial documentary coverage of it that can be found on YouTube and other video sites, and also to the official report. File this under HATE CRIME HOAX.


1987/8: ANOTHER DOOR CLOSED: RAPE TRAUMA SYNDROME by Michael Donohue.

Although the above article by a superior court judge errs in favour of this fallacious concept, it contains a fairly comprehensive overview of the literature up until that time - from an American perspective - and bundles of case law.

“Expert testimony of RTS can be both relevant and helpful to the trier of fact in rape prosecutions.” Indeed?

He concludes: “...the myths which surround rape and its victims remain. Juries’ general ‘tendency to view rape charges with skepticism and suspicion, especially when there is a suggestion of willingness or agreement on the part of the victim’”.

If the lady consents, she is not a victim, and juries are rightly entitled to be skeptical when a woman does not report reasonably promptly, or if she continues to date her alleged rapist.


1988: Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests is founded in Toledo by Barbara Blaine. Click here for more.


1988: The Credibility of Children’s Allegations of Sexual Abuse by Kathleen M. Quinn.

This is a very interesting though flawed article that covers both false and true allegations of sexual abuse, anonymised as usual. Although it does not mention rape, the word penetration is used, which is as good as when dealing with preschoolers.

The main problem with the article is that the author vastly underestimates the true incidence of false allegations of child sexual abuse, be they mendacious or sincerely mistaken. But:

“Large-scale investigations resulting in mass disclosures of sexual abuse are susceptible to a copycat or mass hysteria phenomenon that may yield false reports. For example, investigations of a residential school for children and developmental centers for the retarded yielded many actual cases of abuse resulting in criminal convictions. However, investigators noted a trend that late-arising complaints were more likely to be assessed as unsubstantiated or false.”


1988: In Canada, a teenager known only as R.R.1 is attending a party at the house of her boyfriend. She and another guest go outside and have sex. Click here for more.


1988: Ellen Bass and Laura Davis publish the first edition of The Courage To Heal, one of the most dangerous books ever written. My review can be found here, and what skeptic Robert Sheaffer thinks of it here. In spite of the proven damage done by this book and similar quackery, it has been both augmented and reissued several times.


January 1988: In the Netherlands, a woman reports being raped by a friend. According to the public prosecutor, this was another case of GUILT. She appear too to have been a bit of a HEAD CASE. She escaped with a short suspended sentence.

The above is based on this report from the Dutch newspaper NIEUWSBLAD van het NOORDEN, September 27, 1989, page 18.


February 6, 1988: Very Careful Rape is screened. Although a dramatisation, one cannot help but think it inspired some women, (like Rhiannon Brooker).


March 26, 1988: County man cleared of indecency published in the Lincolnshire Echo, page 5.

The above article reports the acquittal of convicted sex offender George Lewis who was falsely accused by Ray Hill of molesting Hill’s sons.

I actually spoke to Mr Lewis when I was researching my biography of Hill. You can read some of the background to the case therein, in particular pages 79 & 80 (book page numbers).


March 28, 1988: This report so dated from page 3 of the Dutch language newspaper Leeuwarder Courant proves that while all the nice girls love a sailor, soldiers have to take what they can get, which in this case is A WOMAN SCORNED.

The false accuser was a teenager of Limburg Landgraaf who accused her former boyfriend of raping her because...he didn’t want to take her back home with him to the United States. A medical examination proved there had been recent sexual intercourse, and a cursory criminal investigation showed he had a rock solid alibi. Bad girl.


April 7, 1988: This report so dated from the front page of the Dutch language newspaper NIEUWSBLAD van het NOORDEN tells the story of a teenager from Assen who faked her kidnapping and rape by two men. This appears to have happened, or rather not to have happened, the previous week.


April 19, 1988: A Brandeis University student has sex with fellow student Jonathan Stockhammer behind her boyfriend’s back. She accuses him of rape; he is convicted and given a 15 year sentence, but on appeal his conviction is reversed.

Stockhammer is exonerated on May 1, 1991.


June 3, 1988: Terri Kerr of Whitpain, Pennsylvania, tells law enforcement that on May 30, 1988 she was attacked by two men, raped by one and orally raped by the other. She is medically examined, but during the investigation she admits she made the story up. She is charged with filing a false report.


June 23, 1988: An unnamed fourteen year old boy is cleared at Stafford Crown Court of raping a forty-eight year old woman in July 1987 when Mr Justice Pill directs the jury find him not guilty on the second day of the trial. This is an unusual case, to put it mildly. The woman was described as simple-minded and of low intelligence, though she was apparently not so simple-minded that she didn’t understand the birds and the bees, because she was a mother of three!

Granted this kid was no angel, but what would happen to a forty-eight year old man who admitted having sex with a fourteen year old girl?

[The above is based on an article in the Times, June 24, 1988 - no page given, accessed here through NewsBank Newspapers - U.K. and Ireland].


July 3, 1988: Teenager Sarah Jane Louise Goodwin attends a police station in Lincoln and claims to have been raped earlier that day. On July 6, she puts a name to her assailant, her former boyfriend Thomas Glencross. In spite of a degree of skepticism, Mr Glencross is arrested the following day and held until July 21. Eventually the truth comes out, she had spent the night in question with a man named Robert; they’d had consensual but rough sex, and when the resulting stigmata came to the attention of her mother, she fabricated the rape story, even claiming at one point she had been raped by Robert.

On December 2, 1988, she appeared at Lincoln Crown Court where on pleading guilty to attempting to pervert the course of justice she was given a three year sentence in a young offender institution.

According to the report in the London Times by Craig Seton the following day, she claimed to have been raped in a public house car park at Stamford, while of her 25 page statement, the prosecution said: “It was a vivid and detailed account of rape. Her statement painted a picture of Glencross as a man who over previous weeks has continually pestered and threatened her because he supposedly could not accept their relationship was over. It amounted to a convincing account”.

On April 24, 1989, her sentence was reduced to 18 months on appeal.


August 17, 1988: Lynne Cronin tells police she was beaten, kicked in the head and raped earlier in the day at Cutler Park, Waukesha. This is her second false rape allegation. The first results in an innocent man serving time.


Circa August 26, 1988: An educationally subnormal underage teen is allegedly raped by two brothers. The police were not informed until 1990. It gets complicated because when questioned by the police, their co-defendant admitted raping the girl, but he was cleared of all charges. So what really happened here?

It is clear from the medical notes - which were not disclosed at trial - and other evidence, that the girl was lying about the date, not just wrong, lying. Quite likely she had sex with her boyfriend, but it is clear that none of those involved in this were too bright. My advice to you guys is avoid educationally subnormal women and girls like the plague. Their stupidity often makes them credible witnesses, but they know how to play people.

The two brothers were convicted at Manchester in December 1991, and on February 15, 2001, their second appeal was successful.


August 27, 1988: On said date at Warren, Michigan, a woman claims to have been carjacked and raped. After it happens, she looks for her boyfriend, goes to his house, and sleeps. Then she reports it. She is physically examined, but no evidence is found. An on site investigation proves she is either seriously mistaken or lying about what happened after the alleged carjacking. The case is closed on or after October 12, 1988. In 1992, the same woman claims to have been the victim of a bizarre street robbery which the police conclude never happened. In August 1994, she accuses Robert Mathis and an unidentified man of rape. Mathis is convicted. It remains to be seen if this rape happened either, but Mathis wins his appeal against conviction.


August 28, 1988: New Hampshire woman Barbara Bernier is allegedly raped in her apartment. Shortly, investigator Paul Goupil says that after a thorough investigation, her claim is shown to be untrue.

This article was published in The Telegraph (Nashua, New Hampshire), September 2, 1988, page 7.


September 1988: This report from the Gadsden Times, September 3, 1990, page A2, is one of many about this unusual case. Elizabeth Richardson accused Gary Nitsch of raping her in September 1988. He was arrested and charged but the case was dropped. She told friends the rape story was a hoax, and in February 1990, she was convicted of perjury; on June 8, 1990, she was sentenced to 180 days in gaol and two years probation. And to take out said advertisements. The case was appealed to the Supreme Court of Nebraska, apparently without success.


September 1, 1988: Canadian Newspapers Co. v. Canada (Attorney General)

The above judgment from the Supreme Court of Canada contains some very interesting testimony. Doreen Carole Boucher, co-ordinator of a rape crisis centre, admitted under cross-examination that some rapes reported to her and other rape crisis centres were imaginary. Normally, rad-fems and so-called anti-rape activists will make such an admission only at the point of a gun. Although she does her best to minimise this admission, it begs the question how many clients of such centres are genuine, and how many are either mentally disturbed or simply evil.


September 11, 1988: Russell Kassab puts a teenage girl up for the night rather that allow her to drive home to Garrisonville, a distance of less than fifteen miles. She accuses him of rape. After he appears in court the following month, she writes to the authorities and admits she had lied.

This report was published in The Free Lance-Star, Ocotber 25, 1988, page 20.


October 30, 1988: At Eugene, Oregon, a teenager tells police that on said date a man climbed into her car and raped her. Just like that. When they find discrepancies in her account, she admits she made it up after arriving home late one evening. The linked report is from the The Register-Guard, (Eugene, Oregon), November 17, 1988, page 4D.


November 9, 1988: In Florida, Ivie Cornell Norris is convicted of raping a 9 year old girl, which is said to have happened in March that year. There was said to be no physical evidence - seriously? Like if a 9 year old girl is A VIRGIN, how can a jury convict? Norris didn’t take the stand. How could he not have taken the stand when accused of something like this? The good news is that, aged 11, the girl recanted. She said she was inspired by an episode of the TV programme 21 Jump Street.


December 2, 1988: David Sanderson is accused of raping a girl at his apartment in Deary, Idaho, apparently while other people were present, which may be the reason she recanted. The same article in the Idahoian (Moscow, Idaho), May 2, 1989, page 10A reports the April 1989 dismissal of a rape charge against Idaho graduate student Said Hajib in similar circumstances. It also contains some incisive comment on such charges from a defense attorney:

Public pressure is put on prosecutors to proceed with every rape case, even ones that have weak evidence or are simply false...

A tremendous public disservice is done by proceeding with weak rape cases...


December 14, 1988: In Malaysia, a teenager tells police her boyfriend raped her December 11/2; her name is given a Jamilah Jaafar; his is given as Zali. On August 28, 1989, she pleads guilty to making a false report. In October 1989, she is given a slap on the wrist. This report is from the New Straits Times, October 25, 1989, page 11. What happens to men convicted of rape in Malaysia? Here is a clue, they don’t get probation.


Late 1988: After being indoctrinated by feminist propaganda, Meredith Maran accuses her own father of raping her when she was a child. She is 37 years old. Eventually, she realises the human mind is a fragile thing, including her own; she recants and apologises. She even writes a book about it - one that frankly is not very coherent. Here she is in a short video.


Late 1988-early 1989: After becoming pregnant, Linda Carty claims to have been raped in a Houston car park. She gives up the baby for adoption. In May 2001, Carty murdered Joana Rodriguez - a truly bizarre crime. While on death row, her case was taken up by Clive Stafford Smith and his gang of miscreants; the 1988 rape claim was one of many lies they parroted hoping to adduce sympathy for her. When I contacted Houston Police, I was told they had no record of a rape report by Carty. She probably had a fling with another student. However the baby was conceived, one thing is certain, this evil, manipulative liar was not raped.


1989: In the city of Nashua, New Hampshire, there are 79 reports of rape, 6 of which are determined to be unfounded. [This figure comes from a report in the New Hampshire Sunday News, February 18, 1990, page 11A, (accessed through NewsBank)].

At that time, Nashua had a population of just under eighty thousand, so this is really quite a high figure for reported rapes. It remains to be seen how many of those 79 were genuine, and of course it is possible that some genuine rapes went unreported, though nowhere near as many as the sisterhood would have us believe.


1989: Rape Law: A Feminist Legal Analysis by Miriam Benson is published. Click here for more.


1989: New York woman Valerie Adams files a false rape report. See later entry.


Circa early February 1989: Outsider Lori McLuckie is a really sad case, although far from physically unattractive she said she had never had a boyfriend at school. On relocating to Denver she forms a relationship with a homeless man who has a drink problem. He beats her, and, she claims, rapes her. This claim was almost certainly true. Escaping from his clutches, she runs to a neighbour, an older man who is possibly her only true friend; he has a paternal interest in her, and makes her call the police.

Her assailant stands trial including for rape, but because of her bland, emotionless performance on the witness stand, he is acquitted of all charges. She contacts a man with whom she’d had a fling while at college. He comes to Denver to see her, but when she falls pregnant he tells her he does not want a child, and deserts her.

Lori goes on to form another relationship with one of life’s losers, and for some unfathomable reason, murders him in gruesome fashion, dismembering his body. On May 27, 1988, the police find what is left of Andrew Vigil in her apartment. Her trial starts on January 30, 1989; she testifies that he had raped her. That claim was undoubtedly false. She is convicted, and of course her baby is taken away from her as soon as he is born, prior to her trial. A very sad case indeed.

Here is a review of a documentary about her.


February 3, 1989: On the island of Trinidad & Tobago, Ann Marie Boodram is arrested for the murder of her husband, who was poisoned with weedkiller.

This case is incredible; you can read the full judgment here, but in short, she claimed inter alia to have been raped by one of the detectives assigned to the case.

After being convicted of the murder of her husband, twice, and sentenced to death both times, an appeal to the Privy Council in London was successful, and a second retrial was not ordered. It is clear from the judgment that the evidence against this woman was overwhelming. Along with all the other lies she told, the rape allegation is beneath contempt.


March 12-3, 1989: A fifteen year old girl has sex with Roderick Williams. Click here for more.


April 1989: Georgina Kyriakou has a fling with businessman Jhias Chamas at the London hotel where she works. Then she accuses him of raping her. Mr Chamas spends 12 days in custody before the truth comes out. In November 1990, she is given a 12 month sentence at the Central Criminal Court for perverting the course of justice. This report appeared in the London Times, November 10, 1990, page 2.


April 1, 1989: New York State university student Quincy Troupe is arrested for the rape of another student. On April 15, it was reported that she was temporarily withdrawing the internal student code conduct charge so that the legal authorities could proceed with the case. (Rape should always be dealt with by the police).

On May 10, 1989, criminal charges are dropped by the Suffolk Country District Attorney. Troupe had a rock solid alibi, and there was no physical evidence because although the phantom rape happened around 10pm on March 24, 1989, the student concerned did not report it until the next day, and had showered in the meantime.

Interestingly, Little Miss Anonymous continues to be alluded to as the victim. She was white; Troupe was black, so the usual suspects tried to make a racial issue of it.


April 26, 1989: An article appeared on page 3 of the London Times that garnered little attention: Sex abuse charges dropped

The stepfather of three children was cleared of several charges, including rape. His wife who had been charged with several offences as well, was also cleared. The offences were alleged to have been committed in June 1987. The uncredited author gives the impression that the trial was halted on a technicality, something he called a legal blunder, but in the last paragraph it is reported that one of the girls had been examined by a doctor the day after she had allegedly been raped, and was found to be A VIRGIN. Some technicality.


April 27, 1989: A report is published in the London Times of the acquittal of the defendant in what is said to be the first charge of marital rape ever in Scotland. He was alleged to have handcuffed her first.

Both parties are unnamed, but the alleged rape was said to have happened in August 1988. They had been in the process of reconciliation and “Within a month of the alleged rape, the couple were having sexual intercourse with each other and were showering each other with presents...”

In January 1989, after an argument she told police he was seeing her against his bail conditions. As Counsel for the Defence pointed out:

“if the couple had been allowed to continue their reconciliation they would have been living together today and she would have withdrawn the charges.”

He added: “In my submission, the law should not interfere too closely in differences between husband and wife. I am not suggesting for one second that the law should not interfere at all, but there must be very few married couples where one or other has not gone over the top from time to time.”

The wife had now started divorce proceedings.

Cases like this should not get anywhere near a courtroom, in spite of the incessant whinings of the loony feminist movement.


May 1989: Two false rape allegations for the price of one and a fake knife attack the following month are reported in this article from a Canberra newspaper, June 8.


May 1, 1989: The gullible Oprah Winfrey interviews Vicki Polin. This one is hilarious. On the actual programme, Polin was given the pseudonym Rachel, and her being raped as a child was the least disturbing of her revelations.

Predictably the programme caused uproar with the usual charges of anti-Semitism; if Oprah had not been black she would never have survived it. Naturally the lunatic fringe made enormous capital from it too. Here is what is said to be Polin’s testimony concerning a bill in the Wisconsin Senate 19 years later. For what it is worth. Thankfully the organisation she founded in 1999 - The Awareness Center - closed in 2014.


May 6, 1989: Teen stripper Donna Stephan is not raped on Route 22, and admitted as much. According to the New York Times of July 23, 1989, she claimed too to have been sexually assaulted at a private frat house party on May 5. Tsk, tsk!


May 9, 1989: This is a horror story because it concerns the actual rape of a child and the fanaticism of so-called child protection services who were intent on proving her father was responsible, totally ignoring their usual mantra of “believe the children”.

Alicia Wade was 8 years old when a man broke into her bedroom and raped her. She told her parents she was experiencing pain lower down, and was taken to a San Diego hospital where she was immediately diagnosed as the victim of a gross sexual violation. When she was asked about her condition, the girl gave a detailed description of her attacker, but nobody who mattered would believe her.

After her parents had been put through Hell, as detailed here (from page 4), James Wade was finally cleared of raping his own daughter. Convicted sex offender Alan Carder was eventually identified as the monster who did this. File under FALSE AND TRUE.


May 23, 1989: This report from an Australian newspaper so dated tells the tale of two young women who cried rape the previous weekend, and were shortly found to be less than truthful.


May 26, 1989: A woman claims to have been abducted and raped in New York’s Central Park. George Conner is arrested and spends five days in gaol before the police realise they’ve been had. Shelley Bjorkland admitted she had lied. She had also made no fewer than 11 false rape complaints in California! And had been arrested on similar charges in 3 other states!

This may have been another COPYCAT FALSE RAPE ALLEGATION because on April 19, 1989, a woman (later identified as Trisha Meili) was savagely raped and left for dead in Central Park. The case of the so-called New York jogger became a cause célèbre because of both the nature of the crime and of the following investigation, trials and appeals. (Her first name is sometimes misspelt Shelly).


July 23, 1989: Ellen Holmes appears at Alachua General Hospital after what appears to have been a dust up with Willie Ray Myers; she accuses him of raping her; he too appears at the hospital for treatment; he is charged with battery and burglary while she is charged with filing a false rape report. From the little information available this would appear to have been some sort of domestic incident, and as the lady gave a good as she got, they should have been allowed to kiss and make up. Sadly, the imbeciles who control our criminal justice system don’t think like that. This report appeared in the The Gainesville Sun, July 24, 1989, page 2B.


July 11, 1989: Claude Hampton is accused of raping a teenage girl in his apartment at Newport, Rhode Island with the assistance of Jaime Lewis. They are held without bond, but shortly their accuser recants. On July 20, the police say she will probably he charged with filing a false report.

[The above is based on a report in the Providence Journal, July 20, 1989, page B-06, (accessed here through NewsBank)].


August 20, 1989: Lyle and Erik Menéndez murder their parents at the family home in Beverly Hills. Click here for more.


August 28, 1989: A 14 year old boy is arrested in Florida on suspicion of...well, take a gander at this excellent analysis of Bobby Fijnje - the so-called Old Cutler case - which saw Stephen Ceci appearing as an expert witness. (You will find his name elsewhere in this database).

Here is an HTML version of the letter the jurors sent to the State Attorney after they had acquitted this poor kid of all charges; it is dated May 9, 1991. The State Attorney concerned went on to serve as Attorney General of the United States; this has been called the case Janet Reno would like to have forgotten. This and the Waco massacre, of course.


September 22, 1989: Wolverhampton magistrates sentence Mandy Ray to four months in a young offenders institution on her conviction for wasting police time. Her false rape allegation led to the arrest of an innocent man.

This article was published in the Daily Telegraph, September 23, 1989, page 10.


October 3, 1989: Brenda Carey tells Orlando Police she was abducted from the Rosemont Plaza shopping centre and raped the previous afternoon. The following day, she is charged with filing a false police report.


October 24, 1989: Ohio State University student Michele Yentes is raped at knifepoint late at night by a black sexual predator. The assault provokes outrage by students and faculty members. And more outrage including among blacks when it turns out this fiend was a figment of her imagination.

Her punishment is meted out on October 31, 1990 and is reported by the Daily Kent Stater, November 2, 1990, page 3.


November 1989: You couldn’t make this one up, but she did! Lesbian Sandra Harris has sex with David Sheedy hoping to get pregnant. She told her lover Alison Westcott she’d been raped. She told the police too, and an innocent man called Nigel Kennedy (not the famous violinist) was arrested when Westcott saw a man matching the description of the phantom assailant. Harris identified him falsely as the non-existent rapist. This poor bloke spent 18 days behind bars before he was cleared by DNA. When the police finally arrested Sheedy, the truth came out, and at the Central Criminal Court on August 5, 1991, Harris was given a 15 month sentence with 9 months suspended after pleading guilty to perverting the course of justice.

The Harris case is discussed in this November 1991 article by Edward G. Lawrence from The New Law Journal called Sex cases: abolition of corroboration rule.


November 18, 1989: In Saratosa, Valerie Malone accuses Cleodis Peterson of raping her. He is charged with several offences, but she recants the rape allegation. It is not entirely clear what happened, and it is likely that neither was telling the whole truth, though there appears to have been some sort of financial transaction and/or dispute between the parties. This article appeared in the Saratosa Herald-Tribune, July 1, 1990, pages 1B & 3B.


December 5, 1989: Amine Baba-Ali is convicted by a New York judge of unspeakable crimes against his 4 year old daughter due to a combination of a malicious ex-wife and an incompetent medical examiner. Eventually his convictions are overturned and he receives substantial compensation for his lost years, but he never sees his daughter again. A truly sad case.


December 13, 1989: Teenager Gary Lamont Moore of Bowling Green is released from prison after a charge of first degree rape is dropped, his accuser having recanted.

This article appeared in the Daily News (Bowling Green, Kentucky), December 14, 1989, page 2-A.


Circa December 23, 1989: The article immediately below is from a Florida newspaper, The News-Journal, April 8, 1993, page 6A.

Cases like that of Anne Norris would be laughable if they were not so tragic.


1990-April 1992: This is a case that although bad enough could have been tragic. Nicole Lynn Althaus was born April 10, 1975. In 1990, she made a single allegation against her father Richard, that he had touched her inappropriately. From there, her allegations mushroomed, resulting in the arrest of her father for rape and other crimes, and for her mother for sexual assault. Fortunately, the courts soon realised that whatever had been happening here, it was not sexual abuse. In April 1992, Nicole herself recognised her delusions, and withdrew her allegations. She said she realised she couldn’t have walked on hot coals because she didn’t have scars. She and her parents went on to sue those they held responsible for implanting her with false memories. Here is the full judgment.


1990: Valerie Adams files a false rape report at Rotterdam, New York. See later entry.


Circa 1990: “To spare you the graphic details, from age six to nineteen I was tortured physically and sexually in cult rituals. I was raped, deprived of food and forced to undergo three abortions (all fathered and aborted by Doc himself).” These are the ravings of Teal Swan.

If you haven’t heard of the lady, she is a modern mystic. And a con woman. She has been interviewed by the mainstream media, and at least some of her claims have been investigated to no effect. In 2005, she filed a police report in Utah. Suffice it to say no evidence has been adduced to support her eyewitness accounts of the murders of children!


1990: This is an indecent assault rather than a rape case. It is included here because the false accuser RECANTED after 20 years. Ian Henderson is accused of indecent assault by the 14 year old Carrie Crownshaw. He is convicted and given a 3 year sentence at Acton Crown Court, serving 16 months. In 2010, Crownshaw goes to the police, apparently wracked with guilt. By this time, she is a married woman and mother of four. In May 2008, she is given a suspended sentence at Harrow Crown Court.


February 1990: Kellie Waddell accuses a former colleague of raping her in late August 1979. Seriously? Dr Varga is tried and acquitted; the Crown appeals, but the Court of Appeal for Toronto dismisses said appeal in May 1994. Here is the judgment. If you read this, it is clear that not only would the rape have been doubtful due to the layout of the room where it was alleged to have taken place, but that this woman had serious alcohol problems. The Crown complained that her cross-examination at trial was tantamount to character assassination. And a false allegation of rape is not?


February 5, 1990: In Nashua, New Hampshire, teenager Jennifer Cleveland is arrested and charged with falsely reporting a rape. Click here for more.


February 5, 1990: A woman makes an early morning call - like 12.30am early - on Pittsburgh dentist Clinton Runco. They are both married, though not to each other, and she is in fact the wife of a close friend of the good doctor, although one doubts that friendship survived this incident. The two had sex - she said it was rape; he said it was consensual. Although the case was dropped, ostensibly for medical reasons, the woman had psychiatric problems and had made a false rape allegation before.

This article appeared in the Pittsburgh Post-Gezette, November 6, 1990, page 5. One would have expected some sort of disciplinary action (not to mention divorce proceedings!) to be taken against Runco for what was clearly unprofessional behaviour, but twenty and more years on he was still practising.


February 9, 1990: At Nashua, New Hampshire, teenager Anne Marie Baker is arrested and charged with filing a false rape report after admitting she lied in her initial interview.

[The above is based on a report by Kris Frieswick in the New Hampshire Sunday News, February 18, 1990, page 11A, (accessed through NewsBank)].


March 13, 1990: Personality Characteristics Of Falsely Accusing Parents In Custody Disputes by Hollida Wakefield and Ralph Underwager.

You can ignore the babble in the above paper about personality disorders; the bottom line is that in custody disputes some people - men as well as women - play very dirty indeed.


March 23, 1990: Carol Moores is allegedly raped in her own home by Wayne Green. She appears to have made this claim officially for the first time on June 23, 1990 in the particulars of a civil action rather than in a police witness statement. Carol Ann Moores v Wayne Rory Green is heard in the Portsmouth County Court later that year, and results in a 5 figure judgment for the plaintiff. However, afterwards, evidence comes to light that totally undermines the rape allegation. On June 6, 1991, the judgment was overturned. You can read what the Court of Appeal said here.

The following day, writing in the London Times, Justin Rollins said: “New evidence showed however, that during the time Mr Green was said to have been at her home, Mrs Moores had two telephone conversations with another former boy friend. BT records were said to show that during the five to ten minutes that she claimed the rape occurred, she was speaking on the telephone.”


March 14, 1990: At Waukesha, Milwaukee, Sheri Stevens claims to have been raped in a hospital car park after being attacked by Michael Lewis and two other men. Lewis spends three months behind bars. Stevens actually claims to have been sexually assaulted twice in ten days, the first time in a restaurant car park. This assault was admitted by Lewis; it was not a rape but a personal dispute.

Stevens repeated the lie on March 28 but recanted in June, and pleaded NO CONTEST to a charge of perjury relating to the second incident. She admits she concocted it, including burning her sweater:

“The statement I gave was a lie...I was afraid he was going to come back after me.” Indeed. Lewis was convicted of a misdemeanor and received probation. She underwent therapy.

[The above is based on a report from The Milwaukee Journal, July 31, 1992, Waukesha Edition III, front page and page W4].


March 15, 1990: American businessman Gary Ramona is confronted by his teenage daughter Holly who asks him: “Why did you rape me?”

He went on to successfully sue therapist Marche Isabella and Dr Richard Rose chief of psychiatry at the Western Medical Center in Anaheim for implanting false memories in her.

This case - notorious and sad in equal measure - needs no citations, but here is an article from 2012 that mentions it.


March 25, 1990: Here is a truly heartwarming story. On said date, George Fitch of Fairfax, Virginia is arrested for the rape of his girlfriend. At his trial on August 8, 1990, Rachael Ann Butler recants, saying she made up the allegation because she was angry at him. On November 29, 1990, she is convicted of giving false testimony and sentenced to 2 months behind bars. The above chronology seems suspect because the linked report from The Free Lance-Star for January 31, 1991, page 35, says they were reunited 2 months after his arrest and married the day after his acquittal. Which begs the question why did the case go to trial?


March 28, 1990: Kept woman Zoora Shah tells Bradford police she was raped by Mir Aslam. Later she claims to have been raped multiple times by her lover Mohammed Azam. On December 21, 1993, she is convicted at Leeds Crown Court of the murder of Mr Azam and other offences. Dedicated feminist liars have totally rewritten the history of this case; don’t believe a word they say! The Court of Appeal got it right.


April 10, 1990: The judge presiding over the trial of German businessman Dieter Kemp comes under fire for telling the jury “women don’t always mean no when they say no”.

Mr Kemp is acquitted; he and the non-victim had drunk three bottles of champagne, saki, and smoked cannabis before having sex at his King’s Road apartment. Another ludicrous case that should not have got anywhere near a courtroom.

[The above is based on a report published originally in the Times, April 12, 1990 - no page number given, accessed here through NewsBank Newspapers - U.K. and Ireland].


May 3, 1990: Teenagers Angela Stevens (also spelt Stephens) and Brandi Flodin tell police at Moscow, Idaho they were raped by two migrant workers. On May 4, Miguel Beltran Munguia and Feliciano Pena Rodriguez find themselves behind bars where they remain for 78 days. The girls planned and synchronised the false allegation, but were not able to give a coherent reason for doing so. File this one under CAPRICE.

It was Stevens who came clean. In July 1990, both girls are indicted for perjury. In November 1990, Stevens is told she must serve 72 days in gaol (clearly a quid pro quo for the time the men served). She is also ordered to address her substance abuse issues, as reported by The Daily News (Pullman, Washington), November 8, 1990, page 8A.


May 3, 1990: At Schenectady, New York, Valerie Adams claims to have been raped at knifepoint. This was the third time she had claimed to have been raped in three years, and was third time unlucky for her, especially as her lies led to an innocent man spending six months behind bars. This report from The Daily Gazette, January 23, 1991, tells how she was indicted by a grand jury that month.

Just before she was about to be sentenced, she decided to fire her attorney, apparently unsatisfied with the plea bargain he had negotiated.


May 22, 1990: This disturbing report so dated is from the Dutch language newspaper Het Vrije Volk, page 5. The translation says an appeal court in The Hague cleared a 53 year old man of raping his own daughter. This one is complicated, but he had been convicted at Rotterdam. It began when the man tried to end his daughter’s relationship with her drug addict husband by convincing her to make a false allegation against him. His actions appear to have boomeranged.


June 1, 1990: The Supreme Court of Victoria quashes the convictions of radiographer Vincenzo Mobilio who...boy, is this a weird one? Read the judgment carefully and see if you can make more of it than I can. What can I say? File this one under GENUINE MISTAKE. This guy had no bedside manner at all, but seriously, shouldn’t women always be chaperoned at times like this? That would avoid false allegations, true allegations and misunderstandings like this appears to have been.


July 16, 1990: In Ohio, a woman facing a charge of driving under the influence is booked into the Lucas County Jail. Shortly, she claims to have been raped. Medical evidence says something different. This report is taken from The Blade, FINAL HOME, (Toledo, Ohio), July 23, 1990, page 11.


August 6, 1990: This is as good a date for this case as any. A Louisiana woman who has joint custody with her ex-husband takes her daughter to the doctor for a routine examination. The girl is found to have a vaginal irritation, and guess who is accused of sexual abuse? This started as a GENUINE MISTAKE but if you read this judgment you’ll see it didn’t take long for malice to creep in.


August 6, 1990: Arthur Clark of Crystal River is arrested for the rape of Cindy Fisher; in the words of Judge Gary Graham: “This was a violent rape of a total stranger upon a public thoroughfare” adding “The weight of the evidence against the defendant is great”.

Fisher gave a detailed description of her alleged attacker down to his jewellery, but on August 31, Arthur Lee Clark is released from gaol, and on September 18, Cindy Annette Fisher is arrested and charged with false reporting.

[The above is based on the report by Keith Morelli in The Tampa Tribune, FLORIDA Edition, September 20, 1990, page 1, (accessed here through NewsBank)].


August 7/8, 1990: At Bowling Green, Kentucky, a woman is allegedly raped in a nursing home. Later that week, the allegation is ruled false. What happened? The clue is in the woman’s age - 92. This report is from a local newspaper, the Daily News, August 10, 1990, page 2-A


August 10, 1990: A 13 year old girl from Colbert reports being kidnapped at knifepoint from her home and raped. Later that month she tells a Spokane detective she made it all up. This report is from The Spokesman Review, August 21, 1990, page B2.


September 10, 1990: At Inverness, Florida, an unnamed man is acquitted of the 1984 rape of his own daughter, who was 9 years old at the time. She claimed he began fondling her at the age of 5, and raped her weekly when she was 9. The girl made these allegations only in 1989. This article appeared on page 1B of the Ocala Star-Banner the same day. Can you spot the deliberate spelling mistake.


October 31, 1990: A white student is not raped by two men on the campus at George Washington University. This claim appeared initially in the student newspaper GW Hatchet. The phantom assailants were described as having “particularly bad body odor”, they laughed at the victim, and one said “You were pretty good for a white girl.”

The author of the hoax was soon revealed: “independent rape counselor” Mariam Kashani. Needless to say, black students in particular were not amused, especially as an accomplice made a phone call posing as a police officer to confirm the allegation. File this one under both CAMPUS ACCUSER/FEMINIST BRAINWASHING and PROFESSIONAL LIAR.

In 2007, a Jewess studying at this university claimed to have been targeted by a hate campaign - some anonymous individual drawing swastikas on her door. You guessed, she was doing it herself. She was caught out by a concealed camera. And the response? She needed help.


November 10, 1990: The 71 year old Saratosa doctor Herbert Karol is accused of raping one of his patients. She claims to have been raped 9 days earlier, so there is no physical evidence. The doctor is arrested on December 13, 1990, and what happens next is something we see so often in such cases, other victims come forward with their own allegations of sexual impropriety, although in this case none of rape, apparently. Fortunately, the case goes nowhere. This article is from the Saratosa Herald-Tribune, June 21, 1991, page 4B.


November 12, 1990: This article relating to the Rochdale ritual abuse scandal appeared on page 5 of the London Evening Standard, LATE PRICES EXTRA.

You can find a lot more about this and other ludicrous ritual abuse scandals on the Religious Tolerance website. See the entry for February 1987 - the Cleveland sexual abuse scandal - that kicked off this nonsense in the UK.


November 13, 1990: Holly Turner of Clarkston, Idaho is pulled over by a state trooper for driving erratically, and says she has been raped by her stepfather - as you would do. She is taken to hospital for an examination, but two days later, she recants. The scratches on her person were self-inflicted. This report from the local press, is best viewed at 50%.


November 18, 1990: A report in the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette by staff writer Jan Ackerman says Judge Robert E. Dauer cleared the gynecologist Dr J.T. Shah of raping three women in his Mount Lebanon surgery. The rapes were alleged to have taken place on February 28, 1985, in March 1985 and September 25, 1987.

This is a weird but by no means unique case. Two of the complainants were said not to have been present at the time, and the doctor’s wife said she was present at the time of the third alleged assault. There was a fourth accuser whose testimony was not considered strong enough to present to a trial court. Curiously, in February 1995, a different Dr Shah was convicted of sexually assaulting one of his patients during a gynecological examination. He too faced multiple accusers.


December 3, 1990: This is not a straightforward allegation of rape but is included here because of the false allegations of sexual fondling that pre-dated it. On said date, Dewayne Stamper is due to stand trial for statutory rape. He seeks to adduce evidence that his accuser has falsely accused three other men of sexual fondling. After careful deliberation, the North Carolina court allows his request. Believe the children, indeed.


Circa 1991: Sabrina Dean files a rape allegation against a man she knows, but withdraws it the next day. In 1996, she is robbed and raped by Lajarrette Booker who tries to use this and a prior suicide attempt to undermine his conviction. The appeal goes to the Arkansas Supreme Court, and is dismissed.


March 12, 1991: In New York State, a high school student tells police she was snatched off the street by two males, taken to nearby woods, then raped and sodomised. By the following afternoon, an intensive investigation reveals this claim to be totally false. Sonya Lashea Wallace is charged with a misdemeanor and taken to hospital for a psychiatric evaluation. This report is from the New York newspaper The Daily Gazette, March 14, 1991, page B1.


March 21, 1991: Violence Against Women: The Increase of Rape in America 1990

The above document is an hysterical piece of feminist propaganda disguised as an official American Government document. Where to begin?

Page 14: Were American women really 20 times more likely to be raped than in Portugal, 26 times more likely than in Japan, and 15 times more likely than in England?

Page 15: And here we go again “...rape is the crime least often reported to the authorities”. One more time, how does anyone know? And if rape is so difficult to report, why are false rapes so easy to report? Incredibly, the word false does not appear once in the entire document.


March 30, 1991: Patricia Bowman has consensual sex with William Kennedy Smith in the small hours, then cries rape. The two had met at a bar in Palm Beach. The case goes to trial, and he is acquitted, wisely taking the stand to deny the allegations.

This was not the first time Kennedy Smith had been accused of rape; three other women claimed he had raped or attempted to rape them previously, but the judge would not allow them to testify. This is one of the perils of celebrity culture, or in this case, simply having a famous name.


April 1991: Airhead Mindy Brickman accuses a fellow Princeton student of rape, although not to the police. Her claim soon falls apart, and she recants in print the following month.

Would you believe she went on to become a lawyer, and, ironically, a member of the Anti-Defamation League?


May 10, 1991: Sharon Albino is kidnapped at gunpoint by Keith Ensey and raped. Or is she? Click here for more.


May 10, 1991: Charges (52 counts) are filed against San Diego man Dale Akiki; further charges are filed in February 1992. This well-known absurd ritual abuse case needs no citations. The volunteer at Faith Chapel nursery school was accused primarily because of his physical appearance. The allegations against him included raping and sodomising children galore. And of killing an elephant and a giraffe in the classroom! The trial dragged on for seven months and resulted in him being cleared of all charges. He spent two and a half years on remand.

This excellent ten minute documentary about the case was made in 2007.


June 1, 1991: This report so dated from The Gainesville Sun, page 4B tells the sad tale of teenager Renee Hester who was kidnapped and raped at gunpoint the previous weekend. Well, it wasn’t quite so sad because she was neither kidnapped nor raped, but she was arrested and charged with filing a false report. It remains to be seen though why she had to resort to this as one female police officer claimed.


June 3, 1991: Andrea Lloyd is given a two year sentence at the Central Criminal Court for a false rape allegation aggravated by both fraud and a false allegation of violence.


June 21, 1991: Englishman Professor Michael Patterson, a lecturer in Theatre at the University of Ulster in Coleraine, Northern Ireland is arrested, interrogated over several hours, then charged with rape and buggery. He is released on bail.

Here, he tells his own story in more graphic detail than related to the Belfast Telegraph in November 2002. It was only after the further allegations this student made that the penny finally dropped with the police. Little Miss Anonymous remained so; let’s hope she didn’t go on to inflict misery on another innocent man with her bizarre fantasies.

The reader is invited to compare the above with false accuser Katherine Clifton.


July 1991: Michael O’Malley is accused of raping Barbara Trapp multiple times. He is charged with five counts of sexual assault and spends some time behind bars, but a lengthy investigation shows her allegations to be without foundation. In spite of this, she is not charged with false reporting, but with the aid of an idealistic lawyer, O’Malley sues Trapp for defamation, and in December 1993, a Wisconsin jury awards him $12,000 damages. Realistically they could have added a naught to that, even though he had little chance of recovering anything from this pathetic woman. This article from the Milwaukee Sentinel gives an insight into her motives.


July 13, 1991: Here is another sad tale, in this Press Association report so dated, Francis Reynolds who was due to stand trial at Manchester Crown Court was found dead in a canal. His false accuser - a schoolgirl and A VIRGIN - had made false rape allegations (plural) before against others.


July 18, 1991: Around 10.30pm, Kathleen Mary Gregson knocks on a door in Tilbury and tells the householder she has been raped, ostensibly by a stranger. She looks the part, and is crying. The police are called, she is taken to a police station and medically examined; it is confirmed she has had intercourse consistent with rape. She is taken to hospital where she is also treated for an injured ankle, then taken home.

Less than three hours after her report, the accused is arrested at the home of his parents. Kathleen Gregson is taken back to the police station at 3pm on July 19; she makes a lengthy statement. Five hours later, the officers who had been questioning the suspect, question her, at which point she admits she knew him and that the sex had been consensual! She makes a second statement retracting everything, and after 20 hours 35 minutes, Mr Anonymous is released.

After pleading guilty to doing an act tending and intended to pervert the course of public justice, she was given a 9 month sentence at Chelmsford Crown Court. At the time of her appeal, May 21, 1992, she was 49 years old; her victim was much younger. Her sentence was reduced to four months.

[The above is a summary of this reported case from the Westlaw database].


August 2, 1991: In Davis, California, Janet Berger tells police that on July 29, she was gang-raped by five skateboarding youths on a cycle path. Two weeks later, she tells a rape counsellor she simply fell off her bicycle, and doesn’t understand why she made such a claim. This false report appears to have generated enormous public outrage.


August 9, 1991: A woman claims rapper Joseph Simmons raped her in his hotel room on said date after a concert in Cleveland. On August 23, he is indicted on three counts of rape and one count each of kidnapping and sexual imposition. Rappers are bad dudes, right? On February 22, 1992, it is reported that all the charges have been dropped when it comes to light the woman is a SERIAL FALSE ACCUSER.


September 8-12, 1991: The notorious Tailhook Scandal. A massive mythology has grown up over this convention in Las Vegas, but at least two of the women involved lied brazenly; Elizabeth Warnick who claimed she had been gang-raped admitted to her lies on the witness stand. The authors of this article may have an agenda, but they have probably come as close to what really happened as anyone.


October 2, 1991: 1 IN 5 LIE IN MAKING RAPE CHARGES by Amanita Duga. Click here for more.


October 7, 1991: The American actress Roseanne Barr accuses both her parents of physically and sexually abusing when she was young. Here is a tiny sample. Twenty years later, she is not so sure, although she did read The Courage To Heal - nuff said!


Halloween, 1991: This is the date the 17 year old Donna Smith first made specific allegations against her father; the date is very revelant because this another of those bizarre memory abberration cases, this time from Maryland. You can read some background to it here.

Thankfully, it had a happy ending of sorts, because eventually the girl faced up to her delusions.


Circa December 1991: A girl known only as Heather T, apparently aged 14, tells her mother she has been forcibly raped, showing her torn clothing as evidence. She repeats the story to a hospital nurse and to the police. Then she claims she had consensual sex with an unidentified male. The first claim was definitely not true. Later, she claims that Jessie L. Redmond who might be described as some kind of social worker, propositioned her, offering her drugs for sex on October 31, 1992. Redmond is given a typically heavy sentence for exploiting a position of trust to have sex with an underage girl. On February 14, 2001, the United States Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit, reverses his conviction.


Circa 1992: The woman known three years later as Lashonta Harrison tells family members that she has been raped in order to provide an excuse for coming home late, but recants the allegation just before the police are called.

Convicted rapist Anthony Lynn Wyrick rapes Lashonta Harrison on July 26, 1997. He is tried by Knox County Criminal Court, convicted, and because he is a violent repeat offender, is given life without parole. He appeals, and the Court of Criminal Appeals of Tennessee reveals to the world the facts in the previous paragraph. Although his appeal was successful, justice caught up with Wyrick in 2016 when he was convicted of the 1985 rape of two teenage girls based principally on DNA evidence.


1992: A woman accuses her own brother of raping her. Thirty-five years previously. The unnamed man stands trial at Tuscaloosa County Circuit Court in January 1996, and fortunately is found not guilty. Why does anyone take these head cases seriously?

This article was published in The Tuscaloosa New, January 11, 1996, page 1B.


1992: The autistic Betsy Wheaton accuses her own father of raping her. Or does she? This is a clip of her from the 1993 documentary Prisoners Of Silence.


1992: FALSE BUT SINCERE ACCUSATIONS OF SEXUAL ASSAULT MADE BY NARCOTIC PATIENTS, by P. Hays, published in the MEDICO-LEGAL JOURNAL, Vol 60 Part 4 1992, pages 265-71.

The above was probably published in the fourth quarter of the year, but I have decided in my infinite wisdom to put it at the beginning.

Yes, I know the word NARCOLEPTIC sounds correct, but the title really does say NARCOTIC. At the time it was published, the author was based in Canada, University of Alberta.

He reports four anonymised but interesting cases: two 42 year old women; a 39 year old man; and a 31 year old woman. The second patient - a single mother - described being raped by a police officer and later by her boss. She wondered how they could have done this then carried on their regular (non-intimate) relationships without batting an eyelid. Now you know.


1992: Accused of sexually assaulting his 7 year old stepdaughter, Dale Duke pleads no contest. [See the cases of Ray Spencer (February 1985) and Brian Banks (July 8, 2002) to understand why an innocent man might do this]. He is given a heavy sentence. The girl recants in 1998, but this is ignored by the court. In March 2011, evidence comes to light that the child was coached. In November the same year, a Dallas court overturns his conviction.


January 5, 1992: Roy Wade of Peoria, Illinois is accused of raping a teenager thirty years his junior. The girl is said to have told a friend in the first instance, but three days later it is reported by Detective Pat Rabe that she made it up.

[The above is based on a report in the Journal Star, January 8, 1992, page C1, (accessed here through NewsBank)].


February 1992: This story from Grand Rapids, Michigan, is both sad and shocking because it involves the conviction of an innocent teen, Quentin Carter, a mere boy of sixteen, a waste of youth, and the actual rape of a ten year old girl. Read a bit about it here if you wish, but watch this two minute video, and don’t be ashamed to shed a tear. File under FALSE AND TRUE.


February 7, 1992: A report in the London Times, so dated, page 7, reveals that a young woman named Wilma Wetherow had been given a 3 month sentence at Bow Street for making hoax phone calls to the police in which she said she was being raped.


February 14, 1992: A young woman takes a taxi from Leicester Square to Southgate (which is actually in North London), and would you believe she is raped at gunpoint by the driver? The police did, the fiend was a black man, or he would have been had he existed.

This report is from the London Evening Standard LATE PRICES EXTRA, February 21, 1992, page 18. The reference to forensic tests is explained in A far cry from the truth?

This is the initial report from the London Evening Standard LATE PRICES EXTRA, February 18, 1992, page 2. As will be clear from the Brixton incident, as well as demented women there are real monsters out there.


March 1992: This is another insane HISTORICAL CASE, this time from Newfoundland. Twenty years after it never happened, a woman decides she was raped by her uncle, and he is charged. She was 11 or 12 at the time, she says; the time frame is 1971/2, winter months. He was tried by a judge only, and acquitted. Here is the judgment; the defence evidence (or The Defenee Evidence - as it is spelt) is very telling, see in particular the reference to the basement.

Was this woman simply lying? No. If you’ve read this far you’ll realise that false accusers of this kind are so dangerous because they believe their delusions.


March 4, 1992: Saleswoman Linda Johnson visits Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio, where she claims to have been kidnapped, raped and robbed. She said the attack happened around 7.30pm in a parking lot. Chief of detectives Major Leonard Strawderman and Cuyahoga Falls police spend over a hundred hours investigating her allegations before concluding she made it all up. She was examined at Akron City Hospital where it was determined she had not been raped.

Although this appears to be her first and hopefully only false rape allegation, there is evidence she has made at least one false allegation before, possibly an insurance scam. At the time of this report she also had warrants (plural) outstanding for alleged financial crimes. She admitted the robbery was a hoax but would not talk about the (phantom) rape.

[The above is based on a report by Robert Hoiles and Eric Sandstrom published in the Akron Beacon Journal, 1 STAR Edition, March 13, 1992, page B1, (accessed here through NewsBank)].


March 12, 1992: Stafford County woman Pamela Jenkins fakes her abduction and rape. She is found wandering barefoot the next morning. After a 5 day investigation she admits she was neither kidnapped nor raped. When she appears in court the following July, she is given a complex sentence that includes spending a month behind bars. This report was published in The Free Lance-Star (Fredericksburg, Virginia), July 27, 1992, page C8.


March 15, 1992: Tammy McElreath meets obstetrician Dr Joe Wardlaw of Commerce, Georgia, then accuses him of rape. Two days later, she recants. Her husband Dennis is then charged with several offences including attempted extortion.


March 31, 1992: Female serial killer Aileen Wuornos tells a Florida court that her first victim raped her. Richard Mallory was murdered by Wuornos on November 30, 1989. Although he was a convicted sex offender, Mallory did not rape Wuornos; in her first statement she claimed only that she thought he had intended to rape her.


April 15, 1992: Gary Blevins of Florence, Alabama is cleared of sexual offences against a 14 year old girl who claimed to have been violated by him over a period of 2 years. The girl said she had been raped by her stepfather too. The State called a so-called rape counsellor to testify as a supposed expert witness; although Jane Gilbert testified that the girl’s behaviour was typical of sexual abuse victims, she admitted under cross-examination that non-rape victims exhibit similar behaviour. In other words, rape trauma syndrome is a vacuous concept. Wisely, Blevins took the stand in his own defense.

This report is from the page 1C of the TimesDaily (Florence, Alabama), the following day.


May 6, 1992: At Roanoke, Virginia, a thirteen year old girl comes home late and tells her father an horrific story: she was kidnapped and beaten by four unknown white men. Later, they become black men - Jamaicans - who drove her around for several hours in an apparent attempt to confuse her. Finally, two young men - Darren Cobbs and William Dungee - are said to have raped her.

DNA tests show the girl has indeed had sex, but not with these two dudes. The following April it is reported that District Attorney Alice Ekrich had filed for discontinuation. There is a lot more to this case, there may have been a personal motive for her falsely accusing these two men, albeit at the third attempt. There was also evidence the girl had had consensual sex with other men (plural), the same day. Girls like this need locking up for their own protection.

[The above is based on a report by Laurence Hammick in The Roanoke Times, METRO Edition, April 3, 1993, page A-1, (accessed here through NewsBank)].


May 7, 1992: In Washington State, three underage teenage girls are charged with motoring offences after taking a vehicle without permission. When they were stopped the previous month, they claimed they were on their way to the hospital because one of them had been raped. Stupidity compounded.

This article appeared in The Spokesman-Review, May 12, 1992, page B2.


May 18, 1992: Rape ‘victims’ sometimes do lie: this excellent article by Alan Dershowitz appeared in the Wilmington, North Carolina newspaper the Morning Star, page 7A.

This was also published elsewhere, for example in the Boston Herald under the title When women cry rape and lie - I found that through NewsBank.


June 1992: A young married woman named Danielle Warren claims to have been raped in Lakeland, Florida. She tells police she was attacked by a man who appeared to be having car trouble. No one is arrested, and the July 16, 1992 issue of the Lakeland Ledger quotes Sergeant Randy Harrison of the Lakeland Police Department:

“We located a witness who knew where she was at the time of the attack. She wouldn’t admit it, but the attack was unfounded and the case is closed”. He added she was having marital problems.


July 1992: Annette Howard accuses her ex-husband John Howard of marital rape. This case was played out in the civil courts - at Wake County, North Carolina - with a predictable result. This report is from the Morning Star (Wilmington, North Carolina), August 10, 1994, pages 1B & 2B. Coincidentally, in the UK, another defamation case - Wraith v Wraith - was also played out in 1994. That too ended with a victory for the plaintiff husband and, in that case (which was not about an allegation of sexual abuse), nominal damages.


July 16, 1992: A mother of three is allegedly raped in her backyard while her daughter is watching television indoors. Although she does not identify her assailant, she gives significant details about him; she also claims he had been stalking her for weeks. In late September, it is reported that Rockbridge County Sheriff Bob Day had concluded the woman was not telling the truth.

She underwent medical tests, the results of which were not disclosed, but from the details I have seen she was a HEAD CASE, which is presumably the reason the authorities decided not to prosecute her. The reader is invited to compare this case with that of Gail Sherwood.

[The above is based on a report by Victoria Ratcliff in The Roanoke Times, STATE Edition, September 23, 1992, page A1, (accessed here through NewsBank)].


July 29, 1992: A far cry from the truth? by Isabel Tang.

The above article is from the Guardian, Women’s Section, page 17. MRAs, MGTOWs and people who understand these things will recognise the de rigueur feminist narrative which minimises the scale of false rape allegations. Julie Bindel is quoted, false allegations she says come from men, ie “She wanted it”, but it doesn’t stop there. She cites an anonymous case given to her by a Manchester detective of a woman posing as a child making calls to the police claiming she had been sexually assaulted. When they traced her “It turned out she was in fact an adult who was relating experiences that had happened years ago, when she was sexually assaulted by her father. She could only now talk about it because her father had recently died” - and was unable to defend himself. Pathetic.

The Cypriot woman alluded to here is Georgina Kyriakou, see entry for April 1989, (above). For the taxi driver false rape allegation, see entry for February 14, 1992, (above).


September 1992: An unnamed woman accuses her husband of...well, read the judgment in this insane Canadian case, then ask yourself how any court could have found her fit to have sole custody of their infant son instead of committing her to the nearest booby hatch.


September 1992: Susan Gooch meets a stranger in a restaurant, the two have sex in a shop doorway then on a Metropolitan Line train between Baker Street and Harrow.

For whatever reason, she then accuses her work colleague, a younger man named David Dunn, of raping her on the train. He is arrested. He is also sacked, although when the truth comes out, he is reinstated.

Incredibly, even her victim parrots the de rigueur narrative. In the October 27, 1993 issue of the Daily Mirror he was quoted thus: “In doing it, she’s also hurt all genuine rape victims who will probably now have a harder time putting their case to the police.”

According to The Independent, October 27, 1993, when she appeared at the Central Criminal Court to face two charges of attempting to pervert the course of justice, Gooch said in a statement read by the prosecution: “Although I thought it was rape, I accept I was not in fact raped.”

She received probation for this outrage, two years. And was ordered to pay £1,000 prosecution costs.


September 1, 1992: Restricting the Admissibility of Expert Testimony in Child Sexual Abuse Prosecutions: Pennsylvania Takes It to the Extreme by Lisa R. Askowitz.

The above article from the University of Miami Law Review covers a lot of ground including the (non-existent) child sexual abuse accommodation syndrome, but there is an interesting observation on page 205:

“...recent studies have indicated that mental health professionals may encourage false accusations of sexual abuse through improper interviewing methods.”

Talk about a classic understatement.


September 9, 1992: A report in the Daily Mirror, page 13 (accessed here through NewsBank Newspapers - U.K. and Ireland) says that thanks to the paper, Stephen Townsend was cleared of sexual assault. He had been accused of participating in the gang-rape of a nightclub dancer, who went to Ibiza where she made similar claims against four men. A Spanish judge dropped those charges when it transpired she’d had sex with thirty men on her holiday, something to which she had consented. The charge against Townsend was dropped by Wolverhampton magistrates.


September 21, 1992: So-called feminist Camille Paglia explains to Bob Costas why she is so disdainful about the concept of date rape.

While she talks a lot of sense, I must point out that I don’t go anything like as far as the Woody Woodpecker of Reason on the issue of consent. A good indication is when the lady starts taking her clothes off, and if she starts taking yours off too, you’re home and dry!


October 1992:Rape allegations: sorting the wheat from the chaff by Charles P. McDowell.

The above from the journal of the Association of Police Surgeons - pages 29-30 - is a straightforward, honest article by a medical professional.


October 24, 1992: Norma Reeder is allegedly raped by Timothy Denton and another man. Click here for more.


October 10, 1992: At Schinveld in the Netherlands, a woman claims to have been raped and robbed on the way home the previous night, October 9. The police carry out an extensive investigation - no robbery; no rape.

This report is from the Dutch newspaper imburgs agblad, October 31, 1992, page 13.


October 13, 1992: The alluringly named Flores Faye Knife of Saskatchewan reports her rape in the evening, about an hour after it didn’t happen. She goes to hospital, makes three statements, then recants them all. She is convicted of public mischief. She tells her shrink she was sexually assaulted when she was 12 years old, and suffered several abusive common law relationships. Like we should believe that. He said she was suffering from rape trauma syndrome (which does not exist) but the court took an entirely different view. Curiously, the appeal court found that although the actus reus had been proved, she lacked mens rea, apparently because she had no motive. Her conviction was quashed. Like when did any of these mad cows require a (rational) motive to make a false rape allegation or report?


October 18, 1992: Woman sues mom for $4M in alleged incest case by M.A.J. McKenna. Click here for more.


October 18, 1992: This article so dated reports on the case of Deborah Ford who had recently accused a man in Manhattan of rape. He was promptly arrested, and almost as promptly, it became clear that he rather than she was the victim.

It was shortly established that she had made false allegations including rape as far back as September 25, 1986. I can’t help feeling sorry for this woman, who was said to be homeless. Still, I doubt she was homeless for long!


October 31, 1992: This one is a Halloween night prank with a difference. As reported by the Ocala Star-Banner, October 7, 1993, page 28, Wanda Mary Normile has sex with an acquaintance to give the appearance of rape. Then, get this, her brother James Burke ties her up in her Orlando hotel room and beats her, quite badly it appears. File this one under GIVE ME MONEY.

A decade and a half later it was reported that James Burke died in March 1994, while Wanda Mary Normile (alias Wanda Mary Burke alias Wanda Mary Cleveland alias Leah Ann Kelly) pleaded guilty to theft and falsely reporting a crime; she was sentenced to three and a half years. The whole family appear to be total scum.


November 24, 1992: On this date in The Hague, a female soldier is said to have reported a rape during an exercise by three other soldiers. The report was false; this is one of the main reasons women shouldn’t serve in the armed forces, at least not alongside men.

This article appeared in the Dutch newspaper imburgs agblad, December 18, 1992, page 3.


November 30, 1992: A 13 year old South Carolina girl is apparently abducted by three men, and raped. Thomas Cope is arrested December 3 and held until December 16. The girl’s initial story was plausible, especially as she was found walking almost naked and in a distressed state. Although there is no racial aspect to it, this story is reminiscent of the 1987 Tawana Brawley case. This report appeared on the front page of the Herald-Journal (Spartanburg), February 11, 1993.

[For the avoidance of doubt, the above (American) Thomas Cope is not to be confused with the (English) serial rapist of the same name].


Circa 1993: Serial false accuser D.A. makes her first false rape allegation at the age of 9. She goes on to falsely accuse her brother-in-law Willie Baker, who is convicted.


1993: Kevin Peterson is convicted of abusing both his daughter and his son - “sexual contact short of rape” - and is given a 15 year sentence. He is released only in November 2007. Years later, both kids recant saying they were coerced by their mother and stepfather.


1993: The Morning After: Sex, Fear and Feminism by Katie Roiphe.

According to the Amazon UK website, the paperback edition of this excellent book was published January 17, 1994. Here is my review.


January 1993: Mahila Vinod Kumar files a report accusing two men of raping her. For whatever reason, the case drags on for a decade and a half. On November 28, 2001, the men are acquitted, then the girl finds herself in the dock. Finally, she is given a 3 month sentence by a court in Madhya Pradesh, which is upheld by the Supreme Court in July 2008.


January 1993: Student Matthew Kydd has sex with a fellow student at university; he says it was consensual; she says otherwise. In November 1993, a jury at Norwich Crown Court takes just 35 minutes to decide whose version they prefer. This was one of a number of notorious date rape cases that should never have been brought.


January 1, 1993: The Illinois State Legislature passes the Ritualised Abuse Of A Child Act, Illinois State Law #87-1167.

Under this law a person commits a felony if he “Actually or in simulation, tortures, mutilates, or sacrifices any warm-blooded animal or human being”.

Which probably explains why horror films are made in Hollywood rather than Chicago.


January 3, 1993: A woman claims to have been raped at knifepoint in the fitting room of a San Diego store, a report that is said to have generated both a $10,000 reward and more publicity tha all the reported rapes in San Diego - real and imagined - the previous year. Later that month it is revealed that the only place this rape happened was in the victim’s head. This report appeared in the Los Angeles Times. Most interesting is the claim therein that she recanted only after being promised she would not face prosecution. Since when did the police in America or anywhere else allow suspects to dictate to them in such a fashion?

The sickening details can be found in Deceiving Others/Deceiving Oneself... (below); it makes disturbing reading.


January 21, 1993: Researching the “Rape Culture” of America... by Christina Hoff Sommers.

I can’t be absolutely certain about the publication date of the above, but this is the earliest one I have found. Christina Hoff Sommers calls herself a feminist - not in my book, she ain’t. She has written at length on rape and related subjects, and is a prolific debunker of feminist lies. Herein she tackles inter alia the Koss study. The one fault of this article is that she has fallen for the claptrap about prison rape.


January 25, 1993: An unnamed Australian man has sex with his ex-wife. Theirs was a rather unusual relationship, and this last act of passion ended with him standing trial for rape. He was acquitted August 17, 1993.


January 28, 1993: A young woman is allegedly raped by two men at Pichhore, India. She tells her father and her uncle, then the police. To put it midly, this case is complex, and is not resolved until July 11, 2008 when the Supreme Court of India announces: “The evil of perjury has assumed alarming propositions in cases depending on oral evidence and in order to deal with the menace effectively it is desirable for the courts to use the provision more effectively and frequently than it is presently done.”

Check out the entry for October 2014 for an uncanny sense of déjà vu.


January 29, 1993: Ellen Smith is sentenced at the Central Criminal Court. She went the extra mile, slashing her thighs with a broken wine glass to frame her lover John Pickard. There is not much information available on this case, but what if he hadn’t had an alibi?


February 3, 1993: Mary Bogdanowicz tells police that on said date she was raped, beaten and sodomised by 4 black men, giving them a detailed description. Two days later she gives another statement, changing her story. By the time this report was published in the New York newspaper The Daily Gazette, February 11, 1993, page B5, it is clear these black men existed only in her tiny mind.


February 3, 1993: Laura Goldman is allegedly raped by Thomas Lee at his Palm Beach home. She does not file charges, but begins harassing him, bunny boiler style. Lee pays her $200,000 to stop harassing him! She is still not satisfied, and ends up in court. This report is a simplified page from the archive of the New York Daily News. She flees to Israel but after a lengthy battle she is extradited, and ends up with a mere five years of probation in 2009. In March 2017, it is reported she had obtained White House press credentials!

File Laura under GIVE ME MONEY to begin with.


Circa March 1993: During divorce proceedings, Idelle Cowles accuses her husband Orvando of sexually assaulting their daughter. Although not a false rape allegation, this is a particularly obsessive case of PARENTAL ALIENATION SYNDROME which the gullibles fell for.

Fortunately, the Los Angeles courts would have none of it; here is what appears to be the final judgment.


March 4, 1993: This report appeared on page 3 of the Islington Gazette on said date. Keith Sole who had been facing rape and other charges at Bedford, has the case against him withdrawn.


March 12, 1993: David Lehrman of Newmarket, Ontario is arrested for sexually abusing his autistic son, Derek.

Clock up another false allegation care of Facilitated Communication; see entry for Prisoners Of Silence.


April 1993: According to the London Times, August 26, 1993, page 1 - a report by James Landale - a Hertfordshire court found a fitness instructor guilty of wasting police time after she staged her own disappearance and alleged rape while suffering from bulimia. She was given a 12 month suspended sentence. The police hunt is said to have cost £20,000.


April 17, 1993: At North Greenbush, New York, a 13 year old girl accuses 5 boys of raping her at knifepoint in her bedroom the previous night. Unsurprisingly, this case attracted wide local coverage. Later she admits the sex was consensual. Leaving aside the fact that she was too young to consent, in view of the ages of her alleged attackers and her admitted lies, this can be classed as a false allegation. This report appeared in the Sunday Gazette Schenectady, June 13, 1993, page F2.

Guys, don’t do this sort of thing, and girls, however old or young you are, don’t even think about it.


May 1993: The Reality Of Repressed Memories is a lengthy article from an academic journal by the world’s leading authority on false memories. Herein, Elizabeth Loftus discusses the damage done to fragile minds by The Courage To Heal, mischief-making therapists, and much more.


May 10, 1993: At Daytona Beach, Florida, Gloria Glenn goes for a ride with two men and has sex with one of them. Shortly she contacts the police and tells them she has been raped. They are both arrested. By May 14, investigators have concluded the sex was consensual; the men are released, and she is arrested. This report is from The News-Journal, May 15, 1993, page 2B.


June 11, 1993: Studies Reveal Suggestibility Of Very Young as Witnesses by Daniel Goleman.

The above article by a psychologist was published in the New York Times. It highlights the problems and dangers with interviewing very young children in cases of alleged sexual abuse, see in particular the reference to the mousetrap experiment.

If you do not have access to specialist scientific journals, check out some of the excellent videos on YouTube on this and similar subjects, then ask yourself how many reports of child sexual abuse have any basis in fact. My guess is very few, certainly where the alleged the perpetrator is female.


June 27, 1993: This one is beyond belief. Four year old Valin Johnson is found dead at her home in Sault Ste. Marie, Ontario. Her uncle - William Mullins-Johnson - who had been babysitting, is accused of sodomising and strangling her. In September 1994, he is convicted. His first appeal is denied in 1996 with a dissenting judgment. He is released in September 2005. In October 2010 he is awarded $4.25 million. Mullins-Johnson was a victim of a later disgraced pathologist, Dr Charles Smith. There was no anal rape, no crime, period.


July 4, 1993: South African cricketer Mark Bredell meets a strange woman near Henley Regatta; the two go into a field where they have sex. Realising what she has done, she cries rape, but she didn’t cry out at the time.

Bredell stands trial at Oxford Crown Court, and in November 1993 is cleared by a jury.

File this under REGRET SEX.


July 19, 1993: An article so dated from the London Times, page 17 - accessed here through NewsBank Newspapers - U.K. and Ireland - reports on the case of a student nurse who claimed she was blindfolded, handcuffed and raped by her police officer boyfriend.

After two months the charges were dropped, so now she is said to be suing him for damages, but interestingly, according to said report she “consented to sex in his bedroom” but protested at being handcuffed and blindfolded with a tie. Doesn’t that sound to you like an admission that she lied about the rape?


July 27, 1993: Jacqueline Padmore is given a sentence totalling 3 years 9 months at the Central Criminal Court: two and a half years for blackmail; a year for assault occasioning actual bodily harm; three years for another blackmail attempt; one year for the theft of a wallet; and nine months for stealing £400 from a kindly pensioner.

The crack addict who was described as a modern highwaywoman would flag down a motorist on a spurious pretext, then once in his car would demand money, and scream rape if he refused. She attacked one motorist on January 28, 1993 - 3 weeks after being released from prison; and another on April 21.

[Her conviction was reported by the London Times, July 28, 1993, page 3].


August 1993: Student Tyjay Hill has sex with a slightly older student in the open at Bangor, Maine. She reports the alleged rape promptly, and unable to make bail, he finds himself locked up until trial. He takes the stand in his own defense - as any innocent man should barring exceptional circumstances. After a two day trial, he is cleared, the lack of physical evidence corroborating his claim that the sex was consensual.

This report appeared in the Bangor Daily News, February 3, 1994, page 15.

[For the avoidance of doubt, the above is not to be confused with the much younger convicted sex offender Tyjay J. Hill].


August 9, 1993: According to James Landale in the Times, August 23, 1993, page 1, a 33 year old hairdresser who claimed to have been kidnapped in her car and sexually assaulted twice (the word rape is not used) may be charged with wasting police time. She was driving through Cardiff when this crime never happened, and the cost of the related police operation was estimated at £100,000.


August 13, 1993: Marlboro police officer Lawrence Moffa is fired by the Mayor. On September 9, 1993, he is indicted for an extortion attempt; he was said to have threatened to file false rape charges against a Framingham man who had failed to pay child support. Weird, huh?

[The above is based on a report in the Worcester Telegram & Gazette (Massachusetts), September 21, 1993, page B4 - accessed through NewsBank].


August 24, 1993: A woman who claimed United States Senator Dave Durenberger raped her in 1963 suffers a setback when a Minnesota judge throws out a lawsuit in which she had accused him of siring her son. Medical evidence proves this is not the case, but some people are never satisfied.


September 1993: A man is accused by his eldest stepdaughter of sexually abusing her from the age of 7 or 8 culminating in 4 acts of rape. He stands trial in October 1994, and is cleared in 14 minutes. There are though care proceedings which go all the way to the House of Lords.

The full judgment can be found here. This can be a little confusing because at paragraph 11 the accuser is alluded to as C, while at paragraph 60 she is alluded to as DI.


September 1, 1993: SEXUAL VIOLENCE Our War Against Rape by Linda Fairstein is published. Click here for more.


Mid-September 1993: Tawana Brawley rides again! At Greenfield, Massachusetts, an anonymous tip off - presumably a phone call - leads to the discovery of a black woman, bound and dumped in a ravine. She claims to have been kidnapped at gunpoint by two white men. Later, she admits there was no rape, no men and no gun.

This report is a screengrab from the NewsBank version of an article by Jacqueline Walsh in The Republican, Springfield, Massachusetts, February 18, 1994, page 13.


September 19, 1993 onwards: This sordid Canadian case contains an unpleasant grain of truth. Extensive allegations of sexual abuse were made by a young boy and his twin sisters against their parents, then the foster parents with whom they were placed, and finally a total of 16 people. One person pleaded guilty, the natural parents were convicted, and then when they came of age, all three kids recanted. You can read some of the extensive background to the case here. Suffice it to say that some people got the wrong end of the stick, in particular John Lucas and his wife Johanna accused a police officer of complicity in child rape, and this became in their minds a massive conspiracy. Alas, there is never any convincing true believers.


October 19, 1993: Prisoners Of Silence

The above documentary in the Frontline series presents a comprehensive debunking of Facilitated Communication, a technique that was supposed to be a breakthrough in the treatment of autism. FC is junk science, but its greatest fault is that it has led to a large number of false allegations of sexual assault, including rape. The 2007 Wendrow case is probably the most notorious, and it is disgraceful it should have happened nearly a decade and a half after this programme was broadcast.

Here is a transcript of the programme, and here is an abstract of what is called a confession by Janyce Boynton, the woman who facilitated Betsy Wheaton.


October 19, 1993: King’s College, London student Austen Donnellan is cleared of raping another undergraduate after a Christmas party the previous year. This is another notorious date rape case that needs no citations. Nigella Lawson summed it up poetically: “Rape is a terrible thing. That is beyond debate. But to wake up and find yourself in bed with someone, when sober you wouldn’t touch with a barge pole, is not such a big deal. We’ve all been there, honey. It’s called student life”.


October 21, 1993: Dean Howell and his co-defendant are sentenced at Southwark Crown Court for kidnap and assault occasioning actual bodily harm. Howell is given a 5 year sentence; Darren Woodhead a 2 year sentence.

This case highlights the dangers a woman can face when she makes a false rape allegation against the “wrong” man. When the unnamed woman here falsely accused Howell, he decided to administer summary justice.

[The above was reported in The Independent, October 22, 1993, page 10 - accessed here through NewsBank Newspapers - U.K. and Ireland].


October 29, 1993: Fairbairn causes rape anger by Stephen Bates.

The above article was published in the Guardian on said date at page 2. Sir Nicholas Fairbairn (1933-95) was a plain speaking Scot, a bit too plain speaking for some, including the sisterhood. His opposition to anonymity for complaints in rape cases was right on the money, in particular that this can encourage some to make false allegations.


October 30, 1993: A woman is kidnapped and raped in Sacramento. When the police investigate, they find CCTV evidence that shows her inside a convenience store three hours after the abduction. That and other evidence undermines her credibility, although she still insists she was raped. Clearly she shouldn’t have taken so much methamphetamine.


November 1993: Archbishop of Chicago Cardinal Joseph Bernardin is accused of sexually assaulting Steven Cook, who files a lawsuit against him. This was another historical allegation/false memory. Cook recanted three months later.

This short clip includes footage of both men. Steven Cook died of AIDS in September 1995 aged just 36; Bernardin died the following year. I don’t want to read too much into this, but it may be that as a Catholic, Cook was looking for a way, albeit subconsciously, to pass the buck for his own sexual follies. Sinners don’t go to Heaven and all that.

According to this article by someone called Brother Michael Diamond, Bernardin raped an 11 year old girl in 1957 when she was 17. As part of a Satanic ritual, no less.


November 11, 1993: The book A Rock And A Hard Place: One Boy’s Triumphant Story is published; this is a really sad story about a boy whose parents were complicit in the systematic rape of their young son. He suffered a lot more, but when attempts were made to contact the author, he was found not to exist. Even so, this trash was republished several times, including an Italian edition.


November 19, 1993: Divorce’s Deadliest Weapon

The above documentary is about false allegations of child sexual abuse in divorce/custody disputes, which here includes a suggestion of oral rape. If you don’t want to watch the full archived version, here are three significant clips:

Sexual abuse lies exposed by a child psychiatrist

A barrister comments on the epidemic of false allegations

How accusation by innuendo works


November 26, 1993: The Court of Appeal for Ontario quashes the conviction of David Norman for having sex with a woman without her consent (Canadian parlance for rape) on July 23, 1992. The offence was said to have been carried out in September 1973 when the complainant was 13 years old.

This woman had been in therapy since 1987, which had enabled her to “recall” these “blocked” memories. The trial judge was duped by this nonsense, but thankfully the appellate court remedied the injustice.


November 29, 1993: Married and divorced at 19? Yes, and behind bars for up to five years as Utah woman Lydia Ann Goodfellow is convicted of perjury after lying under oath about being raped by her ex-husband, as reported by the Deseret News, November 30, 1993, page B4.

Mind you, the poor bloke did spend 23 days behind bars. She was also ordered by District Judge John Rokich to pay him restitution, including his legal fees.


December 1993: The first trial for marital rape in the Irish Republic ends in acquittal at the Central Criminal Court, Dublin. The anonymous non-victim had severe credibility problems, including an admission in a lower court of lying in a police statement.

[The above was reported in the Daily Mirror, December 9, 1993, page 13 - accessed here through NewsBank Newspapers - U.K. and Ireland].


December 18, 1993: At Punta Gorda, Florida, a teenage boy claims to have been sexually assaulted - ie raped - by a strange man. An ectoplasmic one, apparently.

This article appeared in the Saratosa Herald-Tribune (METRO EDITION), December 22, 1993, page 3B.


December 25, 1993: A short report of a non-rape from Cleveland in the North of England.


December 30, 1993: Jeffrey Scott Costa is arrested, accused of repeatedly raping his girlfriend Vickie Gray, and locked up. Shortly, she admits the sex was consensual. She was angry with him for reasons unrelated to sex. He is released from gaol on January 11, 1994, and it is said she may face perjury charges. This report is from the local press, the Ocala Star-Banner for January 15, 1994, page 1B.


1994: False Rape Allegations by Eugene J. Kanin.

Although the above is an important article, the cases to which it alludes have been anonymised, so none of them are included here.


1994: In New Zealand, Allan Rust is accused of raping an underage girl. He is cleared at a retrial. The girl had been instrumental in instigating another false allegation of sexual assault.


1994: Crying Wolf: Hate Crime Hoaxes In America by Laird Wilcox is published.

The above is really a political tract but it does include some mention of false rape allegations, including the Tawana Brawley case.


1994: Law Enforcement Guide To Satanic Cults

Is the above really an educational tape?

Did you know there are three levels of Satanism? Dabblers, those involved for spiritual reasons, and the criminal element. If you check out the list of symptoms that starts just before 40 minutes and compare with the list of symptoms given for rape trauma syndrome, you’ll see what I mean, barring semen found on the child’s underwear and other real symptoms, that is. If you want to watch the video at the above link, you may wish to download it first in view of the file size.

Here is an article about missing kids in America written by a rational human being. The real statistics are a lot more modest than those given here.


1994: Believe Her! The Woman Never Lies Myth by Frank S. Zepezauer.

The above is an excellent if disturbing article: read, learn and digest.


1994: Roger Mennell is accused of raping and sexually abusing a woman when she was 7 years old two decades earlier. Uncharacteristically the jury was told that the accuser was a victim of FALSE MEMORY SYNDROME when the case came to trial in 2015, a case that should clearly never have been brought.


January 1, 1994: Michael Seear, a police officer, has sex with a fellow, female, constable, after a party, but he does not have a happy new year. When her boyfriend finds love bites on her breasts and neck, she can’t bring herself to tell him the truth. Three months later, she accuses Seear of rape. He is cleared by a jury at the Central Criminal Court in February 1995.


February 1994: In Tasmania, Father Alan Farrell is accused of sodomising a drunk, a man he’d tried to help. His nightmare lasts five years.

For legal commentary see the journal article from November 2, 1998, (below).


February 1994: Anthony Tovey delivers a wardrobe to a woman’s apartment. She invites him in for a cup of coffee, which he accepts. The next day he is arrested; she had accused him of attacking her, holding her captive for three hours, and raping her. He was remanded in custody. Eventually, DNA tests showed there had been no such attack. His false accuser does not appear to have been prosecuted.


February 14, 1994: At Providence, Rhode Island, teenager Eva Baptista accuses her ex-boyfriend of raping her in his car. She files her complaint on Monday morning claiming the incident happened around half past midnight. In no time at all, Joao Pina is arrested; he is arraigned the following day, but the same day around 10am, Baptista’s new boyfriend phones a detective and tells him the rape never happened. Eva admits she lied. According to Pina, although they had dated for years, he had not seen her since they broke up in November, even though she had phoned him repeatedly since then.

Eva Baptista is charged with filing a false report while the courts are still dealing with her complaint! The same day - February 15 - she is sentenced to supervised probation for one year, 20 hours of community service and ordered her to pay court costs.

[The above is based on a report by W. Zachary Malinowski in the Providence Journal, Blackstone Valley Edition, February 16, 1994, page B-01, (accessed here through NewsBank)].


February 19, 1994: In the Deep South, Richmond County deputy Billy Hambrick pulls over a car that is weaving across the road at 1am. The driver is arrested, but his female passenger is unable to drive home because she is intoxicated too, so Hambrick drives her home, whereupon she phones the Augusta Police Department and accuses him of rape.

Hambrick is placed on administrative leave, but by Sunday - ie the day after - she recants her claim. She was 38 years old.

[The above is based on a report by Stephanie Hunter in the Augusta Chronicle, February 21, 1994, page A16, (accessed here through NewsBank)].


February 20, 1994: At Central Falls, Rhode Island, a 16 year old girl claims she was kidnapped at knifepoint and raped. When pressed, she admits she spent the night with her boyfriend and panicked. Detective Joseph Corey says “We thought best that it be handled by her mother”.

The girl actually went into considerable detail describing the abduction - at 10.30am the previous day, ie Friday, February 19 - baby booties dangling in the vehicle, a house that contained a stove, milk crates, and a sheet over the windows. She arrived home and told her brother, who had already reported her missing. Then he phoned the police and informed them (in good faith) of the alleged rape.

And just for limerick writers, this non-crime was investigated by Pawtucket Police!

[The above is based on a report in the Providence Journal, BLACKSTONE VALLEY Edition, February 22, 1994, page C-01, (accessed here through NewsBank)].


February 24, 1994: Edited by the demented Valerie Sinason, Treating Survivors Of Satanist Abuse... is published in both hardback and softback. It is incredible that any mainstream publisher would put out such rubbish. You can read what I thought of it here. Some academic reviewers have been far less flattering.


March 6, 1994: In sunny California, Monique Thomas is raped by a man who pulls her into an elevator, a despicable crime made all the more so by the 24 year old victim being in a wheelchair. She reports the assault not quite four hours later, the sort of thing a genuine victim would do, allowing for immediate shock and everything, but Monique is not a genuine victim. A thorough investigation involving over a hundred hours of police time results in the Contra Costa County District Attorney’s Office filing charges against her on March 10.

[The above information was extracted from a report by Peter Fimrite in the San Francisco Chronicle, March 11, 1994, FINAL/EAST BAY Edition, page A21, (accessed here through NewsBank)].


March 12, 1994: On this date, the New York Times reported that according to his lawyer Michael Kennedy, Ricardo S. Caputo was raped in an alleyway when he was a boy. (And that’s the reason I murdered those four women). We hear this sort of flim-flam all the time in mitigation at criminal trials. You can read all about this lowlife here.


March 21, 1994: At Bloomington, Illinois, Shelli Wills tells police her adoptive father Kenneth Wills (by his previous marriage) broke into her apartment and raped her. He is arrested promptly, but has a cast iron alibi, he was at a function with many witnesses. She recants, although the charges against him are not dropped until May. On November 9, she is arrested and charged with filing a false report.

[The above is based on a report in The Pantagraph, November 11, 1994, page A6, (accessed here through NewsBank)].


April 1994: This is another ASYLUM SNEAKER CASE. False accuser Seniet Abebe claims to have been arrested in her native Ethiopia in April shortly after the disappearance of her husband. That much is probably true. She claims to have been held in gaol where she was raped and abused. Unfortunately, she appears only to have realised this when she reached Australia, having made no mention of it in South Africa, from which she had travelled on a false passport.


April 6, 1994: Indian national Manjit Kaur enters the United States where she claims asylum. At or about this time she claims to have been beaten and gang-raped in front of her children. Seven years later, she admits she had lied.


April 13, 1994: A Texas schoolgirl tells her teacher she was raped by Brian Franklin on an unspecified date the previous month in the backyard of her father’s house. She was thirteen at the time. The teacher does what is required, and in February 1995, the police officer goes on trial; he does not testify. This was especially foolish because there was evidence the girl had had sex, which is at least statutory rape. In 1998, the girl claims she was repeatedly sexually abused by her stepfather; this leads to an appeal in 2002 which Franklin loses. In 2016, he is finally cleared. Here is a video report.

This one should probably be filed under FALSE AND TRUE. I will refrain from making any comments about the girl’s mental state.


April 13, 1994: Deanna Ormiston of Summerfield, Florida, claims to have been kidnapped by a dude wielding an axe who took her to a wood and raped her. This one is solved in quadruple quick time. After identifying said dude from a line-up, he is arrested, whereupon the non-victim admits the sex was consensual and actually happened at his house. She appears in court and is dealt with appropriately with what a British Home Secretary once alluded to as a short sharp shock.

Victim on Wednesday, convicted false accuser on Thursday, and written up in the local press on Friday. This article appeared in the Ocala Star-Banner, April 15, 1994, page 1B.


April 26, 1994: At Inverness, Florida, Anna Brown claims her boyfriend Rudolph Van Tassell raped her. And her 15 year old daughter. And her 90 year old mother! Unsurprisingly the local plod found that difficult to swallow, especially as the two other alleged victims did as well! This appears to have been a grossly stupid allegation motivated purely by spite. Anna Brown was hauled off to gaol for filing a false report; she was said also to have resisted arrest.

[The above information was extracted from a report by Keith Morelli in The Tampa Tribune, April 28, 1994, page 1, (accessed here through NewsBank)].


June 1, 1994: Children at Risk: The Secret Double Life of a Paedophile

Unlike most of the films about this subject, the above is a thoroughly researched documentary about Peter Righton, a real paedophile who managed to insinuate himself into the heart of the British establishment. I have included this because - just in case you didn’t know - there are real monsters out there.

The other important thing about it is that the footage of Righton’s chum Charles Napier shows how paedophiles actually groom their victims - Napier used alcohol - something that is in stark contrast to the way usually portray by both the gullible and the fanatical.

My review appears at the bottom of the page, the only one at the time of writing, January 2017.


June 4, 1994: Nadine Pearson tells police at Bradenton, Florida she was raped in the street. She exhibits bizarre behaviour at the rape crisis centre, and ends up being charged with assaulting one of those nice detectives as well as with filing a false report. This article is from the Saratosa Herald-Tribune, June 8, 1994, page 3B.


June 20, 1994: At Colonial Heights, Virginia, late at night, Sharon Graves is attacked by not one but two of the most dangerous sexual predators: black ones. She is abducted and raped from outside a grocery store. That’s the bad news. The good news is they existed only in her tiny mind. She reports this imaginary incident less than three hours after it didn’t happen, and a prompt police investigation leads to her being charged with filing a false report later the same day.

[The above is based on a report in the Richmond Times-Despatch, City Edition, June 23, 1994, page B-4, (accessed here through NewsBank)].


July 1994: A middle aged man and two teenagers - who will not be named here - are accused of raping a prostitute in Tel Aviv. Two of them appear to be father and son. The men are remanded in custody, but the following month, the woman’s statement is found to be inconsistent, she was not bruised in spite of claiming to have been badly beaten, nor did she scream or seek help from neighbours in the building.

[The information above is based on an article by Raine Marcus in The Jerusalem Post, August 4, 1994, page 4 (accessed through NewsBank)].


July 1994: Early in the month, an unnamed 61 year old man is cleared at Teesside Crown Court of raping his own daughter. This was another HISTORICAL/FALSE MEMORY case. According to the report in the Sunday Times of July 10, the jury took a mere 27 minutes to clear him.

“The daughter, now 34 and with a history of mental problems, reported her father to police after psychiatrists and social workers teased out her childhood imagination, concocting the theory that her depression and suicide attempts were caused by child sex abuse. The first alleged rape had happened 30 years ago; the last when she was 16. She had not known about them until undergoing therapy.”


July 1994: Deceiving Others/Deceiving Oneself: Four Cases of Factitious Rape by Mark D. Feldman, Charles V. Ford and Tim Stone.

The above article from an academic journal speaks for itself. The Nordstrom rape hoax alluded to therein can be found in this database at January 3, 1993, (above).


July 8, 1994: According to the non-victim, the actor Craig Charles and two other men violated her in her own home. Click here for more.


July 14, 1994: Three professional basketball players are alleged to have raped a woman in a Detroit hotel room. Derrick Coleman, Jalen Rose and Chris Webber are soon cleared by forensics but Coleman especially is unhappy and launches a civil suit against false accuser Toia Maudette Reed.

This short report is from the archive of the New York Times.


July 16, 1994: This report so dated from page 5 of the Dutch language newspaper Amigoe reports a very heavy sentence imposed on an unnamed woman on the island of Aruba. The eighteen years was not simply for a false rape allegation though, there was also the little matter of three kilogrammes of the white stuff.


Summer 1994: Four Latina lesbians in sexy romp sounds like every red-blooded male’s dream, but the case of the San Antonio Four is actually a nightmare, and proof positive that this sort of injustice is not exclusive to men.

Kristie Mayhugh, Elizabeth Ramirez, Cassandra Rivera and Anna Vasquez were alleged to have forced themselves on two young girls on more than one occasion. The girls delayed reporting (ie made it up later), and to cut a long story short, the four falsely accused women ended up behind bars with the kind of sentences that are handed down in the US for these kind of crimes, real and imagined.

Here is one of the failed appeal judgments.

The four were back in the news in 2016, by which time the case against them had all but collapsed, and the documentary Southwest Of Salem was released.

One word of warning, many people reporting and commenting on this case view it through the lenses of racism and homophobia. This database contains entries for many white men - some of them quite privileged - so please don’t be taken in by such mindless rhetoric.


August 3, 1994: A girl is asked by a detective if she had ever been sexually abused by Robert Devereaux of Wenatchee, Washington State. She denies it but claims later that he had raped her and other girls in his care. She had actually been placed in juvenile detention on suspicion of poisoning Devereaux and another girl, something she admitted.

From this humble beginning, 43 adults would eventually be charged with a staggering 29,000+ counts of sexual molestation. Here is the full sad story of this ludicrous witch-hunt.


August 7, 1994: A letter from Lynn Wills of Heyworth, Illinois, appeared in The Pentagraph on this date; click here for more.


August 10, 1994: When the rape rap is phony by Alan Dershowitz.

As well as some general commentary, the author highlights three recent cases of falsely accused athletes. Here is a paragraph from it:

Although it is dangerous to generalize from a small number of studies, these results have been corroborated by others. For example, back in 1987, New York sex prosecutor Linda Fairstein told an interviewer that “there are about 4,000 reports of rape each year in Manhattan. Of these, about half simply did not happen.” In her 1993 book, Sexual Violence: Our War Against Rape, Ms. Fairstein dramatically lowered this figure to 5 percent without explanation. The FBI reports that approximately 8 percent of rape cases are unfounded. According to the Purdue report, “Some feminists virtually deny the existence of false rape accusation and believe that concept itself constitutes discriminatory harassment towards women.”

[The above excellent article appeared in The Washington Times, Edition 2, Page A14, (accessed through NewsBank)].


August 12, 1994: Ohio woman Melissa Ray and her boyfriend fake her kidnapping and rape. In December, she admits publicly the abduction was a hoax, and says she did it because she was pregnant and was worried about telling her parents, a curious thing to say in view of her age, and in 1995.

It remains to be seen how much money and how many man hours were wasted by law enforcement including the FBI on this wild goose chase. This report is from The Blade (Toledo, Ohio), April 1, 1995, page 9.


Summer 1994: ANONYMITY FOR WOMEN IN RAPE TRIALS by Conrad Russell.

The above article is a fairly straightforward plea for maintaining the status quo by a London-based academic.


September 5, 1994: A first year student at Texas Tech, Lubbock, is raped. That’s the bad news. The good news is that on September 21, she is un-raped. Her recantation is reported by The Victoria Advocate (Victoria, Texas), September 24, 1994, page 3A.


September 12, 1994: In Florida, the Sebring State Attorney’s office informs law enforcement that Kimberly Mays then fifteen years old had accused her father of sexually assaulting her from the age of seven. She soon withdraws her allegations.

This one is actually rather complicated; Robert Mays was not her natural father, and the poor kid was clearly mixed up due to her unique personal circumstances.

This article gives an insight into how she would go on to screw up her life.


September 13, 1994: At Bloomington, Illinois, late at night, Valerie Bray tells her husband and the police she was raped by John Cook. Before the police can take action, Robert Bray forces his way into Cook’s home armed with a blunt instrument, but comes off worse when the householder grabs a knife. The following day, Mrs Bray recants her claim, and is arrested.

[The above information was extracted from a report by Steve Arney in The Pentagraph, September 16, 1994, page A3, (accessed here through NewsBank)].


September 17, 1994: A student at Texas Tech, Lubbock, claims she has been raped. Two days later, after campus police get to grips with the investigation, she withdraws her complaint. This was the second false rape allegation on this campus in less than a month; see entry for September 5, 1994, (above).


October 2, 1994: Two men have sex with a disreputable young woman at Australia’s Surfers Paradise. She would have cried rape but apparently did not know what the word meant, even though she had once worked as a receptionist in a brothel. The jury takes 35 minutes to acquit them.


October 21, 1994: The Court of Appeal quashes the rape conviction of Gareth Linekar. This is a strange, some would say amusing, case. Linekar was convicted of rape in September 1993 at the Central Criminal Court for which he received two years probation and 100 hours community service. This apparently extraordinarily lenient sentence was due to him having had (consensual) sex with a Streatham prostitute for a fee of £25, then making off without paying her!

The whore cried rape, knocking on a nearby door nearly naked and appearing distressed. Both she and he lied about the encounter, although he was convicted. In quashing his conviction, the Court ruled that if he was guilty of anything it was of procurement by false pretences. Most people would indeed regard this as theft of services, but as an immoral contract is not enforceable in law, there are no civil remedies for this sort of thing. Like the case of the three basketball players a decade later, this one should be filed under ASKING FOR IT.


October 21, 1994: At Kajang, Malaysia, a 15 year old schoolgirl tells the authorities she was raped by two men more than twice her age. The following week, the truth comes out; she had consensual sex with a 19 year old and pointed the finger at the two innocents because...Her tryst is charged with statutory rape; in the UK, this would probably not have attracted the attention of the police. This report is from the New Straits Times, October 29, 1994, page 9.


October 25, 1994: Beekman v Beekman is decided by the Court of Appeals of Ohio. Although not an allegation of rape, this child custody case is worth reading. As Judge Stephenson points out about false allegations of sexual abuse: “This tactic for achieving a preferential posture for child custody is almost as despicable as the act itself”.


November 3, 1994: In the UK, the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act, 1994 is given the Royal Assent. Section 32 of that Act abolishes the corroboration rule for sex offences.

This was a very dangerous move, as you’ll understand if you’ve read this far.


November 8, 1994: This is the date of an alleged multiple rape. At this archived link the reader will find a long, translated article by Sabine Rückert. If you can read it in the original German, so much the better. It tells the incredible story of Amelie, who although raped numerous times by both her own father and her uncle, was still A VIRGIN.


November 11, 1994: A teenager is the victim of a vicious gang attack in Philadelphia; the next day, Edward Polec dies in hospital. The previous week, a girl and her friend had been set upon by a gang - stupid teen stuff. The girl denied claiming she had been raped. This is another, and in this case tragic example of the RUMOUR MILL.

The above is based on this report from the Allegheny Times, November 23, 1994, page A2 - this newspaper is an edition of the Beaver County Times.


November 24, 1994: Lynn McArthur is fined £800 at Dumbarton Sheriff Court for falsely accusing Robert Miller of rape. She’d had sex with him in the back of his car - a one-night stand - then fearing she might become pregnant...On December 13, 1994, the Daily Record reported that Miller had turned to drugs (and petty crime) under pressure from the allegation. He faced various charges. This would not be the first time the victim of a false rape allegation had used the trauma to attempt to excuse or mitigate his own bad behaviour, but the court was told he had no previous convictions, so he does deserve some sympathy.


November 27, 1994: According to the Moscow Pullman Daily News of May 10, 1995, Candice Wagner is not abducted from a mall in Washington State. Unfortunately, that is not what she told the police; in May 1995 after pleading guilty to making a false report, she is given a complex sentence including some time behind bars and a fine.


November 29, 1994: A thirteen year old girl is dragged into an alley and raped at Lodi, California. There is no doubt this crime happened, but the perpetrator was wilfully misidentified as Peter Rose. You can read all about this sad story here.

It remains to be seen if the actual rapist would ever have been caught, but it is clear that for whatever reason, the victim was pressured into identifying the wrong man. File under FALSE AND TRUE.


December 23, 1994: Patricia Hyde of Montgomery, Alabama has sex with a former lover. The sex must have been real bad because the guy shoots her afterwards! She accuses him of rape but shortly admits the encounter was consensual, although unsurprisingly Captain Wyatt Gannt wants to speak to him as a matter of urgency, a $2,500 reward being offered for an arrest.

[The above is based on a report in the Press-Register, December 31, 1994, AM Edition, Section B, page 3, (accessed here through NewsBank)].


1995: Prior False Allegations Of Rape: Falsus In Uno, Falsus In Omnibus? by Denise R. Johnson.

The above is an incredibly facile polemic from the Yale Journal Of Law & Feminism, the main thrust of which is that if a woman has falsely accused a man of rape on a previous occasion, the jury in the current rape trial should not be made aware of this.


1995: This is a notorious case from New Zealand; Hamilton University student Nick Wills is accused of rape by a HEAD CASE known only as Wendy. The police simply assume his guilt, and it is left to his family to demonstrate the falsity of her claims. Unbelievably, the local rape crisis outfit continues to support her claiming this was a case of mistaken identity. Or perhaps not so unbelievably if you’ve read this far.


1995: On the island of Bermuda, teenager Glennea Michelle Grant (or whatever her name was then) makes a false rape allegation. Eight years later with a broken marriage behind her, she does something far more serious and stupid.


February 2, 1995: Teenager Sandra Stewart pleads guilty at Dingwall Sheriff Court to making a false rape allegation. She spent the night with a sailor then made up the false rape story to appease her angry father.


February 14, 1995: Janet Hendricks accuses her ex-husband Joseph Arledge of unspeakable crimes against their young daughter.

Little information is available on the above case, but it appears to be a gratuitously false allegation based on the girl’s medical condition. At any rate, Mr Arledge was not prepared to take this sort of allegation lying down, and it ended up in the civil courts.


February 19, 1995: At Prince George’s County, Maryland, a teenager is kidnapped at knifepoint and raped, but manages to escape from her attacker 32 hours later. On February 20, the police go public; the following day, a 16 year old disappears; two days later she re-emerges telling a similar tale, but soon recants. She had spent the time with her boyfriend.

This report is a simplified page from the website of the Washington Post. There are a couple of interesting quotes here:

“Police said they routinely field rape reports that are later recanted for one reason or another.” - Not what the sisterhood would have us believe.

“Unfortunately, we do get a good many people who say they were raped when they actually weren’t.” - We would prefer they were? Damn, that didn’t come out right!

Whatever the police say, file this naughty girl under COPYCAT, after she comes back from the woodshed.


March 1995: Alveda Torrado is charged with making false rape allegations against two inmates of Union County Jail. Very sensibly, since this incident, new rules have been introduced barring the mixing of male and female inmates without supervision. Torrado took off to Puerto Rico on her release but returned and surrendered to the authorities in November 1996. On January 31, 1997, she was given a six month sentence for contempt of court and making a false declaration. It was reported that two prison guards had been disciplined for allowing her illicit liaisons.


March 27, 1995: Gloria Grajo tells an American judge she was raped repeatedly in her native Philippines, apparently for political reasons. This appears to have been the first time she made this allegation - against a named individual. The judge is not impressed, and neither should you be.


March 28, 1995: Another case of false memory syndrome. At Teesside Crown Court, a man is cleared of raping his own daughter.


Spring 1995: Consent, Credibility, and the Constitution: Evidence Relating to a Sex Offense Complainant’s Past Sexual Behavior by Clifford S. Fishman.

The above is a lengthy article from the Catholic University Law Review by a leading American legal scholar. Crammed with case law, it covers rape shield laws, allegations by children and prostitutes, prior false allegations, prior truthful allegations, and much more.


April 1995: Pamela Boylan tells detectives she was stripped and raped by two men. After a full scale probe is launched, she tells the truth. She’d had sex with a former boyfriend, and told her then current boyfriend she had been raped because it was the first excuse that came into her head.

In September 1996, she is fined £200 at Tillydrone Court, Aberdeen. Her conviction is reported by the Daily Record, September 11, 1996, page 9.


April 9, 1995: The body of Mark Jackson is found by his mother, hanging from the staircase. He had stood trial for rape at Exeter Crown Court where he was acquitted, but his name had been all over the media, and he couldn’t take it. His suicide was mentioned in Parliament by John Greenway - Conservative MP for Ryedale - on July 8, 1999.


April 16, 1995: The body of Gonzalo Ramirez is found by the side of the road at Irvine California. Click here for more.


May 18, 1995: This is another well-documented false rape allegation that needs no citations. Yolanda Saldívar meets Selena Quintanilla-Pérez at a Days Inn motel in Texas and tells her she had been raped on a recent trip to Mexico. The kind-hearted Selena drove her to a hospital where an examination of Saldívar revealed no trace of this obviously phantom rape. On their return to the motel room, Saldívar murdered her. She was convicted of first degree murder in October 1995 and given a life sentence.


June 17, 1995: Three silly girls in Florida think it’s fun to phone the police and claim they are being raped. This report is from the Ocala newspaper the Star-Banner, June 20, 1995, page 18.


June 19, 1995: Daytona Beach man Leroy LaRoche is accused of orchestrating the kidnap and rape of a teenager, a co-worker, on said date. She claimed to have been snatched off the street after 11pm and violated for 5 hours. Although she had two black eyes, there was no evidence of rape, something for which she had a lame explanation. Eventually, her story fell apart although she did not recant. By that time though, LaRoche had been locked up for four months; he’d lost his fiancée and a great deal more besides.

This sad tale was related by The News-Journal, October 25, 1995, pages 1D & 2D.


June 23, 1995: Cressey Brazier is cleared of twice raping a teenage girl, in June and October 1993. The doctor from Dedham, Maine, was also accused of hitting Little Miss Anonymous in the face in April 1994. This report illustrates the at times shoddy practices of police who investigate cases of this nature. Brazier’s attorney suggests the detective on the case didn’t investigate it properly at all, and when he realised the doctor had alibis for the original dates, he simply changed them.

From other reports it is clear the doctor was a busy man - as doctors tend to be. He was also newly married, and in addition to spending time with his new wife, was spending as much as he could with his daughters from his previous marriage. From other media reports, it is clear this case should never have got anywhere near a courtroom. It is possible too to discern a motive for the allegations as the non-victim had gone to primary school with one of his daughters.


June 25, 1995: This report from the London Times, pages 1 & 2, covers the aftermath of the trial of the youngest boy ever to be indicted for rape in England. According to the defence there was no rape because there was no sex!


June 27, 1995: Around 5am, Stephanie Kendle attends the Mary Washington Hospital in Virginia where she claims to have been carjacked in the small hours and raped numerous times. Detective Jeff DeBord conducts a lightning investigation, and it is soon determined that rather than being raped by a stranger, she had been with a man she knew, a man who was not her husband. This article appeared in The Free Lance-Star (Fredericksburg, Virginia), June 28, 1995. page B8.


July 10, 1995: Lawton Gay sets fire to the apartment of his lover Shelley Goodbread at Paddock Park, Florida. At his trial in September 1997, it comes out that Goodbread had falsely accused a man of rape before she began dating Gay. The judge excludes this, he is convicted, and given a ten year sentence.

In 1983, Gay had been convicted of serious charges following a dispute with a truck driver.


July 15, 1995: This is another case that sees an innocent man’s life all but destroyed on the uncorroborated testimony of a wanton woman. Traffic warden Anthony Hunt is invited into the home of a special constable known here only as AB. They have sex. She doesn’t tell the police she was raped, although she does tell other traffic wardens. In March 2002, one of these traffic wardens tells another (senior) traffic warden, who reports it to the police.

Anthony Hunt is arrested on May 14, 2002. It is claimed that AB had reported the alleged rape by phone to her sub-divisional officer within half an hour. And he did nothing. On December 18, 2003, Anthony Hunt is given a four year sentence at Winchester Crown Court. On December 6, 2005, his appeal is heard. And is allowed. Among other things, two witnesses recalled seeing him in the company of his accuser after the date of the non-rape. Here is the full story.


August 1995: A woman known as Carter - an alcoholic as well as a head case - is arrested in Adelaide. She claims then or shortly after to have been raped by a detective when she was 13, (which would have been around 1983). Eighteen years later, she makes another false rape allegation, this time against a bloke named Morgan.


August 9, 1995: In the Philippines, Rogelio Javier is arrested for the rape of his neighbour Genalyn Barotilla. The accusation appears to have been made some time the previous month. Although the case against him is dropped, his employer sacks him for being absent without leave. He appeals, and after protracted litigation, the Supreme Court orders he be reinstated or compensated.


August 31, 1995: Kim Driver is given a suspended sentence by magistrates at Gloucester. She was said to have brought a police force virtually to a halt after claiming to have been kidnapped and raped. She does not appear to have pointed the finger at a named individual, and made up the lie to cover for a one-night stand. Although a mother of two she appears to have been single, but she had a boyfriend. Do the math. Conveniently, since her last court appearance she was said to have been diagnosed with an identifiable psychiatric condition; the rape claim was a cry for help. Yeah, we got that, help, I’ve been kidnapped and raped. Unreal.

[The above is base on a report from the Guardian, September 1, 1995, page 8 - accessed through the ProQuest database].


October 1995: Jeopardy in the Courtroom A SCIENTIFIC ANALYSIS OF CHILDREN’S TESTIMONY by Stephen J. Ceci and Maggie Bruck is published.

I consulted the second printing, January 1996.

The word rape does not appear in the index, but the authors cover many false rape cases against the young, and real ones including the case of Russell Bishop.

Page 31: citing a 1987 study of 576 reported cases of child sexual abuse in Denver (in one year!) - 53% were classified as “indicated”, 23% as “unfounded” - there were deliberate/malicious false allegations and some that were honest mistakes, of which there are a couple of truly shocking ones in this database (William Mullins-Johnson, entry for June 27, 1993; and George Gwaze, entry for January 7, 2007).

The authors cover coaching in custody disputes and infantile amnesia, the latter, in my humble opinion, being the cause of the bulk of sexual abuse allegations made by the young and the not-so-young.


October 11, 1995: This report from the London Times, page 5, speaks for itself. The woman who accused John Griffin of raping her, wrote to him and retracted. She was subsequently charged with perverting the course of justice.


October 16, 1995: Jim Fairlie is called to a family meeting to learn that his daughter, who had been undergoing psychiatric treatment, had accused him of unspeakable crimes including running a paedophile ring. Thankfully, a police investigation led nowhere, and eventually, Katrina Fairlie came to her senses. In October 2007, she received an out-of-court settlement from NHS Tayside which she held responsible for implanting false memories in her mind.


October 30, 1995: Roxeen Newman tells the police she was raped by a named individual. On March 4, 1996, she appears in Hamilton District Court where she is convicted of making a false complaint. She had also made two false complaints of non-sexual assaults. She walks away with a slap on the wrist.

This report appeared in the New Zealand Herald, March 6, 1996, page 14.


November 1995: A woman alluded to as a mentally ill drug abuser claims to have been raped by a serving police officer and another man. The former has a rock solid alibi, he was at work at the time.


November 15, 1995: This report so dated is a very simplified page from the website of The Herald (Glasgow) wherein it is claimed that teenager Caroline McKinlay has become the first person in Scotland to be sentenced to detention for making a false rape allegation. This means youth detention, not staying behind after school to write lines every schoolday for three months.

Not only did she stage the crime scene but she confirmed what every MRA and MGTOW (and one suspects every feminist with half a brain knows), women and silly young girls like her cry rape when THEY REGRET what they have done:

“I was happy enough until the sex was all over but later I didn’t want it to have happened.”


December 1995: Alan Collier (variant spellings of his name) is arrested for the 1980 rape of an unnamed woman. This notorious case from New Zealand saw him convicted in June 1996 then cleared on appeal when supporters revealed the police had made no meaningful investigation.


December 11, 1995: A man alluded to only as Nigel is arrested at his home. He is accused initially of five counts of common and indecent assault on a family friend between 1978 and 1995. He stands trial, and in spite of the judge pointing out that the prosecution case is full of contradictions, he is convicted by a majority verdict of committing two of the incidents alleged from ten years earlier. He is given a four year sentence but wins an appeal.

[The above information was extracted from NewsUK wherein it is credited to Oxfordshire County Publications, November 19, 1999, apparently the Oxford Mail].


December 11, 1995: Pastor Robert Roberson and his wife Connie of Waterville, Washington are cleared of all charges; they had faced multiple counts of child sexual abuse, including rape. This trial was part of the ludicrous paedophile witch-hunt that swept across the United States destroying so many innocent lives, women’s as well as men’s.


December 22, 1995: Los Angeles lawman Harris Mintz is alleged to have raped a Calabas woman. The following year his own wife accuses him of spousal rape on at least three occasions from December 1992 to May 1995.

Then the truth comes out, the woman from Calabas had made a false allegation of a sexual nature before, and concocted this one for financial reasons. The officer’s wife had jumped on the bandwagon. By this time Mintz had spent five months behind bars. In April 1997, it was reported that he had been formally exonerated.


1996: Factitious Sexual Harassment by Sarah Feldman-Schorrig.

Although the above article from an academic journal concerns primarily sexual harassment as its title suggests, the author also alludes to “factitious rape”.

“Based on the forensic examination of more than 50 sexual harassment plaintiffs, the author believes that some women who file claims are motivated by the need to portray themselves as victims.”

She discusses one anonymised case of a woman who made a false claim of sexual harassment at work; she was said to have previously made false rape allegations against a former lover several years earlier as well as claiming to have been sexually abused as a child, although we are not told how we know the childhood sexual abuse was real.


January 1996: Raman Kumar is arrested and accused of arranging the rape of a woman named Kaloti by two different men. He is rearrested the following month, and after a trial and a retrial at Warwick Crown Court he is cleared of rape but convicted of assault and intimidating a witness. He is sentenced to three years, four months, but his conviction is quashed by the Court of Appeal. See also the relevant entry for December 2006.


January 3, 1996: Ana Negron is not raped by Joel Gibilisco and James Born at Born’s Laureldale home; unfortunately, she doesn’t tell the authorities this until February. This report from the Reading Eagle, June 27, 1996, page B5, contains details of her sentencing.


January 5, 1996: A 13 year old girl from Southport, North Carolina, has sex with her 17 year old boyfriend then claims to have been kidnapped and gang-raped. The police believed her, but she came clean to her family.

This article was published in the Morning Star (Wilmington, North Carolina), January 18, 1996, page 1B. Two comments here, my apologies for the poor quality of the scan, this is not my fault. And 13 is far too young for girls to be having sex.


February 1996: Distinguishing Between True and False Allegations of Sexual Abuse Part I: Adults Alleging Abuse as Children by Felicity Goodyear-Smith, Vol. 25, No. 2, pages 47-50.

The above article from a New Zealand journal so dated covers many subjects and gives some sound advice, including without independent corroboration, adults’ claims of sexual abuse of kids are no more reliable than those made by the young. It covers such topics as jumping to conclusions, evidence of coaching - ie PARENTAL ALIENATION SYNDROME, and more.

With regard to adult claims, I would say that if anything these are far more unreliable for many reasons. A child accuser may be mistaken or coached, but an adult may have all manner of issues.


February 1996: Another sad case from Scotland; this was actually raised in Parliament. Stephen McLaughlin has sex with former girlfriend Elidh Connell. At 2am the following day he is arrested. Connell withdraws the allegation, saying she made it to make her boyfriend jealous. Go figure. She is charged with wasting police time, and pleads not guilty. In February 1997, she appears at Ayr Sheriff Court where it takes a jury just fifteen minutes to convict her. She is given 240 hours community service and a heavy fine. In October 1997, on his sister’s birthday, Stephen McLaughlin drives to a remote spot in the Galloway Forest and kills himself; he was 23 years old.

[The above is based on a report in The Daily Record, November 10, 1998, page 10 - extracted from NewsUK].


February 1996: Although this New Zealand case does not concern a false rape allegation, it is included here to show both that young girls can and do lie, and that women can also be the innocent targets of their ire. This girl admitted in court to lying about being sexually abused by her mother as well as by a friend of her father.


February 1, 1996: This is the date the incident was reported to law enforcement; it actually dates to May 6, 1995. This is a bizarre case which ended up in the civil courts with the accused winning damages against the accuser. The parties were referred to only by letters. In his Supreme Court of British Columbia judgment, Mr Justice Collver was not impressed with the claim about the condom in the hot tub. Nor should you be.


February 1, 1996: False rape accuser Liz Skene is given nine months of probation at Falkirk Sheriff Court. She had accused Brian Ross of rape. After his arrest, DNA testing proved they had not had sex, non-consensual or otherwise. Then in court, she accused him of raping her again, this time a year previously!

Here is an earlier report - of her conviction - from the Daily Record, December 15, 1995. My apologies for the poor quality scan; this is the best copy possible.


February 3/4, 1996: Brown University student Adam Lack goes to bed with fellow student Sarah Klein, or Sara Klein ’99 as she is usually styled. In the morning, they exchange phone numbers. The following month, she accuses him of rape, claiming she was too drunk to consent. No criminal charges are filed, but the case generates wide publicity. Accusers like her make a mockery of genuine rape victims.


February 15, 1996: Courtni Mahaffy phones the police and tells them she has been raped at knifepoint in her own home at Rancho Bernardo, California. She identifies Kevin Baruxes as her principal attacker. At eighteen he is two years younger than her, and appears to have been a bit of a Jack the Lad. The jury doesn’t buy his alibi, and on her word alone he is convicted, receiving a sentence of 18 years to life. He was exonerated in 2003.

This is a simplified page from The San Diego Union-Tribune, May 13, 2016. Herein you can read about how the case against him fell apart, and how he was nearly murdered in prison.


February 20, 1996: This is the date of a Supreme Court of British Columbia judgment in a custody dispute. It is offered here without comment save that it contains lunatic ravings by a girl about her dead parents.


February 22, 1996: Mrs Nobuko Nobuhira accuses Soka Gakkai Honorary President Daisaku Ikeda of raping her on three occasions. This was a notorious case in Japan which appears to have had a primarily if not exclusively financial motive. She and her husband were totally discredited. This link is to a simplified webpage of a timeline in English.


February 28, 1996: Cathy Fordham is allegedly attacked in her own home by a former lover, and is treated at a hospital for the resulting injuries - which were almost certainly self-inflicted. Whatever, on April 29 she makes a formal allegation of rape against Jamie Nelson, with whom she has history. Nelson is arrested, tried by a judge alone, and given what in the US would have been considered an extremely lenient sentence.

This notorious Canadian case was the subject of an excellent 2009 documentary by Ida Eva Zielinska. It will suffice here to say that eventually Fordham made one false allegation too many, Nelson was cleared on appeal, and Fordham was given a 6 month sentence for threatening a former lover. Sadly, it was not quite happy ever after for Nelson, but at least unlike Scott Espinosa, whose mother committed suicide while he was in prison, Nelson’s father lived long enough to see his son cleared.


March 14, 1996: Teenager Tracey McManus is given a non-custodial sentence at Falkirk Sheriff Court after admitting making a false rape allegation against Lawrence Kelly. This report is from the website of The Herald, (Glasgow).


March 17, 1996: A teenage student at the New College of Florida has sex with a former student in his room. A month later, she accuses him of rape, claiming after four glasses of wine she could not remember the whole incident and was too drunk to consent. Thankfully he was cleared. How pathetic are these stupid women?

This report appeared in the Saratosa Herald-Tribune, June 6, 1996, page 1B.


March 31, 1996: The documentary Cry Rape is broadcast in the 60 Minutes series. Here is an interesting document relating to it from the New Zealand Broadcasting Standards Authority.


March/April 1996: Counselors and the Backlash: “Rape Hype” and “False-Memory Syndrome” by Carolyn Zerbe Enns.

The above is a by and large hostile article. Any author who quotes Mary Koss with approval has to be suspect. The word confabulation appears only twice in its ten pages; it is confabulation along with loopy or outright mendacious therapists that has been responsible for so many of these terrible tragedies as in the Ramona case, see entry for March 15,1990, (above).

I have taken the liberty of adding a quotation mark to the above title.


March/April 1996: Distinguishing Between True and False Allegations of Sexual Abuse Part II: Allegations Involving Children by Felicity Goodyear-Smith, published in Patient Management, Vol. 25, No. 3/4, pages 61-4.

The above article from a New Zealand magazine so dated is the second part of or second article by the same author found at February 1996, (above).


April 15, 1996: This one is complicated. On said date, Indianapolis police officer John Walton is acquitted of rape. This appears to have been due partly to his eliciting testimony from two of the accuser’s co-workers that she had made two false rape allegations before. She denied making them, but the court accepted that she did, and so should you. Here is what the Supreme Court of Indiana said.


May 2, 1996: New York police officer Desmond Robinson and a female colleague go out drinking; the night ends with her accusing him of serious sexual offences as well as assault. Eventually she drops the sexual allegations, but Desmond is now an ex-police officer as he pleads guilty to assault.

The words of the female Assistant DA are worth noting: “...in all my years of experience working with sexual assault victims, I have never met a less candid individual who for months denied obvious facts.” Probably because she was married. That quote is taken from the New York Times; here is a simplified page.


Circa May 3, 1996: Elise Makdessi makes a tape alleging she had suffered sexual harassment, including rape, at the hands of several US Naval personnel with whom she worked. This is a truly fantastic false rape allegation made for purely financial motives, one which led to the murder of both an innocent man and of the false accuser herself at the hands of her co-conspirator husband.

On May 7, 2001, Eddie Makdessi was indicted by a grand jury for the murders of his wife and Quincy Brown - Brown was killed first; Elise immediately afterwards. He was convicted on March 16, 2006. His failed appeal before the Virginia Court of Appeals gives some background to the false rape claims, as does the October 2008 documentary Double Cross. File this one under GIVE ME MONEY.


May 16, 1996: Cambridgeshire Police reveal that a woman who claimed to have been raped in her own home while under police protection had made the whole thing up. The investigation must have dragged on a long time because it engaged 30 officers and was said to have cost £200,000. No charges were being brought against the woman, so she can be filed under HEAD CASE.

[The above is based on a report called Fantasy rape which was published in the London Times, May 17, 1996].


June 1996: Glyn Kirpalani is questioned by the police after his anonymous former lover accuses him of raping her twice between January and April 1995. This false allegation results in an action for slander at the High Court presided over by Mrs Justice Smith. It ends with a hung jury. The plaintiff had spent (for him) enormous sums of money, and this woman had dragged his name through the mud, something with which she was said to have been pleased.

[The source for the above, the London Times, May 13, 1999, page 8 - accessed through NewsUK].


July 2, 1996: An article so dated from The Free Lance-Star, page C2, reports that Fredericksburg woman Tina Campbell had accused her estranged husband of abducting and raping her. When her story fell apart, the rape and abduction charges against Robert T. Campbell were dropped, and she was charged with filing a false rape report.


July 5, 1996: A 14 year old girl is allegedly raped in Clearlake, California although she does not make this claim until the following spring, to a drug counselor. Under mandatory reporting regulations, the police are informed, and two men are arrested. In spite of her testimony being all over the place, Brendan Loftus and Arvind Balu are convicted.

This is a simplified page from The National Registry of EXONERATIONS that documents their roller coast ride to freedom which involved a judge incorrectly applying rape shield laws to conceal the fact that at the material time the girl was A VIRGIN.


August 1996: A teenager accuses taxi driver Ian Cuthbertson of rape. She was said to have been living out a bizarre fantasy. In July 1997, he is cleared at the High Court in Glasgow.


August 6, 1996: I invented my rapist is the title on the front cover of the magazine. Click here for more.


August 18, 1996: Recovered memories or delusion? by Tim Klass.

The above article was updated 15 years later. It covers several cases: Julie Alley; Ross Cheit (the San Francisco Boys Chorus case); Patricia Rice; Steven Cook; and Chuck Noah.

Cheit is a nutter with academic credentials; it remains to be seen if he really did forget the sexual abuse he suffered as a boy; one can only speculate as to what would be his reaction if one of his former students were to suddenly remember the sexual abuse he suffered at Cheit’s hands.

Here is a critical review of his magnum opus.


September 16, 1996: Englishman Albert Wilson is arrested in the Philippines accused of raping a 12 year old girl said to be his stepdaughter (in reality his common law stepdaughter). Wilson was charged initially with attempted rape, later increased to rape. He was convicted and sentenced to death in spite of the exculpatory evidence. His conviction was reversed on December 21, 1999.

Here is a legal document that sets out the background to the case and the final judgment. This appears to have been a rare EXTORTION ATTEMPT.


September 1996: In Edmonton, Canada, Bonnie Ambrose falsely accuses a police officer of rape. Bad move! In June 1998, she is convicted of effecting a public mischief; she receives a 2 year sentence. If you want the long version, click here.


September 1996: Ashley Pittman has sex with a fellow student. Two years later she withdraws her consent, or as the prosecution put it, she was was so traumatised by the alleged attack that she waited more than two years to contact the police. Yeah, right. Here’s a real gem: “The jury was told that because of the period that elapsed between the alleged attack and the allegation being made there was no forensic evidence to support the woman’s complaint.”

Fortunately, not all juries are as gullible as some prosecutors are venal. His trial at Swansea Crown Court ended on July 27, 2000 with the jury taking just 45 minutes to acquit him.


September 9, 1996: The headline on page 7 of The Daily Record reads GIRL CRIES RAPE TO GET PLANE HOME - School trip lies got man arrested - the story is credited to Tony Ellin.

This is a screengrab from a duplicate version on-line. The article concludes:

Cornwall schoolgirl Caroline Dickinson, 13, was raped and suffocated in a youth hostel in Brittany in July.

French police are still hunting her killer.


September 20, 1996: A 13 year old girl who claimed to have been raped in a restroom at Crossler Middle School, Salem, recants, apparently after CCTV evidence shows no evidence of a 6 foot 4 white male with a swastika tattoo behind his ear.

The girl’s case is said to have been referred to the grand jury. A better idea would have been to tell her father to take her to the woodshed. This article appeared The Register-Guard (Eugene, Oregon), September 21, 1996, page 5B.


October 6, 1996: A case from Rhode Island in which three men were accused of raping a drunken woman (although only two were on trial here) sees a local politician making a stellar pronouncement: “Four people were involved in this regrettable incident, three of them took responsibility for their actions. One did not”. The fact that the jury included six women indicates that ordinary women have more common sense than the sisterhood and the usual so-called anti-rape activists.


October 12, 1996: Christina Heaslet has sex with fellow student Nathaniel Lewis in her dormitory room at Akron University. She sees him out at the front desk then tells the resident coordinator for the dormitory she has been raped. This woman calls the police; Heaslet declines to speak to them or to press charges. She is taken to a hospital but then changes her mind. Lewis is arrested the following day. He is charged with rape. Several weeks before the trial date he receives an anonymous letter which contains xeroxed copies of excerpts from Heaslet’s diary, pages which imply she consented or even that she stitched him up. It remains to be seen who sent these pages. In spite of this clearly exculpatory evidence, on June 6, 1997 he is convicted, and on July 16, 1997 he is sentenced to eight years. The judge had excluded some of this evidence under the state’s rape shield law. Lewis appeals.

On October 2, 2002, the Supreme Court of the United States quashes his conviction.

This article by Hans Sherrer shows this sordid affair had a relatively happy ending for Nathaniel Lewis. My apologies for the way the two pages came out when reformatted.


October 16, 1996: Archna Gupta claims to have been kidnapped at knifepoint and sexually violated by her former lover Michael Lewis (whom she claimed to have known as Mike Daniels). The New England man is arrested on October 24, 1996 and held on her word alone. Eventually, the forensic evidence comes back, and it clears him, but he is not released until April 1998; the charges are dropped on May 7, 1998. Archna Gupta is indicted for perjury, pleads no contest, and is sentenced to five years. Later, during civil proceedings brought by Lewis, it is revealed she had made a previous false rape allegation.


October 30, 1996: The Court of Appeal of Alberta dismisses the appeal against sentence in the case of R v Hudon. There is not much information about this case in the public domain, suffice it to say that the teenage false accuser Nicole Hudon gave the police a detailed, horrifying but entirely fictitious account of her sexual violation at the hands of three men. She caused them a great deal of aggravation, and wasted police time and resources. Her sentence of 15 months was found to be anything but excessive.


November 1996: Baldev Singh is arrested for rape. He is charged, and spends 23 days on remand. In May 1997, at Birmingham Crown Court, the case is thrown out by the judge. See entry for December 2006.


November 13, 1996: West Point sophomore Su Jin Collier has sex with a fellow cadet - not for the first time - then accuses him of rape. Fortunately he is cleared, but she is in hot water.

This report is from The Daily Iowan, May 1, 1997, page 3A. She also made the New York Times the previous month wherein it was said she had hired a publicist, like any genuine rape victim would do. Not. Shortly she had an attack of common sense and threw in the towel.


November 14, 1996: Maria Hnatiuk tells a jury at Norwich Crown Court that she was a virgin when she was raped by the DJ Richard Skinner - this claim was actually made in a written statement; later on in the case, she said she had been put up to the false rape allegation. Hnatiuk was on trial for murder, and was convicted. In fact, the DJ had had a months’ long affair with the bisexual Hnatiuk, and there had apparently been some sort of plot between her and her lover to blackmail Skinner, who had wisely gone to the police.

On November 28, 1996, Hnatiuk was given a life sentence for the murder of teenager Rachael Lean.


November 14, 1996: A 27 year old woman claims to have been dragged into a garden and raped at Kincorth, Aberdeen late at night. On November 18, 1996, the Daily Record reports Aberdeen police confirm they have charged her with making a false rape allegation.


November 22, 1996: New Yorker Oliver Jovanovic meets Jamie Rzucek after lengthy cyber correspondence. What happens next is sordid and bizarre in equal measure, but she accuses him of rape. At his trial, Judge William Wetzel misapplies the rape shield law which results in crucial exculpatory evidence not being heard by the jury. It takes five years, but his conviction is eventually overturned.


November 22, 1996: A woman claims she was kidnapped and raped early in the day. Two days later, Orlando Police confirm the story is a hoax. She had picked up a man in her car who said he would take her to a crack house.


November 28, 1996: The heavily pregnant Maxine Malton is given a 4 month sentence at Manchester Crown Court after pleading guilty to perverting the course of justice; she had framed two strangers for a phantom rape.

This report is from the Daily Mail, November 29, 1996, page 27.


November 29, 1996: At Manchester Crown Court, a man is cleared of indecent assault. Although not a rape case it is important because it is said to be the first (recognised) case of false memory syndrome to come before a British court. (Having said that, see the 1994 Roger Mennell case for starters). The accuser - who was no doubt sincere - had, inter alia, read that most pernicious of books The Courage To Heal.

This article is from the London Times, November 30, 1996, page 1.


December 10, 1996: The body of Dennis Proudfoot is found in his car, two days after he was charged with rape. Later that month, his father received a letter from the alleged victim in which she recanted. This case was raised in the House of Commons by the Conservative MP John Greenway in July 1999, and in the House of Lords by Lord Campbell-Savours in February 2003.


December 13, 1996: It is reported that Cornelius Magee and Michael McCausland have been charged with several offences at St Mary’s College, Belfast where they worked as security guards. McCausland was alleged to have aided and abetted a third man to rape a 21 year old student. On June 13, 1997, the charges against the pair are withdrawn without explanation.


December 16, 1996: Melanie Gibbons attends a Dublin police station and claims to have been raped by a named individual. There had been no sexual contact between the two. Seven years later she appears in court after being extradited from England. She can offer no cogent explanation for pointing the finger at this man.


December 29, 1996: Nina Shahravan calls a Dallas TV reporter and tells him she has been raped by two football players. The next day, she goes to the police. Dallas police hold a press conference. The case is given wide publicity before it becomes clear that Erik Williams and Michael Irvin have rock solid alibis. On January 9, 1997, Shahravan formally recants. On September 16, 1997, she is sentenced to 90 days in gaol and fined $1,500 by Dallas judge Dan Wyde after pleading guilty to misdemeanor perjury.

According to her estranged husband, Shahravan had falsely accused both him and a former fiancé of rape before.


December 31, 1996: At Amsterdam, New York, Kelly Hammond stages a rape to cause problems for a former boyfriend. The local police chief is not amused, especially as this is her second false rape allegation in two years.

The linked article is from the FIRST EDITION of the newspaper that styles itself The Independent Voice of the Capital Region, page B6


Late 1996: Lynn Walker worked alongside Michael Garfoot. She claimed he had put his hand up her skirt. In January 1997, after he was suspended, she claimed he had almost raped her. His employer lifted the suspension and moved him to another branch, but when her allegations continued, he sued her for libel and slander. In court, these allegations became actual rape, oral rape and more. The CCTV evidence and all the other evidence indicated otherwise.

It is understandable why she never took these claims to the police - assuming she was sane - but on February 7, 2000, after an eight day trial at the High Court in Newcastle, Mr Garfoot won the case, and £400,000 damages.

[For the avoidance of doubt, the above Michael Garfoot is not the (much younger) Michael Garfoot who was convicted of sexually assaulting a 13 year old girl in 2012].


January 30, 1997: In Louisiana, John Kinsel is charged with the aggravated rape of a young girl. Click here for more.


February 2, 1997: The Sunday Times publishes a letter from a woman whose daughter had been brainwashed by a therapist.


February 18, 1997: In the Irish Republic, mother of eight Mary Darcy is confronted by a detective 3 weeks after she was allegedly raped. By a serendipitous happenstance, another police officer had seen her being carted away in an ambulance at precisely the time she was supposedly being violated by a phantom who was said to have borne a remarkable likeness to an Australia soap actor!

Darcy - who appears to have been an alcoholic - had been drinking all day. She was given a suspended sentence at Dublin Criminal Court in October 1998.


February 21, 1997: After dining with Little Miss Anonymous, Greenwich Village businessman Paul Krauth takes her back to his apartment for some hot sex. Shortly, for whatever reason, she accuses him of aggravated rape. He is arrested, but on the last day of the month, the non-case against him is dropped as yet again modern technology comes to the rescue.

Here is some background written shortly after his arrest.


February 25, 1997: No Child Of Mine is screened by ITV.

Represented as a dramatisation about a schoolgirl who had been systematically abused by a gang of wicked paedophiles, including her own mother, the following day the London Times reported that “The film has been condemned by the Association of Directors of Social Services, which claims to have evidence that the child portrayed in the drama has a history of making false allegations of rape against men”.

At the time of writing, the full film can be found on YouTube. Here is the official trailer. Ask yourself if this portrayal is even remotely credible, namely a group of people which includes not one but three women inciting a child to commit indecent acts.


March 12, 1997: 5 Women Say Sex Charges In Army Case Were Coerced by Peter T. Kilborn.

The above New York Times article is an example of what can happen when police and other investigators go trawling for victims, and the alleged victims insist they are not victims. It is also further proof as if any were needed that women do not belong in the armed forces, at least not under the command of men.


March 14, 1997: Misty Wedding tells police she was intoxicated and playing cards at 5am when two of her companions forced her to have sex. The following month, she contacts the police and tells them she made up the story. This one can be filed under several categories including CAMPUS ACCUSER.

This report appeared in the Kentucky New Era, April 3, 1997, page 1B.


March 21, 1997: Staff Sergeant Nathanael C. Beach is cleared of sexual misconduct; on March 20, rape charges are dropped against a US Army captain.

Allegations of sexual harassment, sexual assault and even of rape in the military became endemic, and no doubt some of the charges were well founded, but false allegations and truthful ones are the inevitable result of this politically correct insanity. Women do not belong in the military; where they are used in auxiliary roles, they should always be segregated from men and should always but always be under the command of a female officer.

This report is from page 15A of the Saratosa Herald-Tribune.


April 17, 1997: The Taint Hearing by Ralph Underwager & Hollida Wakefield.

The above paper by two leading researchers in the field covers the development of taint hearings in child sexual abuse trials since the notorious Kelly Michaels case; precursors are included.


April 17, 1997: Inspector Geoffrey Smith who is based at Paddington Green Police Station is alleged to have raped and indecently assaulted a woman in her London home. The first media reports seem to have appeared circa December 9 that year.

On July 17, 1998, the London Times reported simply (at page 9) that he had been accused of raping a 28 year old woman police officer, but that the case had been dropped because there was no evidence against him.

[The above report was accessed through NewsBank Newspapers - U.K. and Ireland].


April 20, 1997: According to this article from the Beaver County Times, in August 1996, Gerald Kowalski of Erie, Michigan, met Kinberly Tufts in a bar, had sex with her in a nearby alley, and ended up being charged with rape. Fortunately, after spending 25 days in gaol, the truth came out: the non-victim maded up the rape claim because she was afraid of losing her boyfriend.

In December 1998, a woman named Kimberly Tufts was arrested in Michigan for a trivial offence. If this is the same woman, there is a serious age discrepancy; also the latter is said to have been five foot one but to weigh 145 pounds, so if it is indeed the same woman, Kowalski was obviously drunk as well as framed.


April 24, 1997: A report from the Daily Record, April 25, 1997, page 9. Rosie MacKenzie was engaged to John Cato, who at this point in time was “too drunk to satisfy her”, so she went to the house of a former lover, a man 24 years her senior, had sex with him, then accused him of rape. She pleaded guilty at Dingwall Sheriff Court to making a false allegation. John forgave her!


April 25, 1997: Jill Harth files a lawsuit against Donald Trump in a New York district court. Click here for much more.


May 6, 1997: This is another notorious case that needs no citations because it resulted in the trial, and acquittal, of two 10 year old boys for the rape of a 9 year old girl; they were and remain the youngest boys ever to be tried for rape. On said date, there was what might be called an incident in the outside toilet of a London school which resulted in legal proceedings being brought against four boys, the oldest of whom was 11.

A fifth boy was involved, but he was 9 years old, ie doli incapax. When the case came to trial at the Central Criminal Court in January 1998, it was revealed that the victim had been coached by a female police officer, perhaps inadvertently. Mrs Justice Bracewell directed the jury to return not guilty verdicts on the rape charges, and eventually all four boys were cleared of all charges.

Although no rape or indecent assault was committed, it is clear the girl was abused physically. When I was growing up in the 60s, kids would often bully or assault others, as I know from personal and painful experience, but it was an unwritten rule that you never hit a girl.


May 31, 1997: In New Hampshire, Mary Hensley tells the police she was raped by Corey Clark. After Clark’s arrest, a woman named Krista Witham claims she offered to drop the charges for a financial consideration. Clark made a foolish mistake by initially denying he’d had sex with Hensley, but on June 17, 1997, Hensley recanted officially, although she tried to pass the buck to another woman. She went on to make another allegation of rape, one she did not recant.


June 4, 1997: This report so dated tells the tale of James Chapman and “the Bitch from Hell”. His trial at the High Court in Glasgow saw his accuser taken apart under cross-examination.


June 25, 1997: This article so dated is a screengrab from a much simplied page which was published originally in the Daily Mail.

In 1986, it was reported that Beverley Hayles had accused Keith Desmond Burgher of rape, apparently three years previously. The police refused to take action, but she sought and was granted a temporary restraining order against him. In April 1999 she was back in the news for a bona fide reason. She was said to have permanently damaged her retina with an anti-bacterial shampoo.

File Miss Hayles under HEAD CASE.


July 1, 1997: Joel Hungerford and John Morahan are in effect found not guilty of committing unspeakable crimes.

This is not one case but two from New Hampshire; Hungerford had been accused of violating his own adult daughter for most of her life; Morahan was a teacher who was accused of raping a pupil.

These were both repressed memory cases; it is truly shocking that this sort of mumbo jumbo can be permitted to poison the minds of already mentally unbalanced young women much less be used to send men to gaol for decades. Hungerford went on to sue his daughter’s therapist.


July 11, 1997: Taxi driver Donald Lamont is cleared at the High Court in Glasgow of raping a housewife when the prosecution declines to proceed.

[Report for the above in The Daily Record, July 12, 1997, page 17 - accessed through NewsUK].


July 13, 1997: Lori Dell tells police at Hartford, Connecticut she was kidnapped the previous day by two men and a woman, driven to Hartford, and sexually assaulted. It is not clear if this is an allegation of rape or of a lesser sexual assault, but it is clear from this report that it never happened.


August 7, 1997: In the small hours, Irish national Annette Mangan is making out with a man she met on the island of Cyprus. There are conflicting accounts of what happened next, but it appears the two were not alone, and when she realised one of the others was taking photographs, she made a false allegation of rape which resulted in the arrest of 3 Irish soldiers.

The local police were on the ball, and by 11 that night they were challenging her version of events. It is unclear if she actually had sex with her liaison, but she was certainly not raped. Her sister claimed she thought she had been raped - yeah, sure. According to one report she was “confused and humiliated” and felt as though she had been “raped psychologically, if not physically.”

She pleaded guilty to making a false rape allegation and wasting police time. She was given a four month sentence. This and the Warburton case (August 25, 1997 below) were widely reported at the time.


August 14, 1997: Although this New Zealand case is said here to be a false allegation of rape, it appears to have been only an alleged indecent assault. It is included because of the lengths to which Debra Wood went to frame a total stranger, and the outcome, a two year sentence after her conviction for perjury.

Her case is discussed at length in this November 2004 document (in which her Christian name is misspelt).


August 18, 1997: In Hawaii, a grand jury indicts Lloyd West on four counts of sexually violating a young girl, including vaginal rape. He is convicted. These alleged offences date to February 1993 when the girl was four years old. In March 2000, an appellate court quashes his convictions.

The court did this in part because the girl had made other allegations of a sexual nature, allegations that although clearly false were excluded by the trial judge. It also allowed so-called expert evidence relating to child sexual abuse accommodation syndrome (apparent delay in reporting). What is missing from this judgment and from the case is real medical evidence; the girl was found to be virgo intacta. Can a child of that age be vaginally raped without leaving some evidence, and what of her mother?

The reader will find a number of cases in this database of very young girls making or apparently making false allegations of sexual abuse without coaching, as may have happened here. See in particular the entry for May 12, 1986 (above).


August 25, 1997: A Famagusta court on the island of Cyprus fines Susan Warburton and her lover Paul Shearsmith the equivalent of $645 after they plead guilty to public mischief and conspiracy. The previous week they had told police she was raped in her room by a hotel employee. Warburton was a mother of four, which begs the question why wasn’t she at home with her kids?


August 27, 1997: This is the date of a judgment by an Illinois court in a child custody case. A rather bizarre false rape allegation here was made by a man, who claimed his lover had been raped when she had not. He appears to have done this hoping to have the child taken into the care of the state.


Circa September 1997: A woman falsely accuses two (unnamed, apparently unidentified, and likely non-existent) Asian men of rape. She tries to claim a criminal injuries compensation payout, but is refused. This is an acknowledged false rape allegation. With regard to the others, this judgment was handed down by the Scottish Court of Session in October 2013. Presumably there must have been substantial medical evidence to support her claims against her uncle.


September 1997: You must remember this... by Sandra Martin.

The above anonymised article tells the tragic story of one Canadian family and the damage caused by so-called therapists and recovered memories.


September 1997: Creating False Memories by Elizabeth Loftus.

The above is an interesting article by the world’s leading authority on false memories. It covers inter alia the case of Beth Rutherford, who was brainwashing into believing she had been impregnated by her own father.


September 5, 2007: An Ottawa woman is allegedly sexually assaulted (Canadian-speak for raped) at knifepoint in her own home. The man responsible was posing as a police officer, or he would have been had he existed. Shortly, a real police officer confirms he does not.


September 10, 1997: A teenager is not abducted early morning from the entrance to an apartment block in Allegheny Township, Pennsylvania, held for 12 hours and raped before being dropped off that night at the cemetery.

This appears to have been a COPYCAT false rape allegation, and a particularly stupid one at that, although when she came clean she offered no explanation as to why she had made it. This article appeared in the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette (FINAL), September 18, 1997, page B-5.


September 20, 1997: Converse College student Elizabeth Bender is not snatched by an unknown assailant, blindfolded, handcuffed and raped as she leaves the Ground Zero nightclub. It remains to be seen why she told the police she was, but one female officer was not happy:

“We feel it is unfortunate, but often times communities are deceived by fictitious allegations” said Lieutenant Kendall of the Spartanburg Public Safety Department.

The above was extracted from the Herald-Journal, October 1, 1997, page 1.


October 1997: In the Philippines, Father Macario Peig Apuya is accused of raping a 15 year old girl, who for good measure ropes in his elderly mother. It takes five years to clear his name.

This report is from the Philippine Daily Inquirer, December 21, 2002, page A25.


October 1997: This is another well-documented horror story that needs no citations. Under pressure from her drug addict mother, 8 year old Chaneya Kelly accuses her own father of violating her. In the United States, crimes of this nature attract horrendous sentences, and Daryl Kelly is sentenced to 20-40 years in prison. As soon as she is able to understand her actions, Chaneya recants, but her voice is not heard. Daryl Kelly remains behind bars convicted on nothing more than words.


October 3, 1997: A Florida teenager reports being kidnapped and raped, but three weeks later her lies unfold and she is arrested. She is taken to the Marion County Jail then shortly released into her mother’s custody. This report is from the Ocala Star-Banner, October 24, 1007, front page & page 4A.


November 1997: Elizabeth Wyper sleeps with James Crawford after a party then claims he raped her - to explain to her mother why she had stayed out all night. The victim is questioned for hours before his accuser admits she lied. On April 29, 1998, she appears before Sheriff Colin Miller at Ayr who orders her to do community service and pay Mr Crawford £500. (Story reported in the national press for April 30, 1998, including the London Daily Mail).


November 2, 1997: In California, Damon Auguste is arrested for the rape of a 15 year old girl named Monique. He and Kamani Hendricks are convicted in October 1998; both receive heavy sentences. Auguste comes from a wealthy family, and eventually their money and persistence pay off.

This article from mercurynews dot com gives a fair account of this case. The day after Auguste was arrested, Linda Marshall was kidnapped and raped, also in California. She lied to the police and was not believed. These two also lied. It remains to be seen if they would have been cleared had they been truthful about having sex with their teen slut accuser, but lying to the police - whether victim or accused - is always inadvisable, especially in a rape case, more so for an accused, whose ordeal has yet to begin.


November 3, 1997: In Pleasanton, California, Linda Marshall is kidnapped by James Daveggio and Michelle Michaud. Click here for more.


November 8 & November 21, 1997: Candace Kane of Agawam, Massachusetts, files a false rape report against a local businessman. He is arrested on account of one of these false reports, but twenty alibi witnesses undermine her lies! She rather than he ends up in court where she is ordered to undergo counselling.

[The above information was extracted from Union-News, January 7, 1998, page B2 and the Sunday Republican (Springfield, Massachusetts), March 12, 2000, page A01, (accessed through NewsBank)].


November 18, 1997: The briefest of reports so dated from New Zealand: Lohenet Zarmani makes a false rape allegation, but receives no punishment from the court.


November 22, 1997: This article so dated was published in the New Straits Times, page 16. Fake photographs be they of women being raped or of other atrocities are commonplace in war-time, even if the war is entirely one-sided.

See also the report for May 13-5, 1998 (below) for other false atrocity claims from Indonesia.


November & December 1997: In New York City, a 13 year old girl accuses a 17 year old youth of raping her two months in a row. Then she recants. Should she really have been charged with false reporting? For one false allegation, perhaps not, but for two? This article appeared on page CY6 of The New York Times, February 1, 1998.


1998: An unnamed nurse makes a false rape allegation in Devon. See entry for Roy Burnett for the full story.


1998: At Easthampton, Massachusetts, Kimberly Mileau is fined the maximum $500 after admitting making a false report of rape. She did it to conceal an extramarital affair.

[The above information was extracted from the Sunday Republican (Springfield, Massachusetts), March 12, 2000, page A01, (accessed through NewsBank). This article contains a doozy: “In a court of law, a confession is not enough; the prosecution must have corroborating evidence showing that the suspect’s confession is truthful.” The reality is of course that in rape and other cases with a sexual angle, not only is no corroboration required but no evidence is required, only plausible lies by an accuser].


January 1998: Pennsylvania schoolteacher Michael Gallagher is suspended after a former student of his named Margaret Powell accuses him of raping her in 1985-6. He is arrested, charged and due to stand trial November 30, but prosecutors do their homework uncovering evidence that his accuser has experienced recovered memories. Gallagher gets his life back and says false accusers should be prosecuted; the problem is that women (and men) who make these kinds of false allegations are not lying, they believe their delusions.


January 1998: A teenager falsely accuses a man of rape; she goes on to falsely accuse Kevin Ford in June 2001.


January 1998: Jason Grant is accused of raping a teenager who claimed he forced her to take a bath afterwards to destroy the forensic evidence. The girl said their friendship had been purely platonic, but the defence said they’d had sex many times before. When he stood trial at Manchester in October 2008, the jury cleared him in three hours, and the judge awarded him his costs - a double endorsement of his innocence.


New Year’s Day, 1998: Yet again, we see the first day of the year leading to REGRET SEX, and on this occasion there can be no doubt that he regretted it more than she did. Peter Phillips of Sunderland ends up in HMP Durham, but when his case comes up at Newcastle Crown Court, it doesn’t even go to the jury.

This report is a simplified page from the website of the Sunderland Echo, January 5, 2000 - including the incomplete title.


January 1, 1998: Rape Shield Laws and Prior False Accusations of Rape: The Need for Meaningful Legislative Reform by Christopher Bopst.

The above article by an American lawyer is a fairly comprehensive and unhysterical overview of this difficult subject.


January 3, 1998: In Malaysia, Army dentist Lieutenant Colonel Dr Harjandar Singh has sex with a subordinate. For whatever reason, she accuses him of rape. The case is rightly dismissed because as the judge pointed out, she didn’t use her army training or even scream. This report appeared in the New Straits Times, May 13, 2000, page 10.


January 15, 1998: This is a rarity, a woman is cleared of rape. This case at the High Court in Kilmarnock didn’t even go to the jury. In the dock with Martin Hollywood was his girlfriend Stephanie McCallum. From previous reports it is clear that the two girls came up with this suggestion, and is a guy really going to object? Miss X made sure she shed a few tears, thankfully to no avail. File this one under REGRET SEX.


March 21, 1998: At Lee’s Summit, Missouri, the future Tina McKinley accuses her then husband Theodore White of sexually abusing her daughter/his stepdaughter. This is not a rape allegation but is included here because of the extraordinary circumstances relating to it. This judgment by the Eighth Circuit gives the full background to the case. Note especially the lies, collusion and the previous (threatened) false allegation by Tina McKinley against her first husband.


April 1998: This is another example of women having no agency when it comes to sex. The following is summarised from The Independent, October 17, 2000, page 10, accessed through NewsUK:

British Airways purser Julian Henry and a stewardess enjoy a long drinking session consuming champagne suspected of being stolen from their aircraft. Initially the captain and another crew member are imbibing with them in Henry’s Washington hotel room, but after the other two leave, Henry and the stewardess end up in bed together. She wakes up in his bed and cries rape. The rape case is dropped in 1999, but Henry pleads NO CONTEST to assault and battery, he probably thumped her after she lost the plot. Unreal. If there is anyone who should have been outraged here, it was Henry’s wife.


April 1, 1998: A report so dated from the London Times, page 8: “Angela Brookhouse, 21, of Warrington, who claimed she had been gang-raped because she was ashamed of having sex with a man she hardly knew, was sent to a young offender institution for two months. She admitted trying to pervert the course of justice.”


April 7, 1998: Sean Murphy and his mother Sylvia write to the Archdiocese of Boston demanding $850,000 compensation. Click here for more.


April 7, 1998: Zwelakhe Abedingo Luthuli is arrested for the violation of an underage girl. Similo Portia Phahla claims he raped her several times between November 1997 and March 1998. The medical evidence indicates the girl has never had full penile sex, but Mr Luthuli is convicted anyway, and on February 2, 2000 he is given a ten year sentence. His appeal is dismissed by the KwaZulu-Natal High Court, Pietermaritzburg on September 14, 2000.

In December 2002, the girl recants her testimony, and on December 20, 2004 he is released on a nominal surety. On October 17, 2010, Portia Phala dies, but on October 1, 2014, the Supreme Court of South Africa quashes the rape conviction. There is medical evidence that the alleged victim was beaten by her mother, the inference being that the girl had had sex with her boyfriend, and was too frightened to tell the truth. In all, a very sad tale.


April 12, 1998: At Flushing Meadows, New York, a young woman claims to have been abducted by three men and raped at gunpoint. Under questioning, the gun disappears, one of the men vanishes, and the rape becomes a consensual if sordid act. Bad girl Miss er, what was your name again?


April 22, 1998: At North Stonington, Connecticut, Tina Bourdon is charged with filing a false rape report. The previous summer she claimed she’d been raped by two unnamed men when really she’d had consensual sex with one, an act for which she was paid.

This article from the New London newspaper The Day, April 24, 1998, page 2.


May 13, 1998: Thomas McKenna is cleared at the High Court in Kilmarnock of raping a woman in her own home. She had made two false rape allegations before, and had been charged with public mischief on that account in 1992. Her excuse for her behaviour on one of these previous occasions was that she had been sexually abused by her father when she was four. So that makes her a SERIAL FALSE ACCUSER.

[The above is based on a report in the Sun, May 14, 1998, page 34 accessed through NewsBank Newspapers - U.K. and Ireland].


May 13-5, 1998: Riots erupt in Indonesia. A number of Chinese women are alleged to have been raped, a claim that is bolstered by fake photographs distributed abroad. Here is the retraction of an honest man who admits he has been conned.


May 14-6, 1998: False allegations of rape in adults by K.L Gibbon.

The above article from a medical conference contains an anonymised and quite revolting case of a young white woman - a junkie - who turned up at a hospital (presumably in England) claiming to have been sexually violated by one of those dangerous black predators, the type who does not exist. She had been sexually violated all right, by herself. There are references to studies of false rape including Kanin.

I am not certain the actual date this paper was read because although I found a programme of events dated March 1998, the name Karen Gibbon does not appear in it, so I can only assume she was a late/substitute speaker.


May 17, 1998: Roger Raymond takes a teenager twenty years his junior home to his Camberwell apartment, has sex with her, and ends up accused of rape. Later that year he stands trial, and is cleared of all charges.

This report was culled from the South London Press, November 6, 1998, page 22.


May 20, 1998: Freed nurses to speak out on sexual abuse by Daniel McGrory and Michael Theodoulou.

This story appeared on page 3 of the London Times. Although it is not a false rape allegation, it is worth discussing in some depth. It is a notorious case which led to considerable controversy with all manner of false allegations being made against the Saudi Government, and two cold-blooded killers escaping justice.

On December 12, 1996, the Australian nurse Yvonne Gilford was brutally murdered at the King Fahd Military Medical Complex, Dharhan. British nurses Deborah Parry and Lucille McLauchlan were promptly arrested, and the evidence against them was overwhelming. They were convicted by a sharia court, and Parry was facing a death sentence. Saudi justice may not meet international norms, but there was no doubt the court got it right.

Parry was facing execution, but due to the Saudi system and a lot of legal wrangling, the two women were allowed to return to the UK where they portrayed themselves as victims, claiming they had been sexually assaulted by their interrogators and threatened with rape.

These two were not the kind of nurses you’d want administering you an enema, but unbelievably Parry was allowed to resume her career. McLauchlan was an out and out crook who had been facing a fraud charge when she went to Saudi. She was convicted on her return, and struck off. In 2012 she was convicted of fraud again, but in January 2014 a Higher Power finally caught up with her when she suffered a brain haemorrhage at her Dundee home and died in hospital at the age of 48.


May 29, 1998: The National Association for People Abused in Childhood is registered with the Charity Commission. Click here for more.


May 31, 1998: A teenager claims to have been raped at Busch Gardens, Williamsburg on said date, although she doesn’t report it for over a month. On July 17, the local police chief tells the press she was pregnant when she fabricated the story, and did not know what to do. She will not be charged. This report is from The Free Lance-Star, July 18, 1998, page C4.


July 1, 1998: A Coventry schoolgirl is raped, but: “after police interviewed her yesterday afternoon, she admitted she had fabricated the allegations because she was worried about going home late.”

The above quote is taken from Girl’s rape claim false published in the Coventry Evening Mail, July 3, 1998, page 18. This story was also reported in the (Birmingham) Evening Mail, July 3, 1998, page 18 likewise as Girl’s rape claim false.


July 23, 1998: This report so dated sees Oliver Thompson cleared of rape at Harrow Crown Court. It also highlights an all too common problem, the police and the CPS failing to do their homework. Thompson picked up a HEAD CASE hoping to have a good time with her, and ended up in the dock.


July 25, 1998: Teenager Robert Gough is cleared of rape at the High Court in Glasgow. He had been drinking with the 15 year old, and there had been some intimate contact, but no sex, indeed a doctor who examined her said she was STILL A VIRGIN, which begs the question how did it ever go to trial?

Most interestingly, a teacher named Alastair Fleming testified for the defence to the effect that the girl had once falsely accused him of touching her breast, although later she withdrew the allegation.


July 30, 1998: This is the date of a judgment. As you will see, dear reader, the case concerns a male ASYLUM SNEAKER who got creative with his application, claiming his sister had been raped in his native Sri Lanka. The New Zealand authorities didn’t buy that or any of his other lies, and neither should you.


August 1998: Drug addict Regina Birindelli tells police she was gang-raped by three men on May 16, 1998; she says they videoed the assaults which were vaginal, anal and oral. They are convicted, the jury being impressed by her apparent emotion and by the claim that she had no motive to lie. Emotions are easily faked, and motives hidden. Here is the truth.


August 2, 1998: In the small hours of a Sunday morning, Spokane police answer a 911 call from a residential area. When they arrive, a young female motorist tells them she has been gang-raped by five men from another vehicle. She is taken to hospital, examined and released. She is not interviewed formally until Tuesday when information about the alleged gang-rape is released to the media, but after seeing the resulting reports, she contacts the police and tells them the sex with the five men was consensual.

This report appeared in The Spokesman-Review, August 5, 1998, page B6. File this one under AIN’T NUTHIN’ LIKE A GANG BANG.


September 6, 1998: White slut Shawn Stratton has sex with three black dudes at the University of Wisconsin, then accuses them of rape. Here is a simplified page from The National Registry of EXONERATIONS concerning this particularly sordid case. Jarrett Adams was seventeen at the time; he went on to become an attorney. Stay away from those ho’s, bro.


September 16, 1998: Missouri woman Judith Lummis is allegedly kidnapped at knifepoint and sexually violated. Click here for more.


September 21, 1998: Police in Morecambe close an investigation into a claim that a woman had been raped on York Bridge when the victim admitted she had made it up. Apparently the poor woman had been under pressure for a variety of reasons, and had been referred for medical help and counselling instead of being charged with wasting police time.

This article appeared on the front page of The Visitor (Morecambe), September 23, 1998. My apologies for the poor quality scan, which was beyond my control.


October 13, 1998: Two false rape allegations the same day in New Zealand! At Wainuiomata, a 16 year old girl claims to have been attacked by three men. At Lower Hutt, a 14 year old claims to have been dragged into a car by six men and raped. Must have been a big car, but not as big as her imagination, mind, she was drunk at the time.

This report is from The New Zealand Herald, October 22, 1998, page A14. It alludes too to Debra Wood of Upper Hutt who was given a two year sentence for perjury in September 1998 after falsely accusing a man of indecently assaulting her in Petrone. (See entry for August 14, 1997).

Lower Hutt police are said too to be concerned at the growing number of young women getting drunk then making false allegations of sexual assault including rape.


October 14/5, 1998: At Amsterdam, New York, a woman has a late night dust up with her boyfriend. She calls the police, and he is arrested after a scuffle. Then Miriam Rivera accuses him of raping and sodomising her. The major charges against Luis Torres-Rivera are soon dropped when she admits the sex was consensual. Subsequently, she too is arrested.

This article appeared in The Daily Gazette, October 16, 1998, page B14.


October 26, 1998: In spite of its title, this is a false allegation of attempted rape rather than rape period. A deranged wife on the island of Malta tries to win back her estranged husband by making a false allegation against another man. This one is actually quite complicated, but it remains to be seen why it took the courts until October 2002 to dispose of it.


November 2, 1998: Lies, Personality Disorders and Expert Evidence: New Developments in the Law by Ian Freckelton and Teresa Henning.

The above is an interesting article by a barrister and a legal scholar. It concerns a then recent alleged case of male-on-male sexual assault in Tasmania (and the reliabilty or otherwise of complainants who are not right in the head. Like most of us in the 21st Century!


December 1, 1998: This is the date ASYLUM SNEAKER Amina Muse claimed to have seen her brothers murdered in Somalia, where she was also gang-raped. The only problem was, she had been living in Sweden since 1995! She also went by the name Ayan Abdulle, and although she was granted Swedish citizenship, she is probably not originally from Somalia. In January 2011, she was given a four and a half year sentence at Harrow Crown Court for fraud.


December 3, 1998: A 13 year old girl is raped at knifepoint in the back of a postal van by a black man at Newton, Massachusetts. That’s the bad news. The good news is that the dude was actually white and the sex was consensual. The truth was revealed by Beverly Ford and Ann E. Donlan writing in the Boston Herald, December 31, 1998, page 1, (NewsBank).

Yeah, I know, a 13 year old girl can’t consent; the boy concerned is said to be 17. She should be taken to the woodshed; if he did face a statutory rape charge as suggested here, he has only himself to blame.


December 8/9, 1998: Here is a rape allegation that should definitely not have been taken seriously. Brian Salmi is found chained to a bed and gagged in an Earl’s Court hotel. He would tell the police he had been held prisoner and force-fed Viagra by two blondes! The hoax was exposed by the News Of The World on December 20. Salmi appears to have a track record for this kind of stupidity.


December 13, 1998: A motorist tells police she was forced off the road by a man in a pickup truck. She was then dragged from her vehicle and raped. This happened at Mendon, Massachusetts. Or did it? Three days before Christmas, Detective Ernest Horn announces this incident was fabricated “to obscure other unrelated behavior”.

[The above information was extracted from the Worcester Telegram & Gazette (Massachusetts), December 23, 1998, page B1, (accessed through NewsBank)].


December 19, 1998: Gerald Regan is cleared of all charges. This is a surprisingly little known and totally contrived witch-hunt of a powerful politician. Gerald Augustine Paul Regan was Premier of Nova Scotia from October 1970 to October 1978. In 1993, it was announced he was being investigated for historical sex crimes, and as often in cases of this nature, one allegation leads to another and another and another.

This report on his trial and acquittal is a good starting point. An attempt was made to bring further charges in 2002, but thankfully nothing came of it.


Christmas Day, 1998: Three young girls visit an octogenarian on their own initiative; they are aged 11 to 16 but are clearly not sugar and spice. In spite of their young ages, they have been drinking alcohol and are carrying bottles of vodka. After bluffing their way in they proceed to take liberties with this clearly vulnerable man, and when he asks them to leave they say they will tell people he raped them. They do precisely that, they tell one man at any rate, teenager Daryl Jee, who confronts the victim at ten o’clock the next night, forces his way in, and smashes the place up.

Prior to this he had gone to the wrong house and vandalised a car when no one answered the door. Jee was tried at a lower court, in Nuneaton on January 25, 1999 where he pleaded guilty to two counts of criminal damage and one of unlawful entry. WHAT’S THE MATTER WITH KIDS TODAY?

[The above was summarised from the Coventry Telegraph, January 26, 1999, page 2 - accessed through NewsUK].


December 31, 1998: This one takes the biscuit, and it is not even unique - see the May 2007 case of Victoria Patrick. Earlier in the month, two Edinburgh police officers are called to a party where Catherine Steven is drunk and abusive. Instead of ejecting her or even arresting her, they drive her home. So she accuses them of rape. Although she is given a 3 month sentence on New Year’s Eve, she serves only ten days before being freed on appeal, and in April 1999 her sentenced is quashed; she is given community service instead. This one can only be filed under NO GOOD DEED GOES UNPUNISHED.


1999: Rape Myth Acceptance: Exploration of Its Structure and Its Measurement Using the “Illinois Rape Myth Acceptance Scale” is published. Click here for more.


1999: Willie Baker of Florida is accused of raping his underage sister-in-law known only as D.A. The jury is not permitted to hear about her previous false allegations of sexual abuse, and he is convicted. More than a decade later his nightmare ends when his conviction is quashed and the Eleventh Circuit dismisses the State of Florida’s appeal.


1999: The case of false accuser Rebecca Harland and victim Scott Smith is if not unique then surely a rarity, a rape victim who is also a wilful false accuser! This report, from the Bangor Daily News, September 16, 2005, page B2, says it all.


January 1999: This is a really tragic case. Schoolteacher Darryl Gee is arrested at his home accused of raping a pupil some ten years previously. He is convicted and sentenced to eight years in prison. He loses an appeal. In August 2002, he dies in Armley Prison from a rare blood cancer, but his elderly mother vows to fight on and clear his name. In April 2006, he is cleared posthumously.

The same accuser was responsible for the false conviction of John Hudson.


January 1999: The case of false accuser Liza Watts was widely reported, but the details herein were extracted from Rape In A Vacuum, page 32.

Teenage barmaid Watts from Crawley claimed to have been raped by a man who offered her a lift home from the public house where she worked. She wasted 60 hours of police time. When she appeared in court she was said to have made similar claims in the past, which means she is almost certainly a SERIAL FALSE RAPE ACCUSER. She was found guilty and ordered to pay £50 costs plus £150 compensation and put on one year’s probation.

She would claim later this was a plea for help because she had been sexually abused all her childhood. Which begs the question, why should we believe that claim either? She was described as a borderline psychotic with “the mind of a 12 to 13 year old”.


January 1, 1999: SERIAL FALSE ACCUSER Shannon Taylor claims to have been raped outside a social club. In October the same year, in spite of no forensic evidence, Warren Blackwell is convicted and receives a 3 year sentence at Northampton Crown Court extended to 5 years on appeal! On September 12, 2006, he is finally cleared by the Court of Appeal. Taylor is named by Lord Campbell-Savours under Parliamentary privilege. The full judgment can be found here.


January 19, 1999: Samantha Heywood appears at Cardiff Crown Court. She had accused her mother of abusing her and no fewer than six men of rape. Four men had been arrested, and a thousand hours of police time wasted. She was said to have accused one man because he was “good-looking, had a good job but didn’t want to know her”. In spite of all this she was given probation after pleading guilty to seven charges of perverting the course of justice.

[The above is based on a report in the London Times, January 20, 1999, page 5].


January 26, 1999: Student Rowena Jones is found in the grounds of her university, distressed, having apparently been bound, and, she said, raped. She had already graduated - in a real subject rather than gender studies - and was studying for an MA. She made a 27 page statement and wasted 900 hours of police time before the truth came out. Exeter magistrates decided she needed a quiet place to continue her studies, so after her guilty plea they gave her a 2 month sentence. In mitigation, her solicitor said Jones had been raped two years before her false claim, but didn’t report it. So she can report a false rape but not a genuine one? Pull the other one.


February 1, 1999: A report is filed with the authorities of a rape at Mayflower Hall, University of Iowa. It is said to have happened around 12.30am on January 25. But it gets better, it is not the alleged victim who files the report; it is her mother.

This article appeared in The Daily Iowan, February 15, 1999, page 8A. Although this bloke is being extremely cautious - probably fearful of being branded a rape apologist - it is clear from this and from a previous report that no rape happened.


February 24, 1999: Juanita Broaddrick appears on Dateline NBC and claims she was raped by Bill Clinton in 1978. At the time she made this accusation, he was President of the United States; at the time he didn’t rape her, he was Attorney General of Arkansas. She appears to have first made this claim some time before, although not the day it happened and never to the police. For what it is worth, a transcript of the Broaddrick interview can be found here.


March 28, 1999: Julie Gavin bangs on the door of a police station at Nechells, Birmingham; she is crying as she says to an officer: “Can you help me? I have been raped”. (No question mark in the original). And no rape either. Her original claim was that she had been dragged into a Volvo after alighting from a bus, and driven to a nearby road where she was raped at knifepoint. Obviously the police launched an intensive hunt, their investigation included taking swabs from under her fingernails. But, on April 15, 1999, she returned to the police station and admitted “she had flagged down a passing motorist for a lift and then consented to sex with two passengers in the vehicle.” As you would do. Then, “feeling guilty and dirty for what she had done she concocted the rape story.” That much I can believe. She pleaded guilty to wasting police time, and was given 140 hours community service and ordered to pay £500 compensation.

[The above report was extracted from the Birmingham Evening Mail, January 21, 2000, page 4 accessed through NewsBank Newspapers - U.K. and Ireland].


April 1999: Former Mayor of Bracknell Alan Ward is accused of rape by his mistress Angela Perret-Green, apparently ON A WHIM. Although he was arrested, the case was dropped, possibly due to her having threatened another former lover with the same treatment.

[The above is based on a report from the News Of The World, July 18, 1999, page 28 - extracted from NewsUK].


April 1999: After breaking up with her somewhat older lover, teenager Kerry-Ann Emmett accuses him of rape. He is arrested, spends 17 hours in custody, and is bailed. The following month she claims he had threatened her with a knife, and he is arrested again. In June, she admits she invented both assaults but is unable to explain why. On November 2, 1999, she is given a 6 month sentence at Winchester Crown Court, and bursts into tears.


April 1999: Tua Letuga has a steamy relationship with her car mechanic. He is a married man, and she is alleged to have attempted to extort money from him by accusing him of rape, which is why she ends up in the High Court at Auckland in June 2000. Whatever the outcome of that case, the sex was consensual.


April 1999: FALSE ACCUSATIONS OF RAPE IN THE NEWS by Linda Piggott and Keith Soothill.

The above article by two academics is not as bad as most of the drivel spouted by feminist cretins. It includes cases listed in this database.


April 5, 1999: Dr Ashok Ramadugu is arrested at Elyria, Ohio on suspicion of the rape of a young multiple sclerosis patient in intensive care. He stands trial for assaults on her and another patient but is cleared when inter alia a bite mark is shown to have been made by a catheter. Best not to talk about the dream evidence. This report appeared in The Bryan Times, June 15, 2001, page 8. File under GENUINE MISTAKE.


May 1999: This is not a rape allegation but is included here because Francis Lawler accused three men of indecently assaulting her: one on one occasion and two on the other. Better still, all three were police officers - from two different forces in Scotland. She appeared in court 18 months later.


May 19, 1999: Andrea Dworkin is in a Paris hotel. Later she would claim she had been drugged and raped by two members of its staff. She didn’t report this rape to the police for a very obvious reason. Even feminist critics like Catherine Bennett have questioned this claim. This was not the first sexual assault Dworkin claimed to have suffered.

[For the avoidance of doubt, the Catherine Bennett alluded to above is not the false accuser listed below at August 26, 2011].


May 25, 1999: The Daily Telegraph reports on the trial of Matthew Hilliard at Nottingham Crown Court; the teenager is cleared of rape after the trial judge directs the jury to find him not guilty, a CCTV tape having come to light that exposes the lies of the non-victim.


May 26, 1999: A woman enters the United States from Germany; she is stopped at Washington-Dulles International Airport because of her suspicious passport, which turns out to be fake. Her name is given as Sandrine Jeanne Fokou/Jeane Sandrine Simo; she claims to be a political refugee from Cameroon, and would you believe she was raped by police officers in December 1998? Neither would I.


Between June 1, 1999 and June 2, 2001: The alleged victim was under 10 years old, and the alleged perpetrator was between 11 and 13. How likely is this? At the age of 26, Lee McGregor stood trial at Reading Crown Court, and fortunately common sense prevailed. He was found not guilty in July 2014.


June 10, 1999: Pablo McCabe and Nora Wall are convicted of HISTORICAL SEX OFFENCES including the rape of a then 10 year old girl in 1987 or 1988. At the time of this imaginary offence, Wall was a nun with the Sisters of Mercy. Known as Sister Dominic, she is said to be the first woman in the history of Eire to be convicted of rape, the first person to receive a life sentence for rape, and the only person in the history of the country to be convicted on the evidence of repressed memory - which does not exist. Her co-defendant was a homeless schizophrenic.

The two witnesses at the heart of this case were Regina Walsh and Patricia Phelan, both of them capricious liars. CAPRICIOUS and MALICIOUS. Phelan had made at least two false rape allegations prior to the trial of Wall and McCabe. The convictions of both Nora Wall and Pablo McCabe were soon quashed, although it was not until December 2005 (three years after McCabe’s death) that the final chapter was written. The full judgment can be found here.


June 17, 1999: An interview with Regina Walsh by the journalist Barry O’Keefe is published in which she claims to have been raped by a black man in London’s Leicester Square. (Strange how the dude is always black, but anyone who knew Leicester Square at that time will testify as to how unlikely this claim is). Wall was one of the complainants in the notorious Nora Wall case - see entry for June 10, 1999,(above).


June 18, 1999: Dallas County Jail inmate Patricia Thiemet claims to have been (gang) raped within its walls. She is taken to hospital, but no medical evidence is found. Detectives interview more than fifty inmates and staff, which results in a false report charge being added to the lady’s existing charges.


June 22, 1999: An ASYLUM SNEAKER from Ethiopia appears before a board at Ottawa. Click here for more.


July 1999: A Pittsburgh woman makes the first of two false rape allegations against different police officers. In September 1999, she makes the second after claiming to have been carjacked by three men who inter alia sexually assaulted her. This article from the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, September 28, 1999, page A13 reports her arrest. Rather than sending her to gaol, she is clearly a candidate for the RUBBER ROOM.


July 17, 1999: A 16 year old girl is not brutally raped at Pitsea after being attacked by 3 strangers. Police went the whole hog setting up road blocks, then she admitted she had lied. Bad girl!


July 31, 1999: Strippagram girl Deborah White is not raped by two men in a public house after performing her act. Two days and 329 (three-hundred and twenty-nine) man hours later, the truth comes out, yet even though she admits lying to the police, she pleads not guilty at Bristol Crown Court to attempting to pervert the course of justice. She is convicted on September 1, 2000.

Once again, CCTV comes to the rescue, and once again we hear it is not the false accuser’s fault. She was high on drugs at the time, and she made up this story when her husband questioned her about how she had spent the evening. So it was either his fault or the fault of the man who sold her the drugs, or perhaps the fault of the man who hired her. Any man’s fault, but not hers.

[The above information was extracted from the Western Daily Press, September 2, 2000, (page number not given)].


August 1999: Kirsty Lindsay is walking her dog when she stops and shares a drink with down and out Donald McPake. Later, she accuses him of raping her at knifepoint; he is arrested and grilled, but when confronted, she breaks down and admits she made it up. The two did not have sex. In May 2000, Lindsay is sentenced to 3 months at Airdrie Sheriff Court. Lindsay’s advocate said she was a lonely and sad woman with psychological difficulties. Her mother said the sentence was disgraceful. Seriously?

[The above was extracted from The Daily Mirror, May 25, 2000, page 27, accessed through NewsBank U.K. and Ireland].


August 4, 1999: Judge David Bryant calls for a register of false rape accusers. This followed the collapse of the trial of a man at Teesside Crown Court. He had been accused of the rape of a 16 year old girl whom it was revealed had made similar allegations against other people which had been dismissed after a lengthy police investigation - to quote the London Times Legal Correspondent, August 5, 1999. It will come as no surprise that wimmin’s groups thought this was a thoroughly bad idea.

They might, but I don’t!


August 12, 1999: This article from Cincinnati so dated reports the recantation of a 10 year old girl who had accused Donald Vulhop of multiple rapes. He had spent two months in gaol, the girl having accused him in January 1999.


August 13, 1999: At Mesa, Arizona, Kari Rae Bodenski tells police she was beaten and raped by a man at a local elementary school. On August 23, 1999, a report in the Kingman Daily Miner, page 3, says she made up the story to get the attention of her husband. File this one under ATTENTION SEEKER.


August 16, 1999: Talk about kicking a man when he is down. In the Philippines, corrupt police chief Francisco Ovilla is facing serious charges when teen tearaway May Gines accuses him of raping her at gunpoint on said date. She claims too that he had sexually assaulted her on July 3, 1999.

Although he was cleared, the false rape allegation was the least of his troubles; in March 2001, Ovilla was one of ten police officers sentenced to death for “qualified bribery”, a sentence that would be Draconian even in Saudi Arabia.

This article by Jerome Aning appeared in the Philippine Daily Inquirer, August 12, 2000, pages 18 and 17. Its title written thus is:

OVILLA RAPE CASE
‘She mocked our
judicial system’


August 24, 1999: Lois Morin fakes her kidnapping and rape by three masked men, apparently in a custody dispute. This report is from the Hartford Courant. She would eventually receive a non-custodial sentence and a massive cost order.


September 1999: Lynn (also spelt (Lyn) Wilson pleads guilty at Falkirk Sheriff Court to putting Mark MacDonald under false suspicion of rape. She had spent the night with him then cried rape the next day. Mr MacDonald worked at Cleo’s, a nightclub in Grangemouth. He was sacked over this. When she appeared in court later that month, Wilson was given 150 hours community service. Her advocate said she’d been suffering from depression due to the break up of her marriage. As she left court, she refused to apologise.

[The above was extracted inter alia from the London Daily Mail, September 24, 1999, page 39, accessed through UK Newsstand].


October 1, 1999: Factitious Disorders and Trauma-Related Diagnoses by Daniel Brown and Alan Scheflin.

The above article by two legal scholars contains inter alia a discussion of false rape claims and Satanic ritual abuse, anonymised as usual.


October 7, 1999-February 2000: Elizabeth Petersen of Taylorsville, Utah, claims to have been subjected to a campaign of victimisation (I hate that word stalking). The first incident is an alleged rape and wounding.

The above is based on this report from the Deseret News, May 18, 2000.


October 8, 1999: Aftab Ali, who appears to have been 19 years old at the time, has sex with a woman old enough to be his mother and then some. She accuses him of rape. Although at the High Court in Edinburgh he is only found not proven, the non-victim claimed she had been raped on four previous occasions. She had withdrawn the allegation on three occasions while on the fourth there had not been enough evidence to proceed.

Many people have been burgled or seriously assaulted on two or more occasions - including me - but is any woman this unlucky?


October 14, 1999: This article so dated appeared in the Evening Post (Bristol), page 5. It reports the acquittal of Stephen Wood who was accused of the attempted rape of an underage girl, with an alternative charge of indecent assault.

He was rightly acquitted; note the bizarre inspiration for this false allegation.


November 8, 1999: Soo Jin Kim arrives in Canada with her husband and child. In May 2004, the Korean nationals apply for refugee protection claiming she was raped in Argentina the year they left, a rape that was not reported to the police for the obvious reason. Read this judgment; women like this are pathetic, so is this one and her husband.


November 10, 1999: Rape statistics ‘ludicrous’ was published in the South Africa Times (UK), page 7.


November 23, 1999: DEDICATED FABRICATOR Alyson Cole is given a 4 month sentence by Leicester magistrates. There was little coverage of this story, but it did make page 3 of the London Times the following day. Cole is another of these madwomen for whom we’re supposed to feel sympathy. She pleaded guilty to 5 charges of wasting police time, seven hundred hours of it. She is said to have fooled so-called trained counsellors as well as detectives. Even then she claimed the first incident was genuine. Apparently it was all triggered by childhood memories (read: ultimately a man was responsible).


December 1999: This is another well-documented scandalous tale that requires no citation. Seventeen year old Ryan Glynn has sex with a fifteen year old girl in the grounds of Ross High School, Tranent, East Lothian. She accuses him of rape. CCTV evidence proves the girl is lying, yet the police withhold it for ten months. The footage - which was nearly deleted - is disclosed to the defence team the day before his trial is due to start - in February 2001.

A note here, in the US this would have been regarded as statutory rape because the girl was just below the age of consent. In the UK however, the authorities rightly take a pragmatic view when one party - usually the girl - is underage, and the other is still a teenager.


Christmas Day, 1999: Oregon woman Dianne Reed tells her boyfriend she was raped in the back of her car by a man on the freeway who, impersonating a police officer, had stopped her vehicle and threatened her with a knife. Her boyfriend calls the police while she goes to hospital. The police investigate thoroughly, but at the end of the day it is she who is charged.

This article was published in The Blade (Toledo, Ohio), January 5, 2000, page 15, and this is an excellent quote from it:

Police periodically dismiss rape cases after evidence proves the reporting person wasn’t raped, but they seldom file charges against the alleged victim.


December 31, 1999/January 1, 2000: This is the probable date. Tommy Moran is invited by a long time friend to a Millennium party at the latter’s Dunfermline home. He had known the complainant (the friend’s wife) for 25 years, although this was apparently the first time they’d had sex - while her husband was sleeping off the drink. Is this any way to treat a friend? Afterwards, the woman cries rape. Moran stands trial in September 2000, and is cleared by the jury in twenty minutes.

[The above was extracted from The Sun, September 29, 2000, page 15, accessed through NewsBank U.K. and Ireland].


2000: A teenage Jamie Leigh Jones makes her first false rape allegation, on the day the divorce of her parents is finalised. She tells her mother, who takes her to the hospital and also tells Jamie’s father, her husband. He doesn’t believe her. No criminal charges are filed. See also entry for July 28, 2007.


2000: This Canadian case was played out over seven years when finally the victim of the false allegation, former RCMP officer John Hudak, received an undisclosed but substantial sum in damages. False accuser Mildred Johnson was convicted of both perjury and fabricating evidence.


January 26, 2000: Emma Harrington tells Catford police she was sexually abused by her stepfather David Luxford eight to twelve years previously when she was between the ages of 13 and 16. He is convicted on specimen charges and sentenced to seven years. His first appeal results in a retrial, and the same verdict, but thanks to the persistence of his loyal wife, he is cleared. This is yet another example of a demented or simply capriciously malicious female taking away a man’s freedom and (in this case) nearly destroying him.


January 30, 2000: At Saratoga Springs, New York State, Joan Winslow makes a late night call to the police from a restaurant and tells them she has been raped. Shortly, she admits she lied telling them the man she accused had used her for sex then thrown her out of his motel room.

This article appeared in Schenectady newspaper The Daily Gazette, (FIRST EDITION), February 1, 2000, page B5.


February 2000: Another widely reported case, babysitter Wendy McClung is given a non-custodial sentence for making a false allegation against Stewart Nicoll. They had consensual sex, and she cried rape to avoid a row with her parents. Her nine months of probation is considerably less than he would have received had her deception not been unmasked.

The spelling of both this guy’s names varies, ie Stuart & Nicol.


February 2000: A teenager falsely accuses two men of raping her in a South London nightclub. However did this one get to court? She goes on to make another false rape allegation a few months later.


February 19, 2000: The Gazette, a Blackpool newspaper, publishes a short interview on its front page with local man Harry Turner. You may have to download and resize this press cutting, but the case dates back at least a year, and may have been historical in nature. He faced nine charges of indecent assault, but a jury at Preston Crown Court took only an hour to clear him.


February 27, 2000: A woman claims to have been abducted in Puxico, Missouri and raped in woodland. Asked to take a lie detector test (presumably a polygraph) she admits she made it up but gave or could give no reason for doing so. This report is from the Southern Missourian, March 8, 2000, page 6A


March 2000: Stacey Havemann of Rapid City is sentenced to a year in gaol. After spending 30 days behind bars for disorderly conduct, she accused a policed officer of rape. The allegation was investigated by outside agencies and deemed to be false, whereupon she recanted and pleaded guilty to false reporting.

[The information above is based on an article in The American News (Aberdeen, South Dakota), March 5, 2000, page 1B (accessed through NewsBank)].


March 2000: Yun Kyeong Sung Kwon is not raped in a Las Vegas hotel room by the husband of Céline Dion. The con woman and her husband are eventually arrested on extortion and other charges against René Angélil. In 2004 and 2005, the two crooks are convicted and sentenced in separate trials.


March 2000: Derrick Jenkins has sex with a teenager half his age in the bathroom of an apartment at Bristol, Connecticut. The case drags on for nearly a decade, but in February 2009, he is cleared by a jury.


March 17, 2000: At Fairbanks, Alaska, teenager Amanda Jennings is allegedly kidnapped by two white dudes with rape on their minds. This is only a false claim of attempted rape but it is included here because the young lady went the extra mile, ripping her clothes in the process. This report is from the regional press.


March 28, 2000: Joanna Bell is given a non-custodial sentence at Canterbury Crown Court. She’d had sex with three Kurdish men the same afternoon - it is not clear if this was one after another or a GANG BANG. She had been married only two weeks! Kent Police were said to have put 65 officers on the case, and no fewer than 13 men were arrested! This was in October 1999. (The information herein was extracted from the London Times, March 29, 2000, page 3).


March 31, 2000: This article so dated is from page 3A of the Rome News-Tribune - a Georgia newspaper. Prison inmate Kevin Wayne Edge claimed to have been sexually assaulted - presumably bummed off - by two other inmates. Thankfully, it never happened, as he soon admitted.


April 2000: The Truth Behind Legal Dominance Feminism’s “Two Percent False Rape Claim” Figure by Edward Greer.

The above from an American law journal is an excellent article that thoroughly debunks this ideological nonsense.


April & July 2000: In South Carolina, a woman tells the Charleston County Sheriff’s Office she was abducted at knifepoint by two men, taken to a warehouse, beaten, and raped. She does not report the alleged crimes at once, which could be (but isn’t) the reason there was no physical evidence. She identifies two men, who are charged, and apparently released on bond, because she goes on to accuse them of raping her in her own home in July 2000.

In February 2001, the charges against the men are dismissed. She goes on to make two further false rape allegations, the second against a police officer on August 3, 2008.


April 10, 2000: A woman claims to have been raped in Southend. In answer to an appeal, a man walks into a police station and is arrested. Two days after her report, the woman admits the rape never happened.


April 13, 2000: 18-stone woman gets life for killing partner was the headline in The Scotsman, April 13, 2000, page 10, (accessed through the UK Newsstand database via Croydon Libraries).

Adele Early is given a life sentence on her conviction for the murder of her lover David Riddler. She stabbed him to death in December 1999, then pulled down his trousers as part of an attempt to claim he had raped or tried to rape her. The fact that she struck him no fewer than 16 times tends to belie that claim. File under PRETEXT FOR MURDER.


May 2000: Single mother Amanda Colvin claims to have been raped late at night. Mubur Rahman is arrested less than an hour after Colvin told a passerby about the non-incident; he is detained for 17 hours. Three days later, Colvin admits she lied, although she still claims to have been attacked while waiting for a taxi! In January 2001, she is given a non-custodial sentence by Cheltenham Magistrates’ Court. (Reported by inter alia the Bristol Evening Post, January 19, 2001).


May 2000: A girl designated only as T.P. claims to have been molested (ie sexually). This claim is false. She goes on to accused her stepfather Genaro Luna of interfering with her between the ages of eight and fourteen. The first allegation concerned her mother’s then lover; T.P. was said to have been five years old at the time it didn’t happen.

Luna is charged with no fewer than eight offences, and is cleared on all counts. The prosecution appeals, and in August 2010, the Court of Appeals of Indiana upholds the jury’s verdict.


May 1, 2000: A South African woman in Dublin tells the police she had been raped by a man while a woman and a man looked on. In the street, apparently. Or apparently not, because a Garda spokesman said: “She made the whole thing up and we don’t know why, she seems to have some problems”.

[The above was extracted The Mirror, May 3, 2000, page 8, accessed through UK Newsstand].


May 8, 2000: Abdirashid Said has sex with a lesbian who then accuses him of rape. He is arrested the following day. A jury at Newcastle Crown Court takes a mere hour to clear him.


June 6, 2000: Sushil Gulati lodges a complaint against a police officer for allegedly molesting his wife. The man is suspended, but then with three others hatches a conspiracy to frame Gulati for rape. This tale of perfidy from India is one you couldn’t make up, indeed the judge said as much in March 2016 when the case was finally resolved.

Gulati died in 2014, but the Indian judicial system went out of its way to deliver justice for a dead man. And false rape aside, here is a quote you - and all who work in law enforcement - would do well to commit to memory:

When “protectors of rule of law become destructors, then court must respond with firm hands”.


June 9, 2000: Married teenager Gemma Collier claims to have been raped at knifepoint while out walking her dog. This evil little minx causes a massive investigation because police in the area had been looking into two genuine rapes at the time. She does not face prosecution after confessing, indeed she goes on to sell her story to a teenagers’ magazine called Sugar. At one point she boasted that her crying rape had led to a hundred men being questioned. After moving from Nuneaton to Rhyl she was back in the news in January 2001 when she fell from a first floor window, something that unsurprisingly resulted in serious injuries.


July 2000: Karen Kirshaw tells the police that after drinking in a public house at Houghton in the North East of England, she was waylaid in the small hours, dragged into a dark alleyway, and raped. She identifies her assailant as an ex-boyfriend. An intense investigation leads to a man who claims to have had sex with her that evening. As can be seen by this report - a simplified page from sunderlandecho dot com - when Kirshaw appears before Houghton magistrates in January 2001, she pleads guilty to wasting police time.

But, as ever - she is not to blame because in this case, she “had been involved in a violent relationship with her partner for about five years before they split up.” So a) the bastard deserved it, and b) it was her mother who initiated the investigation.


July 2000: In England, probably in the Greater London area, a teenage girl tells police she was kidnapped and raped. See entry for February 2000 and the double rape that never was.


July 12, 2000: A businessman from the South of England is cleared by the Family Court of sexually abusing his 17 year old autistic son. This may or may not have been a rape allegation, but it was the first such allegation in the UK resulting from facilitated communication. See the entry for Prisoners Of Silence for the background to this dangerous quackery. In this particular case, Elizabeth Butler-Sloss, the most senior family law judge in England, condemned FC as dangerous. An aside here, one wonders what goes on in the minds of the people who are ultimately responsible for these allegations.

[The above case was reported by Helen Rumbelow in the London Times, July 13, 2000, page 9].


July 12, 2000: The Free Lance-Star for this date reports on the case of Ayana Renee Carter who was recently indicted by a grand jury for filing three false rape reports in Stafford County. According to the police, she had accused men of rape or sexual assault no fewer than seven times in the past three years - including detectives in Stafford and Fredericksburg!


July 23, 2000: A woman leaves a nightclub in the seaside resort of Blackpool; she takes a taxi with a man, and claims later to have been gang-raped by five men in a hotel room. The police mount an extensive investigation, but three weeks or so later this is called off when the non-victim withdraws her complaint, the investigation having drawn a blank.

There is no mention of a rape kit, but it remains to be seen if she simply made it all up or was a prequel to Danmell Ndonye. This report was lifted from the website of This Is Lancashire Dot Co Dot UK.


August 25, 2000: Miss X issues a statement of claim against the actor Steven Berkoff. Details are vague but she is said to be an Asian actress who accused him of assault and rape, aggravated by racial abuse on September 4, 1994. I have seen a number of documents relating to this case that I will not publish here; suffice it to say that this woman does not appear to have been entirely rational. In August 2001, she issued a further claim for libel because Berkoff had denied her allegations. A decade and a half later, the false accusers of Bill Cosby resorted to the same shameful tactics. Berkoff defended the action successfully.


Summer 2000: If you have heard of the Hollie Greig campaign only from the alternative media, you have almost certainly been lied to. Hollie Greig is a Mongol and her mother is an imbecile. It started when Hollie told her mother Anne Greig that she had been sexually abused by father. At least, that was the story Anne told. To cut a long story short, her father was supposed to have shared or hired out his daughter to a paedophile ring. The police were called in to investigate, no credible evidence was found, and the circle of abusers widened until it included not only police officers but the high and mighty of the legal establishment in Scotland. Including people who didn’t exist!

An idiot named Robert Green entered the fray, and the fantasy was promoted by among others the mischief-maker Belinda McKenzie (who would later become involved with the Hampstead Satanic abuse hoax). Green sounds extremely plausible, but he never did any research at all - these people seldom do. The story has spread not only all over the UK but to the far corners of the Earth.

Hollie was not the only child who was allegedly raped by this mythical abuse network. The root cause of the problem appears to be Anne Greig who was clearly off her trolley. She was also just as clearly coaching her daughter.

Eventually the authorities decided to do something to stop the lies that were tainting the lives of so many innocent people - ordinary people as well as the grand conspirators themselves. When Robert Green overstepped the mark he found himself in court and then behind bars. Twice. The first time in 2012. To the true believers, this is proof positive of the power of the conspirators, and no amount of evidence will ever convince them otherwise.


September 6, 2000: Post-graduate student Nicholas Buoy is cleared at Cambridge Crown Court of raping a drunken woman at a party the previous September. It appears that both of them got drunk and then made out, or perhaps they didn’t, because he said he did not remember having sex with her.


September 8-15, 2000: This is one false allegation of rape plus two allegations of assault, but they are bundled together here because they appeared together in the Boston Herald of November 4, 2000, page 10. And because they are hilarious.

All the complaints relate to the Dartmouth campus of the University of Massachusetts. The first unidentified female claimed to have been raped on September 8, but then admitted to state troopers that the sex was consensual: she “concocted a story because she was afraid her parents would learn of her sexual activity”.

The second claimed to have been attacked on September 9, but fought off the fiend. On September 15 she was driving on campus when she thought she saw someone being attacked; she got out to investigate/help, and was grabbed from behind. The attacker had a knife, or would have, had he existed, but: “she made up the second attack because she felt her first report failed to generate enough attention.”

[The NewsBank version of the newspaper was consulted; the article is called Two admit campus attacks were fakes, and is credited to Ed Hayward].


September 13, 2000: This report from New Zealand so dated concerns a case with a long and sordid history. It is also a salutary lesson for men. Guys, give women like this a miss. If you wouldn’t take her home to meet mother, she isn’t worth the candle. By the same token, women should think twice and thrice before engaging in these kinds of practices.

In 1996, Jason Dale, his brother Paul and their friend Callum McLeod had a sordid sexual encounter with a woman at Palmerston. They ended up behind bars after she withdrew her consent retroactively. In February 1999, she recanted her allegations, and in May 1999 she recanted her recantation! At their trial, there was physical evidence consistent with her testimony, but if you’ve read this far you’ll realise that even physical evidence can be manufactured, or simply misleading. The same woman went on to accuse two other men of similar offences, in which her own husband partook.

Having said all that, Messrs Dale, Dale & McLeod might have been better advised to let sleeping dogs lie.


September 13, 2000: This report from the New Straits Times, page 18 speaks for itself. A claim that women were raped in a hostage situation in the Middle East is retracted.

This one can probably be filed under GENUINE MISTAKE.


September 26, 2000: Aged only 20 and already a mother of three, Natalie Knighting is given a six month sentence at Newcastle Crown Court for obtaining money by deception and wasting police time. When she was 16 she claimed she had been raped by a tramp. She was awarded £7,500 by the Criminal Injuries Compensation Board. A routine DNA test of a man arrested for a minor offence proved to be a match for this alleged rape. She had actually had consensual sex with a boyfriend.

She appears to have developed a taste for this sort of thing, as can be seen from this article. Changing her modus operandi doesn’t appear to have done her any good either.


October 27, 2000: Surrey Police confirm that no action will be taken against singer-songwriter Paul Weller who was accused recently by an anonymous woman of raping her in 1996.


October-November 2000: Stuart Harley stands trial at Edinburgh Sheriff Court for indecent assault. A former woodwork instructor at Donaldson’s College for the Deaf in Edinburgh, his accuser admits she had once falsely accused her own father of raping her. Thankfully, Harley was cleared of all charges. What a little monster.

[This case was reported by the Scottish press including The Daily Record and The Scotsman, November 7, 2000].


November 2000: John Hudson is convicted at Leeds Crown Court of the sexual violation of a girl between the ages of 3 and 12. He is given a 12 year sentence. His accuser is of course unidentified but her age gives some idea of their relationship.

He is cleared in 2005. See also the tragic case of Darryl Gee.


November 10, 2000: Inverness woman Tracie Coyle accuses her boyfriend of rape after he ends their relationship. There had been no rape and indeed no sex. The following April she was given 18 months probation.


November 21, 2000: The Refugee Review Tribunal of Australia gives an unnamed Egyptian woman the bum’s rush.

“The Tribunal asked the applicant why she didn’t report the rape to the police. The applicant claimed because it would be a shame, she would be ostracised and her family would kill her” but “The Tribunal had difficulty with various aspects of the applicant’s story.”

Here is the full judgment.


November 26, 2000: Singer-songwriter Mick Hucknall is arrested after being falsely accused of rape. The case is dropped almost immediately.


November 30, 2000: Having arrived in Vancouver three days earlier, a man from Pakistan and his wife claim asylum; they have a young daughter who was born in California in 1998, which begs the question why didn’t they stay there? - anchor baby and all that. This one is incredible. It remains to be seen when the wife first claimed to have been raped, but her husband is actually a convicted murderer. They had been refused asylum in Sweden. Regarding the wife’s rape claims, it is said “The claimant’s testimony on the number of times she was raped was variable, the number decreasing with each retelling. In the first version of her story, she could not specify whether she was raped three or four times”.


December 15, 2000: David Carrington-Jones is convicted of two counts of rape and two of indecent assault against KJ, and two counts of rape and two of indecent assault against LJ (her sister). The girls are his nieces, both are said to have moderate learning disabilities, and the allegations date to from around April 1995 to Christmas 1999. They are specimen charges. KJ was born in December 1983, and appears to have made her first allegation of sexual assault (apparently rape) against another man in or before January 1992.

All the above convictions are quashed in October 2007.


2001: This is a generic date, but the story played out over the next fifteen years is one that requires no citations. Jacqueline Ramohlola known as Mama Jackie was a saintly figure in South Africa, the Angel of Soweto, no less. Her scams included claiming her young charges had been rescued from the streets, and that some of them had been raped. She duped Oprah Winfrey, Hillary Clinton, Nelson Mandela and the United Nations.

In 2006, she was exposed as a fraud by a TV documentary, and in 2016 she was convicted of child trafficking for which she received a 12 year sentence - 5 of them suspended. During her trial, she claimed to have been raped herself when she was a child, but how much credibility does this claim have? The reader is invited to compare this evil woman with Somaly Mam.


2001: KJ claims her own brother had raped her from 1995 to 1999 (approximate dates). See entry for October 16, 2007 for the full background to this shameless, PATHOLOGICAL LIAR.


January 2001: Dearborn police chief Ron Deziel is accused of raping married beautician’s assistant Tammy Divetta. He resigns. This report of her recantation was published first in The Blade (Toledo, Ohio), March 18, 2001, Section B, Page 5.


January 3, 2001: Inquiry procedure defended by police

The above article was lifted from sunderlandecho dot com; it concerns the trawling operation known as Operation Rose. Few details are given here but the inquiry concerned 61 institutions and is said to have cost £5 million, and resulted in 6 convictions from 530 allegations. Most of these were of a non-sexual nature. A decade and more later after the Savile scandal, the usual suspects began whining about a cover up.

One of the few convictions to come out of the case, and one which appears to be sound, was that of Martin Hamill, who was charged with indecent assault and unlawful sexual intercourse with a 13 year old girl, but, and here is the punchline, although he was 38 when the allegation was made, he was a teenager himself at the time of the offence. On June 26, 2007, the Criminal Cases Review Commission referred his convictions back to the Court of Appeal, but on October 23, 2008, they were upheld.

Granted that no one should have sex with a 13 year old girl, including a 17 year old, but this sort of thing is a far cry from the organised paedophile rings the true believers would have us believe were running children’s homes at the time, and which some of them still believe are running the Government!


January 17, 2001: Like celebrities, powerful politicians are often the targets of false allegations, usually of financial corruption, but this story from the Philippines so dated sees Primo T. Murillo cleared of multiple rape allegations made the previous year, apparently from personal motives.


January 25, 2001: This story from the Philippine Daily Inquirer, March 15, 2001 is as bizarre as they come. A decade and more later, Salvador Pecson was still at work as a dentist. What happened to his anonymous false accuser is anybody’s guess.


January 25-6, 2001: Kenneth Samuels is convicted at Mold Crown Court of several offences of indecent assault and rape against one victim, his own daughter. On February 9, 2001 he is given a 10 year sentence; it beggars belief what he would have got in the United States.

There was, or appeared to be, medical evidence, but as by this time she was 16...Fortunately for him, she went on to make other allegations, dragging in her mother! In June 2007, Kenneth Samuels was cleared on appeal. You can read the full judgment here.


January 31, 2001: False alarm bells sounded by Donna Laframboise.

The original of the above article could not be archived and appears to have vanished. False allegations of child sexual abuse are rampant in Canadian courts, which is hardly surprising when one considers the way legal dominance feminism has driven a bus through the rule of law in that country.


January 31, 2001: Shannon Gresham tells University of Georgia Police she was raped in the morning. Detectives spend Wednesday evening talking to her, but there is no mention of a rape kit. Her attacker is said to be around six feet tall, two hundred pounds, and to have short, spiked blondish-brown hair. Two days later, it is reported that she has been arrested. Here is part of an article from the local press.

Note the comment at the bottom, a veteran rape investigator said he could not remember ever charging a woman with filing a false rape report, including the one mentioned in the above paragraph of a student who reported being abducted and raped several years ago. Here is the full report.


March 2001: A 16 year old girl who claimed to have been raped on her way home through Ipswich docks withdraws her complaint.


March 1, 2001: At Wolverhampton Crown Court, businessman Kultar Singh Dale is cleared when the prosecution offers no evidence. He had been accused of the February 2000 rape of a young woman with whom he had not had sex. She spent two nights at his home, then shortly after accused him of drugging her to facilitate the imaginary rape.

[The above is based on contemporaneous reports extracted from NewsBank Newspapers - U.K. and Ireland including the Birmingham Mail].


March 4, 2001: On the island of Bermuda, the 54 year old Amy Stovell claims to have been pulled off her bicycle and violated early morning. Less than two weeks later she withdraws the allegation although the police believe she may indeed have been assaulted. When she appears in court the following month, she is given a suspended sentence.

For a suggestion as to what really happened, check out the August 2, 1991 report from Davis, California.


March 17, 2001: Monique Mwembie arrives in the United States on a fake Belgian passport. At some point this ASYLUM SNEAKER from the Congo claims to have suffered multiple rapes, the usual sad story, and typically implausible.


April 2001: This is another example of a woman with a sick mind playing games, this time with the police. In December 2000, a teenage girl is savagely raped and left for dead in Peterborough. Over four days the following April, Samantha Gaches contacts the police telling them her friend Karen (who did not exist) had been attacked by the same man. She is said to have succeeded in wasting 1,800 hours of police time, during which they could have been hunting the real rapist. She was given a non-custodial sentence by Peterborough magistrates in February 2002. File this evil woman under HOAXER.


April 2001: Stacey Little tells her boyfriend she has been sexually assaulted (Canadian legal speak for raped) by three men after a night of drinking. A four day investigation leads to the arrest of one man, but after suspicion is cast on her story, she comes clean. She is given a sentence of 9 months in gaol and 2 years on probation for public mischief. When she comes before the Court of Appeal for British Columbia we hear the usual sob story and then some. The judges must have been in tears because here is what they said.


April 7, 2001: Police test may expose false rape claims by Sarah Hall.

The above is an interesting article which unsurprisingly provoked an unenthusiastic response from the sisterhood. Whatever the (dubious) merits of this test, real victims are easily recognised for the most part. They are the women with bruises and torn clothing, whatever their demeanour.


April 22, 2001: The following is based on an interview so dated in the Sunday Mirror with Carmen Whittaker, the live-in lover of Lee John Simpson, who had recently been cleared by the Court of Appeal. This is another case of ASKING FOR IT.

Simpson had a one-night stand, actually more of a one-hour stand, with a 21 year old who claimed at trial to have been a virgin. Give me a break. He was convicted and given a 5 year sentence, but in an extraordinary and honourable development, Counsel for the Prosecution expressed his dissatisfaction with the verdict, and it was quashed.


April 23, 2001: The trial of Jane Andrews opens at the Central Criminal Court. In September 2000, Andrews murdered her lover as he slept. Thomas Cressman was both battered with a cricket bat and stabbed. Andrews had previously been employed by the Duchess of York; stunningly attractive, she was also a HEAD CASE. At her trial she accused Cressman of raping her, a TYPICAL FEMININE LIE in such cases. The jury didn’t buy her sob story; Cressman had given her a home and been very good to her, but decided he didn’t want to marry her. Andrews was paroled in June 2015.

Andrews had the audacity to appeal her conviction, and was not short of supporters, the usual ragbag mob of wimmin who claimed in effect that her victim deserved it. By the time her appeal was heard, in September 2003, her allegations of sexual abuse had expanded to other men, including one of her own brothers.

The appeal judgment runs to 49 paragraphs, and makes interesting reading. It really is pathetic the way some people, including so-called mental health professionals, bend over backwards, forwards and sideways to portray women like Andrews as victims just because they are women and reasonably attractive.

Thankfully, Lord Justice Kennedy didn’t buy her sob story, and having appeared before the old goat myself, I can’t say I’m surprised.


May 2001: Annette Jenner claims to have been raped while being treated at Alexandra Hospital, Redditch. Rapes do happen in hospitals, but as this woman was a serving prisoner, it is difficult to credit a stranger was able to just walk up to her and sexually assault her without her screaming for a prison guard or a nurse.

Shortly, she was killed in what appears to have been a bizarre accident - falling from a toilet. (Bizarre but not unique; many years ago I spoke to a woman at the Public Record Office whose son was killed in similar circumstances - fell, hit his neck, and he was gone).

No charges were brought in connection with this phantom rape. According to the coroner, Annette Jenner had a history of making (false) allegations.


May 2001: John Tervet picks up an older woman (who is apparently not a prostitute) and has sex with her in his car. Shortly he is charged with attempted rape, the charge is increased to actual rape, and he stands trial at the High Court in Edinburgh in April 2002 when he is cleared, , although he paid a heavy price while his accuser remained anonymous.

This report is a simplified page from the website of The Scotsman, April 26, 2002.


May 14, 2001: Sara Ylen tells police in California she was the victim of an assault. Later she claims she was raped. James Grissom will eventually be convicted and given a heavy sentence for this false attack, but after Ylen gives an encore, claiming to have been raped in her own home by two men, his conviction is quashed. Incredibly, this was not even the first false rape allegation Ylen had made. In July 2015, her conviction was upheld on appeal. Part of her sentencing hearing can be found here from around two and a half minutes.


Circa May 23, 2001: A senior officer at Barlinnie Prison is suspended after allegations of multiple sex attacks on men, who like him are said to be homosexual. These phantom offences date from February 2000, and include rape.

This screengrab of a simplification of a page from The Free Library; the story is said to have first appeared in the Daily Record. On August 27, 2001, Iain Duff reported in the Glasgow Evening Times that Mr Pike had been cleared of these malicious allegations although he was not identified. He was though driven out of his home, and his sexual orientation appears to have come as a surprise to his family.

An aside here, this is another reason homosexuals and the military or military type organisations don’t mix. Although he was not alleged to have attacked anyone at work, malicious allegations of this nature are a certainty in this environment. Perhaps male homosexuals should work only in women’s prisons?


June 2001: This report is based entirely on the testimony of one man, Tucker Carlson, so caveat emptor. Having said that, as Paul Gambaccini has pointed out on more than one occasion, every celebrity has a stalker. There are a lot of crazy people out there, and if you appear on TV regularly, on the radio, or simply in print, one of these lunatics may stick her claws in you.


June 7, 2001: Mark Roberson Baker of Ames, Iowa, supplies drinks to a group of underage teenagers, and ends up being convicted of rape, alluded to here as third-degree sexual abuse - but rape by any other name, or even child rape. This case is a classic example of how a teenage lie (or boast) can take on a life of its own, by which time it is too late for the liar to retract.

The 13 year old concerned, known as Julia, tells her sister she’d had sex with Baker; the sister tells their mother, who of course informs law enforcement. On June 20, 2001, Baker is questioned by the police, and denies everything - including supplying the alcohol, which of course makes him look guilty. Then he flees the state, which makes him look even more guilty. At trial, Baker tries to introduce evidence that Julia had previously claimed to have had sex with a neighbour. This is refused, and he is sentenced to ten years.

In 2004 however, the Supreme Court of Iowa reverses his conviction. Later, it is reported that he has pleaded guilty to child endangerment, and will walk away time served.

If it isn’t clear from this, let me spell it out, teenagers will often lie to their friends and the world, boasting about all manner of things; often, girls as well as boys think it will impress their peers if they are perceived as sexually experienced. One wonders how many innocent young men were not as lucky as Mark Roberson Baker.


June 26, 2001: Kevin Ford has sex outdoors with a young woman - obviously a slut - who then accuses him of rape. He stands trial at Warwick Crown Court, and is cleared.

This was her second false rape allegation; her first was in January 1998.

[I am informed that the apparent typographical errors in the above linked article are due to problems with formatting].


June 26, 2001: This report from New Zealand so dated would be hilarious if the victim hadn’t spent five weeks behind bars for sexually violating an underage boy before the police realised the complainant was a 30 year old woman. All the charges against the man known here as the Meadowbank painter were dropped.


July 2001: A seventeen year old girl who claimed to have been raped after getting off a bus in Ipswich, withdraws her complaint.


July 16, 2001: At the High Court in Edinburgh, where six men are on trial for unspeakable crimes against the young - boys as well as girls - the star witness, an 11 year old, admits she had lied under oath. The offences alleged date from 1992 to 1998. The case collapsed on July 25, 2001.


July 24, 2001: An anonymised woman from Grenada claims asylum in Canada bringing her 6 year old son with her. She has a sorry tale of physical and sexual abuse, but like so many of these shameless liars she forgot what she had claimed previously: “The panel finds that the alleged rape did not occur as outlined, and has been added to the narrative to explain the 1997 departure to Canada and to strengthen the claim.”

Her bogus claim is rejected November 5, 2001.


August 1, 2001: Madness in Massachusetts! George McHugh is arrested after he is accused of abducting and raping Karen DeCosta. The two had been an item, McHugh siring a daughter with her before marrying another woman; DeCosta appears to have been unable to accept their relationship was over because McHugh took out a restraining order against her, and in July 2002 she found herself in court accused of violating it.

Sadly, things got worse, like mega. In 2005, she was back in court accused of attempting to kidnap their daughter, McHugh having been granted permanent custody of the girl on February 17, 2004 when Judge Stephen M. Limon ruled DeCosta to be an unfit parent. She was said to have previously attempted to hire a contract killer to murder McHugh. She was said also to have hired someone to plant illegal drugs in McHugh’s wife’s car. The reader might like to compare this with the case of Maria Marchese.


August 12, 2001: Valerie Walton contacts the police and tells them she was attacked in a back lane near her home in Hylton Road, Sunderland. Her ex-husband had forcibly removed her underwear and violated her. He is arrested and forensic searching/testing begins. Then she admits she made it all up. When she appears at Sunderland Magistrates’ Court in October 2001, her lawyer tells the bench her client was under the influence of alcohol at the time, but Kevin Walton had physically assaulted her on occasion before. So it’s his fault?


August 17, 2001: A fifty year old woman accuses Mike Tyson of raping her at Big Bear, California on July 16, 2001. As a (rightly) convicted rapist and a hothead, Tyson is an easy target for these kinds of allegations. In October 1991, a woman filed a paternity suit against him, but a blood test proved he was not the father.


August 20-September 7, 2001: Samuel McBrearty stands trial at the High Court in Glasgow, and is convicted on several charges. His appeal against conviction fails as detailed here.

The above is an HISTORICAL CASE; it is also incredible considering the admitted lies the alleged victim told. For example, she said on one day when she was raped by McBrearty she had previously been raped by a gardener whom she said had been given a two year sentence for the crime. He hadn’t, because he didn’t exist!

This case also fits into the PATHOLOGICAL LIAR category, and probably at least two others.


August 28, 2001: In Story County, Iowa, student Katie Robb claims to have been kidnapped by four black males and raped. On August 30, she admits she fabricated the allegation.

The bad news is that her university said it would charge Robb. The good news is that she achieved a degree of immortality when she became the subject of a lengthy and quite vacuous article in the Journal Of Black Studies in which she was revealed to be rather high up in a “gendered hierarchy, based on White patriarchal dominance” instead of the sort of woman any white man should avoid like the plague.


August 28, 2001: Horst Arnold is alleged to have raped Heidi Külzer. Click here for more.


August 29, 2001: This is the date of a Family Court of Australia judgment. The hearings date back to January 1999, and the lies of the rape of the mother by the father and the sexual abuse of his young son probably date from before that. What the judge thought of these claims can be inferred from the order:

“The child S., born ... August, 1992 is to live with the father, who shall have sole responsibility for the day to day care, welfare and development of the child...”

Some women are just vile. File this one under PARENTAL ALIENATION SYNDROME.


September 2001: False Allegations: The Role Of The Forensic Psychiatrist by Richard C.W. Hall and Ryan C.W. Hall is published in the Journal Of Psychiatric Practice.

The above is a very interesting article, even though it endorses the myth that most allegations of sexual abuse go unreported. It covers inter alia the Holly Ramona case and mothers coaching their offspring to falsely accuse their fathers (in divorce and custody cases).


September 3, 2001: A fourteen year old boy has sex with a slightly younger girl in his bedroom - not a good idea. She accuses him of rape. In September 2002, he stands trial at Leicester Crown Court, and is cleared by a jury in half an hour.

Compare the above with the September 12, 2002 case from Mold Crown Court. There must have been something in the air that year.


September 6, 2001: This one is as bizarre as they come. Jonathan Carbin is kidnapped by Daniel Shepherd, his wife Deana-Marie and Wesley Dolly where he is told he must confess to raping a young girl. He does so on video, there being the little inducement of a Samurai sword!

The victim is never charged with rape; in 2002, career criminal Shepherd is given a seven year sentence for this outrage, and is soon in even deeper trouble when he bungles an armed robbery.


September 24, 2001: This is a truly bizarre Australian case; Jennifer Witchard seduces her former lover Matt Wallace with the intention of crying rape as a pretext to having him murdered by her co-conspirators. Thankfully the plan fails, and she receives a 12 year sentence which is later increased to 15. This was her second false rape allegation.


December 10, 2001: Police officer Peter Solley is cleared at the Central Criminal Court of 9 counts of rape between February 1997 and August 2000 (according to one report). The non-victim claimed to have had a brief consensual relationship with him after he had raped her three times. (As any rape victim would). Interestingly, he denied having sexual relations with her at all until confronted with DNA evidence. If she hadn’t been so blatantly dishonest, the trial could have had a very different outcome.


December 11, 2001: Mary Galgoci attends Gnaden Huetten Memorial Hospital in Lehighton, Pennsylvania and claims to have been raped by a neighbour. He provides a blood sample for DNA testing, and is cleared, but Dirty Mary has semen from (at least) two other men on her clothes. In July 2003, she pleads guilty to misdemeanor charges.

[Like the April 7, 2003 false report of Christina Hawk, the above information was extracted from The Morning Call (Allentown, Pennsylvania), November 14, 2003, page B3, report by Bob Laylo, (accessed through NewsBank)].


December 22, 2001: A report that a teenage girl was gang-raped at a Guildford shopping centre turns out to be false according to this article from the London Times, December 24, 2001, page 5. File this one under GENUINE MISTAKE.


2002: A teenage Jamie Leigh Jones makes the second of her false rape allegations, claiming her then boyfriend raped her in her car, drove her to his home, and raped her again. Her father took her to a doctor, but no evidence of either rape or her claimed injuries was found. The phantom attack was not reported. See also entry for 2007.


January 14, 2002: A young woman is allegedly gang-raped in Coventry. Click here for more.


January 16, 2002: Three false rape allegations for the price of one in this report so dated from New Zealand by Sarah Prestwood.

At the start of the New Year, a teenager babysitting her two young brothers in a park at Porirua claimed to have been abducted, blindfolded and gang-raped.

The same week as this article, a woman appeared in Taurange District Court after making a false rape claim; she had claimed compensation after this imaginary rape.

Sometime in 2001, apparently early in the year, a stripper who claimed to have been sexually assaulted in Wellington was charged with false reporting.

The article reports too that “Under new law changes, people who claim to have been sexually abused can receive ACC payouts without having to complain to police”. The changes are said to come into effect on April Fool’s Day - clearly someone has a sense of humour!

And here is a real chestnut: “Defining a false complaint is a grey area. A woman can fabricate a story, or will frequently believe she really was raped, even when the facts prove otherwise. Alcohol can play a key role in distorting the truth.”


January 16, 2002: Another report from New Zealand, this time of a false rape allegation made PURELY FOR MONEY; teenage single mother Amanda Brennan of Tauranga is the bad girl who wasn’t drugged and raped the previous April. For more on financially motivated claims in New Zealand, see Unravelling secrets of sexual abuse, February 14, 2002 (below).


January 18, 2002: At Truro Crown Court, mother of two Julie Renouf is given a six month sentence for attempting to pervert the course of justice. Her lies led to a man being questioned by police for 15 hours and wasting nearly 2,000 hours of police time.


January 22, 2002: A 36 year old woman is not raped by two men in an Ipswich churchyard. On January 26, 2002, the local press reports: “Officers are now working with the appropriate organisations to see she receives ongoing support and care.”


January 23, 2002: At Terre Haute, Indiana, Takeisha Bean is given a lift home by a family member. Shortly, she tells a police officer he had returned and raped her. She is taken to hospital for an examination, but eventually admits she made it all up. On January 26, it is reported that she has been charged with filing a false report.


January 30, 2002: A student claims to have been raped late at night on campus at the University of Sioux Falls. On March 13, 2002, it is reported that she made the whole thing up. Note the use here of the word unfounded.


February 14, 2002: Unravelling secrets of sexual abuse by Simon Collins.

The above article from the New Zealand Herald contains some interesting information about false allegations of sexual abuse Down Under. It begins with the tale of a pseudonymous woman who claims to have been sexually abused by her grandfather between the ages of four and six, actually raped. Then she claims to have been sexually abused by two older boys next door, and on account of these horrendous experiences she became an alcoholic, a drug addict, and a mattress, though not necessarily in that order. The accepted narrative in such cases is that women (and men) who experience these issues in youth and later life do so because of the abuse they suffered when young. An alternative and far more plausible explanation is they reconstruct and at times invent childhood sexual abuse to rationalise their weakness and folly.

The story of Gordon Waugh is far more credible, but by far the most interesting part of this article is the link between allegations of sexual abuse and money. Surprised?


February 15, 2002: Highway Patrolman David Callaway is cleared of raping an 11 year old girl who at the time of his trial was 23 years old. She claimed he had attacked her at Stockton Lake, Missouri, but delayed reporting due to emotional distress. Even police officers are not safe from these pathetic women. This report is from the Southeast Missourian, February 26, 2002, page 5A.


February 16, 2002: A woman contacts the police and tells them (in good faith) her granddaughter has been raped by Hassan Kaabi. The alleged victim, Rebecca McGee, spins them a tall tale about being drugged and raped. She is medically examined, but this proves inconclusive. Kaabi is arrested, charged, and remanded in custody. On February 22, McGee contacts the police and tells them she made the whole thing up.

She appears at Newcastle Crown Court in May 2003 where she pleads guilty to perverting the course of justice. She is given a slap on the wrist.

Granted that devout Moslems like Kaabi says he is should not have sex with white sluts; granted too that she is clearly not too bright, and she did come clean when she realised the consequences of her actions, but listen to the rhetoric of her advocate: her client comes from a “very troubled background”; this court case has been “very upsetting for Rebecca”; she is “a very vulnerable and misunderstood person and is in no way scheming or malicious”.

Who was the victim here?


February 21, 2002: Georgina Fenton is given a slap on the wrist at Cupar Sheriff Court for making a false rape allegation against David Brunton. The sex was real, and so was her consent. Here is one woman’s view!


February 23, 2002: The following was extracted from the London Daily Mail on said date which was accessed through the UK Newsstand database via Croydon Libraries.

Mr Bond was accused of raping a woman in his apartment. By the time the police arrived, her make-up was running, her clothes were dishevelled, and her underwear had been ripped to shreds. She told them in a distressed voice she’d been raped. She’d met him a bar, gone back to his apartment, he emerged naked from the bathroom, dragged her into the bedroom, and raped her. That was half an hour after the assault, at a relative’s house. Looks bad, doesn’t it? But shortly before his trial was due to start, an eagle-eyed member of his legal team named Julie Wardil was viewing CCTV footage that showed the accuser leaving in the elevator; as she does so, she pulls her knickers out of her handbag, and begins tearing them with her hands. The case against Andrew Bond was dropped; his false accuser was not prosecuted, and remains anonymous.

[For the avoidance of doubt, the Andrew Bond alluded to above is not to be confused with a convicted paedophile named Andrew Bond].


February 26-July 11, 2002: The Home Affairs Committee hears evidence over nine days into the trawling of children’s homes for imaginary paedophile rings.

When the findings are published later in the year, the ambulance-chasing lawyers of the sexual grievance industry do not like it.


March 4, 2002: Debbie Cottrell is given a 6 month sentence at Winchester Crown Court after pleading guilty to attempting to pervert the course of justice by falsely claiming she had been raped. Interestingly, the Southern Daily Echo reports: “She pleaded guilty to the charge and asked for four other similar offences involving false allegations of rape, attempted rape, indecent assault and attempted robbery to be taken into consideration”.

She had named two men. There followed the usual apologetics by her advocate.


March 16, 2002: In Montana, Cody Marble is arrested four days after being released from a juvenile detention center. He is charged with the homosexual rape of another inmate, a 13 year old boy. His trial opens November 20, and results in his conviction on November 22. This is not a he said/he said case, but it is a complex one; Marble has serious problems with illegal drugs.

In July 2010, his accuser recants, but there were serious reservations before that. He is exonerated only in January 2017. This is a simplified page from Missoulian Dot Com.


April 2002: An investigation is opened into an allegation of rape against French rock star Johnny Hallyday. A woman known as Marie-Christian V claims he raped her on his yacht. Hallyday said others were aboard the boat at the time. In January 2006, the case against him is dropped.

This was not the first time Hallyday was falsely accused of sexual assault. If you’ve read this far you’ll realise that for male celebrities this comes with the territory.


April 9, 2002: A report so dated from the Maltese press of what might be termed an HISTORICAL CASE, one dating to 1997. A magistrate clears a restaurant owner who had been accused of raping a 13 year old English girl; Abigail Lofaro rules the rape allegation was probably the invention of the girl’s mother.


April 9, 2002: A 16 year old child - alluded to here as a woman is allegedly gang-raped in the small hours at Wellington, New Zealand. Later in the week the police reveal that the men who attacked her did not exist.


May-October 2002: Leon Forde is alleged to have raped a 13 year old girl between these dates and committed other offences against her. In November 2004, he is convicted at Lincoln Crown Court and sentenced to seven years. He was said to have been acting out some kind of vampire fantasy. Clearly somebody was, because 18 months later he was cleared on appeal after evidence came to light that the victim had made it all up!


May 4, 2002: A young woman is not raped in the small hours in an alley at Darlington. Police set up an incident room, produce an e-fit, distribute hundreds of leaflets, then on May 23, 2002, she admits the attack by two men never happened. Later, she was told she would not face prosecution.


May 15-July 31, 2002: In the Irish Republic, a woman accuses her own father of raping her. Details are scarce and her name is not released, but as can be seen from this report, she made a number of allegations of HISTORICAL SEXUAL ABUSE, all of them doubtless false. She had accused him of not only impregnating her but of siring a child by her. This claim was refused by medical evidence. When she was brought to book in December 2007, she was given a relatively heavy sentence. This woman is obviously either seriously disturbed or evil, most likely both.


May 24, 2002: A young woman claims to have been attacked and raped by a masked stranger in her Ipswich home. The local press offers a reward of £1,000, and 200 people are questioned. Two months later, the woman admits she lied.


June 2002: A woman tells police at Florence, South Carolina she has been assaulted, falsely imprisoned overnight and raped repeatedly by a neighbour. The man admits to the sex, which he says was consensual. The case is closed due to her lack of co-operation, and in August 2008, she makes another false rape allegation, this time against a police officer.


June 20, 2002: At the High Court, Mr Justice Eady gives judgment for the plaintiffs in the notorious case of Lillie and Reed; if that is too long for you to read in one sitting, check out this article by Richard Webster and Bob Woffinden.

The Shieldfield nursery case actually dates back to April 1993; the two people at the centre of it - Christopher Lillie and Dawn Reed - were put through Hell. After being accused, charged, remanded in custody and cleared of unspeakable crimes against the young, elements of the press pursued a hate campaign against them. It is clear from this case that the authorities have learned precisely nothing from earlier child sexual abuse witch-hunts.


June 24, 2002: Teenager Brandy Higley of Fredericksburg is not dragged into an alley, held down by two men, and raped by a third, but that is not what she told her boyfriend, who did what any boyfriend worthy of the name would do, and called the police. A medical examination finds no evidence of sexual assault, and in August 2002, she admits she made it all up. This article is from The Free Lance-Star (Fredericksburg, Virginia), August 27, 2002, pages 1 & A10.


June 26, 2002: This one is both a false rape allegation and black propaganda. This may not be the very first appearance of this canard in cyberspace or elsewhere. It has of course been interpreted as anti-Semitic as well as anti-Zionist; the Israelis have committed many unforgivable atrocities against the Palestinians before and since, but it is doubtful if IDF soldiers have ever gang-raped Arab women. On June 28, 2002, Harold Evans explained the origin of the claim in a London Times article. When he asked for the source, he was referred to the Labour MP Lynne Jones; she told him he had received an e-mail from Anthony Razook in Nablus, although she qualified it with the statement that it had not been authenticated.


July 2002: A bloke known only as Herbert K is accused of raping his 10 year old niece, something she claimed happened on two occasions in May 2002. This case resulted in conviction, so I am loathe to include it here, but it just seems so wrong. Although Herbert K was convicted only of indecent assault, he had been accused initially of rape, and was acquitted of attempted rape. Would a 10 year old girl have fully understood what rape meant? I think so, in Twenty-First Century England. In April 2005, the Court of Appeal upheld his two convictions of indecent assault. Read this short judgment and tell me you don’t feel the same way, namely that this is not yet another case of an innocent man having his life trashed on the whim of a child.


Circa July 3, 2002: Soldier Darren Wells is cleared of rape. There is a slightly unusual twist to this tale, apart from his mother playing detective. He was walking the non-victim home in Northwich, Cheshire, when she came on to him. He turned her down, apparently due to an injury, and the next morning he was arrested for rape. The false allegation dates to October 1998.

[The above information was extracted from UK Newsstand where it is credited to the Sun, July 4, 2002, page 31].


July 7, 2002: Leslie Warren has sex with the toxic Miss N, three times by his reckoning, and she accuses him of rape. On November 30, 2003, he is convicted at Bristol Crown Court by a majority verdict, and given a 4 year sentence. On March 1, 2005, after a reference by the Criminal Cases Review Commission, the Court of Appeal quashes his conviction. Although not a serial false rape accuser, this woman had made false allegations against (at least) three other men: one of a common or garden assault; the other two of a sexual nature. Once again we see a man’s life destroyed on nothing more than the word of a woman.


July 8, 2002: Brian Banks is accused by Wanetta Gibson of raping her at their school in Long Beach, California. Click here for more.


July 12, 2002: Korean student Jong-Ok Shin is murdered in Bournemouth. This one is as bad as it gets because false rape accuser Beverley Brown was primarily responsible for framing Omar Benguit for a crime that was almost certainly committed by Danilo Restivo. You can read a bit about this disgraceful case here.


July 20 & 24, 2002: An unidentified woman tells the Rathmines Women’s Refuge she was raped by her own father. She appears to have made such allegations before, from at least 2001. Her claims included that he had sexually abused her since the age of six, and that he had sired one of her offspring. A DNA test had refuted that claim. When she appeared at Dublin Crown Court in December 2007, she was given the unusually heavy sentence of four years. As the reader might suspect from this, she was not a victim of false memories, rather she was “bad from the day she was born”.


August 2002: Two teenage girls claim to have been gang-raped in a Croydon car park. A teenage boy and 3 men are arrested. The truth comes out in November the same year. When they appear at Croydon Crown Court on September 12, 2003, Lauren Moran and Zara Harris are sentenced to 10 months and 8 months respectively. CALL IT CONSPIRACY!


August 2, 2002: In Washington State, Maxina Rabang claims to have been kidnapped and raped; the following week she admits she made it up. This report is from The Spokesman-Review, November 9, 2002, page B3.


August 14, 2002: A girl tells police at Columbia, Maryland, she was raped at a mall that night. Two men are arrested and charged very promptly, but the next night the truth comes out. On August 16, it is reported that one of her victims has already been released; the other is still being held for an unrelated matter.


August 15, 2002: Sonny Wilson is found dead at his Coventry home. This sad case received little publicity. An allegation of rape had been made against him by a teenager earlier in the year. Although it was dismissed, depression got the better of him, and he hanged himself.

The above Albert (Sonny) Wilson is not to be confused with the other falsely accused Albert Wilson (see entry for September 16, 1996).


Circa August 24, 2002: After BP has sex with GB, she becomes pregnant, and in May 2003, gives birth to twins. BP and GB had married on April 11, 2000, but this marriage was removed from the register as fraudulent, apparently sometime in or soon after 2002. At her request. Not unreasonably, GB sought contact with (not custody of) the twins. What happens next shows the depths to which some women will sink in custody and related disputes.

First she claimed he could not be the father because she had never had sex with him, then when a DNA test proved otherwise, she accused him of rape! She claimed the foul deed was done on or about August 24, 2002, (ie around 9 months prior to the birth of the twins). She does not appear to have reported this phantom rape to the police, for the obvious reason.

Naturally, judges have little sympathy with this kind of nonsense, although in a carefully reasoned decision dated January 8, 2008, Judge Morgan of the High Court - Northern Ireland, Family Division ruled that on the balance of probabilities, no rape occurred. The full judgment can be found here.


August 31, 2002: Alison Welfare is found in the restroom of a South London fast food restaurant in a distressed state. Click here for more.


September 6, 2002: Ethiopian ASYLUM SNEAKER Zewde Beyene claims refugee status in Ottawa after arriving in Canada two weeks earlier on August 25. “I was waped”, she says. This judgment spells out why you shouldn’t believe her either.


September 12, 2002: A 15 year old boy from Bangor is cleared at Mold Crown Court of the rape and indecent assault of a 12 year old girl, apparently during a sleepover. As might be surmised, there was no medical evidence; the girl had told two school nurses another boy had been responsible, and two other girls had been asleep not only in the same room but in the same bed. Believe the children, but which ones?

[The above information was extracted from UK Newsstand where it is credited to the Liverpool Daily Post, September 12, 2002, page 16].


September 13, 2002: Psychiatrist vows to stay on Catholic review board despite criticism by Brian White.

The above article was lifted from the website of the Peninsula Clarion; I have made one tiny correction - the second reference to statute of limitations read originally statue.

To find out more about SNAP, check out this page which includes a clip of David Clohessy telling a TV studio audience how he remembered being sexually abused by a Catholic priest having repressed the memory of this years’ long abuse until it was unrepressed by “a movie”. Nutter.


October 2002: Jonathan Hagan pulls a fellow student at a party, takes her to bed in her room, and ends up being accused of rape. He stands trial at Nottingham Crown Court in November 2006. Although he is found not guilty, he is rebuked by the judge.

The non-victim claims he has ruined her life. No dear, you nearly ruined his. File this stupid girl under REGRET SEX.


October 2002: In Siem Reap, Cambodia, Swiss national Rudolf Knuchel is cleared of serious charges including raping two boys. The allegations dated to 2000.

This may be a case of FALSE AND TRUE, in particular a guilty man may have been framed because Knuchel was arrested again on similar charges in 2009. This article is primarily about New Zealand national Graham Cleghorn who was also convicted of serious sex offences in Cambodia. He was given a twenty year sentence, reduced on appeal, and deported. He died in October 2016 still protesting his innocence.

Whatever the truth about these two men, there have been definite miscarriages of justice resulting from false cases against Westerners in Cambodia. The articles Phnom Penh Perspective: Child Abuse by Bronwyn Sloan and Girls take back rape allegations by Matthew Torbit at this link (scroll down) give an insight into how and why such cases are brought. The second article was apparently first published on a New Zealand news site, but the original is no longer there.

The cases against Bart Lauwaert and Clint Betteridge were extremely dubious and definitely included false testimony.


October 16, 2002: This is a long story. According to the Amazon website, Ulrika Jonnson published her inappropriately titled autobiography Honest on this date. In this book she reports that she had been raped by an unnamed individual some fifteen years earlier. The name John Leslie was then blurted out by Matthew Wright on live television. This led to a nightmare roller coaster ride for Leslie, one that instead of up and down went down, down, down. A flood of allegations was made against him by women; he was arrested twice and charged with indecently assaulting a woman, and in 2008 was accused of another rape, in the 1990s. Finally, all charges against him were dropped, but this sort of mud always sticks.


October 19/20, 2002: Professional dancer Michael Flatley has a one-night stand with Tyna Marie Robertson in Las Vegas. On March 4, 2003, she sues him. This is a truly bizarre case. It drags on, and Flatley is finally vindicated on July 27, 2006 by the Supreme Court of California.

In December 2008, Robinson is warned she faces civil contempt charges if she does not cooperate with lawyers who are seeking documentation of her assets.


Fall 2002: A report filed from Farmington. Student Nicole Armitage claims to have been raped in a parking lot. After recanting, she was ordered to page $1,000 in restitution.


November 6, 2002: I offer this civil judgment so dated from Ontario without comment, save that the allegations of the plaintiff, a deranged Rastafarian named Charles Diggs, prove that whatever women can do, men can do better, not that in this case that is anything to be proud of. The false allegations date to December 1998.


November 14, 2002: The following information was extracted from the UK Newsstand database (accessed through Croydon Libraries); it is credited to the Guardian.

In the midst of an unrelated scandal, there is some comment on a former valet to Prince Charles. George Smith claimed to have been raped by a close aide to the Prince in 1989. The police confirmed he had previously claimed to have been raped in May 1999 (by two men) and in October 1999 (again by two men). Both these rapes were alleged to have happened at Hanworth, Middlesex, and both were deemed false.


November 16, 2002: A teenager claims to have been raped during the Middle Tennessee State University homecoming game. Shortly, it is reported by a local newspaper that the rape never happened, and that the non-victim is facing criminal charges.


November 20, 2002: After her asylum request is refused earlier in the month, a Roma woman alluded to only as ZL is said to have told her solicitor she had been raped by a police officer in the Czech Republic. It remains to be seen if this invention was her idea or if the lawyer or some other person suggested she make such a claim. Whatever, the Court of Appeal was not impressed. The full judgment can be found here.


December 2002: KJ accuses a man of raping her. They’d had consensual sex. See entry for October 16, 2007 for the full background to this shameless, COMPULSIVE LIAR.


December 5, 2002: Ashley Lawrence gives an exclusive interview to the local press. Before we go any further, it must be stressed this is not the same Ashley Lawrence who a decade later was convicted of an unspeakable crime against a very elderly woman.

This Mr Lawrence had sex with a woman in a churchyard - something that brings back fond memories for me! The girl was willing at the time, but claimed later that she screamed. Nobody heard her. Mr Lawrence spent a week on remand, and eventually the case was dropped with little or no fanfare. He told the journalist: “The papers don’t even have to report that the case has been dropped against me, so everyone still thinks I am a rapist”. Welcome to rape culture, dude.

His anonymous accuser said she left a Chippenham public house around midnight on September 13, 2002. She appears to have been drunk. Elsewhere it was reported that he said they knew each other, she denied this, but kept changing her story. Although she was clearly not telling the truth, this case shows yet again how dangerous it is in the current climate for any man to have sex with a woman who has consumed any quantity of alcohol because he will be held responsible for his actions even if he is blind drunk while she will not. Having said that, this bloke should have at least had the decency to walk her home.


December 7, 2002: This is another example of teenage boys being only too willing to have sex with teenage girls without thinking things through, and with the teenage girl herein being willing to act like a slut then regretting it soon afterwards. Five teens - four guys and a girl - attend a party at the home of Adrian Missbrenner who has sex with her, as do Burim Bezeri and Christopher Robbins; Sonny Smith videos them. The jurors view the video, and conclude the girl did consent.

When he addressed the jury, Missbrenner’s attorney put it in a nutshell: “If you say he’s not guilty, that doesn’t mean you approve of what happened.” Robbins is acquitted; Missbrenner and Bezeri are cleared of rape but convicted on minor charges; Smith is convicted of producing child pornography! In August 2007, Missbrenner’s wealthy parents settle a civil case with his accuser, paying her a six figure sum. This one can be filed under several categories but ASKING FOR IT is the most obvious.


December 28, 2002: In Scotland, a woman makes a false allegation of rape which she acknowledges to police on February 10, 2003. She tells one officer: “I’m really sorry, Derek, but we all took drugs that night and although I thought that it happened I realised that it didn’t and because they lied about being on drugs and made up their statements thinking they would be helping me I panicked about saying so.”

Years later, she accuses another man of raping her, this time in her own home. On March 9, 2012, Muhammad Abbas is convicted at the High Court in Edinburgh, albeit by a majority verdict. It remains to be seen if the jury got it right, but the appeal court seemed to think so.


December 31, 2002: Mother of four Nicola Collict has it off with Mr X. Then, realising she has been missing all night, she invents a ludicrous story about being kidnapped, raped and dumped at Doncaster Racecourse. Her mobile phone told a different story.

When she appeared at a lower court in Doncaster she was given a fourteen day sentence. Normally I wouldn’t take issue with this, but according to one report she was 8 months pregnant at the time; as nobody was arrested, it would have been more sensible to either suspend or perhaps defer sentencing for six months.


2003: Jason Gabbana is accused of raping an underage girl in Sefton Park, Liverpool. He is convicted and given a five year sentence. On January 12, 2006, his conviction is quashed when it is revealed his accuser had made a false allegation of sexual impropriety against someone else. This had not been disclosed to the defence at his trial. He left court wearing a Michael Jackson mask!


January 1, 2003: Dave Howie has sex with a (now former) female friend on a popular day for false rape allegations. It takes the police three weeks for Lancashire Police to clear him, thanks to electronic evidence. Apparently, no action is taken against his false accuser.


January 13, 2003: This is an incredible story. After leaving a man’s house on said date, two 15 year old girls set about framing him for aggravated rape. When they appear before magistrates at Chippenham on January 28, 2003, they plead guilty to perverting the course of justice.

This is a simplified version of the original webpage from the Swindon Advertiser, January 31, 2003.

In a report from the same newspaper dated February 21, 2003, the non-victim still insisted she had been raped. They escaped with a non-custodial sentence and a costs order apiece. File under both WHAT’S THE MATTER WITH KIDS TODAY? and NONE DARE CALL IT CONSPIRACY.


January 14, 2003: Thai media reports that a woman named Pakaporn Santhalunai had lodged an allegation of rape against former government official Sombat Uthaisang. The dastardly deed was said to have been carried out on November 21, 2002. Wimmin’s groups were said to have praised her for going public, but they weren’t quite so vocal twelve years later when after protracted legal proceedings she was finally given a three year sentence by the Supreme Court of Thailand for making a false allegation.


January 16, 2003: Amber Mundy claims to have been the victim of a serious sexual assault at Oneida, New York State. Her assailant is said to have used a stick, ie rape by instrumentation. The mentally challenged Dan Lackey is arrested, and in May 2004, he receives an eight year sentence.

Three months after his conviction, Mundy makes a similar allegation and is convicted of false reporting - see below. In July 2007, Lackey is finally exonerated.


January 29, 2003: An anonymous American Air Force cadet reports a rape; she had sex with the officer concerned - Lieutenant Ronen Segal - on August 25, 2002, but didn’t withdraw her consent until after her grades slipped. This report appeared in the Lodi News-Sentinel, August 8, 2003, page 16. Although Segal was cleared, this girl is pathetic; the careers, indeed the lives of young men are being trashed on rubbish like this. She flunks her exams and blames this on an imaginary rape. This is the mantra of so many self-styled sexual abuse survivors, they blame any and every future failing in their miserable lives on one incident, even in many cases an entirely imaginary one.


January 30, 2003: This report so dated is a simplified page from the website of The Yorkshire Post. A woman who was caught having consensual sex by a CCTV camera at The Earth Centre in Doncaster made a false rape allegation to prevent herself (and the man with whom she was having sex) from being named.

A similar but far more outrageous case happened in 2015 when city solicitor Graeme Stening and an unnamed female QC were arrested for outraging public decency. After accepting a police caution and realising the effect it would have on her position, this woman claimed she had been too drunk to consent, although happily she didn’t accuse Stening of rape.


February 2003: When police are called to her home, Heather Bremner claims to have been raped the previous November. This was the first of her false rape allegations. See entry for January 25, 2010.


February 3, 2003: New Jersey detective Michael Reedy informs Monsignor William McCarthy he has been accused of sexually assaulting two underage girls. In 1980. This is not a rape allegation but is included here because it was one of many made against priests at the time, not all of them unfounded. McCarthy was asked - asked? - to take a polygraph, and afterwards was told he had failed, a typical police lie.

McCarthy was accused by two women, in what was a bizarre case of malice. It was a good five years before he was cleared. Ask yourself how anyone can defend himself against these kind of absurd allegations.


February 3, 2003: Father of five and former Olympic boxing competitor Tone Fiso is arrested after being accused of repeatedly raping and sodomising a female relative since she was a child. He is denied bail, but in April 2003 it is reported he has been cleared of all charges and walks from New Zealand’s Porirua District Court a free man. Four years earlier, when she was just fourteen years old, this HEAD CASE had falsely accused someone else of sexually abusing her.


February 5, 2003: Michelle Romano is not raped in her car, but she could hardly tell Trooper Robert Beckey that she had traded sex for crack cocaine, could she now? This report is from the Beaver County Times, February 12, 2003, page A9. Beaver appears to be very popular in this part of Pennsylvania.


February 16, 2003: A Malaysian girl is not kidnapped, raped and held for 30 hours while visiting family in Coventry. According to Detective Chief Inspector John White: “in recent months an alarming number of rape claims had turned out to be false.”


February 19, 2003: A student from Indiana State University tells Terre Haute police she was kidnapped late on the night of February 17, held prisoner, and forced to give and receive oral sex from another woman. If this sounds like some sort of porno-fantasy, that’s because it was. On February 26, 2003 it is reported that she had recanted a portion of her statement - read she lied about the whole thing.

She is said to have refused a rape examination, a classic HOAX INDICATOR.


March 2003: After a birthday party, Ben Guerin has sex with another teenager, Jemma Taggart - at her instigation. She accuses him of rape. On April 27, 2006, she pleads guilty at Croydon Crown Court to perverting the course of justice.


March 2, 2003: At Dunedin, New Zealand, a teenager claims to have been dragged from a party and gang-raped. 300+ police man hours and $21,000 of public money later, this is the result.


Early March 2003: This article was first published in the London Times, August 1, 2003, so I presume the year is correct. The names have been changed, so caveat emptor.

If you read the second article, the one by the forensic psychologist, take it with a grain of salt, or better still a boulder. Although this woman doesn’t appear to be a feminist, she is talking rubbish. If you’ve read this far you’ll have realised there are many more types of false accuser than she claims. While some women are ATTENTION SEEKERS, the idea that some false accusers point the finger at the innocent because they are terrified of naming the guilty has no basis in fact. Airhead Dr Kim McGregor says the same thing - see entry for December 28, 2008.

Paul Gambaccini was a lot closer to the truth when he said tonight there will be maybe three hundred girls going to sleep dreaming about Harry Styles. Thirty years from now, two or three of those dreams may have morphed into something more sinister.

What he was talking about was confabulation. What she was talking about was the usual feminist “women can do no evil” flim-flam.


March 23, 2003: Private Jessica Lynch is captured in Iraq. This is a story that needs no documenting. Some time after her rescue, it was reported that she had been raped. This claim did not emanate from Lynch herself - she says she has no memory of it (because it didn’t happen). She is a very personable woman, and should not be blamed for the way she was used. This short video does not address the false rape claims, but does destroy most of the other myths about her that were sedulously created by both the American military and the mass media.


March 24, 2003: This nearly 13 minute video relates to a false allegation brought by sisters Fawn and Terese in Ottawa who claim they were drugged and raped by two men. It speaks for itself, but a few points.

It is notable that more and more often the police are putting female officers in charge of rape investigations. As long as they are not rad-fems (and clearly these here are not), that is a good thing. Nobody understands the murky thoughts of a woman like another woman. We are not told here why the investigating officer was so confident these two were not telling the whole truth, but I would suggest she had considerable evidence from multiple parties, perhaps even photographic/video evidence. As has been documented thoroughly elsewhere, the drugging and raping of women is extremely rare. As far as any drug is used it is usually self-administered alcohol.

The so-called experts alluded to herein are no such thing; Elizabeth Sheehy is a feminist academic whose vacuous book Defending Battered Women On Trial has been shredded by a number of critics including the anti-feminist vlogger Diana Davison.

Polygraphs are junk science, whatever this particular police officer says or thinks about them.

Jessica Carfagnini is a lesbian as well as a feminist.

The commentary by Jane Doe is a wilfully deceptive juxtaposition, and just because she didn’t lie doesn’t mean other women don’t.

We hear the usual statistical garbage. Again, nobody knows how many sexual assaults - rape and otherwise - are not reported.


April 2003: Police investigate a rape allegation at Dartford. The following month they conclude the “victim” was lying.


April 2003: The Conduct of Investigations into Past Cases of Abuse in Children’s Homes is published.

The above is the official response to the Home Affairs Committee hearings of 2002. To put it mildly, it is hostile.


April 1, 2003: Myths, relationships and coincidences: The new problems of sexual history by Mike Redmayne.

The above is an interesting article by a male academic who is clearly not a feminist; it takes a hard look at a difficult subject: the relevance of sexual history in rape trials. Although viewed primarily from a UK perspective, the author covers other jurisdictions. His conclusion is “The law governing sexual history evidence is in a mess”.

However, one of his sources... “Kelly refers to research suggesting that false accusations are invariably accusations of assaults by unidentified strangers” - seriously, dude?


April 7, 2003: Teenager Christina Hawk tells police at Lehighton, Pennsylvania she was drinking, blacked out, and woke up next to a man whom she believed had sex with her without her consent. The name of the victim is withheld when she appears in court the following November. She tells Judge Richard W. Webb she made up the story because she was afraid of her father’s reaction, which begs the question, what did he say when he found out she was two months pregnant? Apparently not a lot, because he attended court with her.

[The above information was extracted from The Morning Call (Allentown, Pennsylvania), November 14, 2003, page B3, report by Bob Laylo, (accessed through NewsBank)].


April 7, 2003: Although she is not named in this report, the woman who cried rape around 8.15pm in Wonford Park, Exeter was Karen Donald. She was said to have sparked a massive search for a man with half blond dreadlocks and a Jack Russell-type dog. When she appeared at Exeter Crown Court in September 2003, she pleaded guilty to attempting to pervert the course of justice.


April 26, 2003: Teenager Kirstey (or Kirsty) Moir is not attacked in a Teesside park. She claimed to have been raped in the small hours, in reality she met her victim in a bar, had sex with him in the park, spent the night with him, then told her parents she’d been raped. James Alleyne was arrested; it was only three months later, after 800 hours of police time and £100,000 of public money had been wasted that Moir came clean. On December 16, 2003, she pleaded guilty to perverting the course of justice, and in January 2004, she was given a nine month sentence.


April 26, 2003: Professional footballer Lee Trundle is arrested by Merseyside Police on suspicion of rape. The next month the allegation is withdrawn. Seven years later, Trundle told Wales Online the full story of his near miss with this obsessive femme fatale.


May 3, 2003: Dar Heatherington disappears in Great Falls, Montana. Click here for more.


May 4, 2003: This short article about a rape crisis centre in the Irish Republic, is a hoot. They appear to be implying that women lie about rape. Shame on them! Also it begs the question, how many ostensibly genuine calls are in fact not genuine?


May 10, 2003: Justin Sullivan has sex with an obsessive woman in Coventry; she accuses him and four others of gang-raping her. The case comes to trial at Birmingham Crown Court in November the same year when all are acquitted.

I found another alleged gang-rape in Coventry reported by the same newspaper, but although that too resulted in the acquittal of all defendants, there was not enough information for me to assess. There is no doubt though that all the acquittals were warranted in this case.


May 15, 2003: This is the date of a judgment concerning an unnamed patient detained at the Royal Ottawa Hospital, Ontario. If you’re about to ask who does she claim raped her, the answer is everyone, including you if she learns of your existence. This is a woman who would have at one time been branded a lunatic, and since I’ve never been fond of euphemisms, that is what I will call her.


May 31, 2003: Teenage half-wit Laura Harris tells police she was raped the previous night. In front of 20 people! Commendably, the police carried out a thorough investigation in spite of the incredible nature of the allegation. The bottom line was that she had got into a fight with another girl, and came off worse. She’d also had a lot to drink. When she appeared before magistrates at Chippenham, they took pity on her; she was given a conditional discharge and a fine.


June 2003: Adam Jones has sex with a disabled woman, who accuses him of rape. After spending over six months in custody, the charges againsts him are dropped before the start of his trial at Warwick Crown Court. Notice the way though that the linked article refers to this woman as the victm; who was the real victim here?


June 2003: The case of Roland Chretien III gives us three false rape allegations for the price of one. In June 2003, “Chris” Chretien of Haverhill, Massachusetts, has a consensual sexual encounter with a woman of his own age. She accuses him of oral rape. In January 2005, he is convicted and given a sentence of from 6 to 12 years.

At his sentencing hearing, one of his sisters Sheila Gawrys claims he had raped her repeatedly between the ages of 8 and 11. It is possible she believed this because she had been in therapy. Her family did not believe her. Chretien’s anonymous accuser asked for the maximum sentence. She said she must now take medication for anxiety and post-traumatic stress disorder, is scared of unfamiliar males and simply going outside her house alone.

“Before the rape I was not any of those things. I trusted people unless they gave a reason not to...It’s a horrible feeling to be so afraid.”

Chretien appears to have made a big mistake by denying he had sex with her at all, but she had kept a tissue with his...ugh. Again, don’t do this guys, not with women you don’t know.

Fortunately for Chretien, this psychopath went to on accuse another man, Peter Hallinan, of the same offence under strikingly similar circumstances. Read all abaht it here.

Chretien’s name was added to The National Registry of EXONERATIONS.


June 2, 2003: In Thailand, a woman from Hong Kong claims to have been gang-raped by four men including a tuk-tuk driver. She was allegedly sodomised and robbed as well, but a swift and thorough investigation soon exposed her lies. None of this feminist nonsense in Bangkok where they